Jordan Smith Commits to Arkansas

theKybluedude

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
634
1,456
93
i think that argument is flawed for a couple reasons

1. uconn has dan hurley as their coach,
who is one of the best in the last couple decades
2. weve seen time and time again that coaches work with certain players well, popes gone the older less talented route for 2 years and it hasnt been pretty
No disrespect meant but Hurley was 16-17 and 19-12 in his first 2 years at U Conn. Didn’t make the tourney. Then 15-8, 23-10 and in his 5th year a title at 31-8. Took him 5 years. Won it in 2023.

Was a superb 113-82 in his 6 years prior 2012-2018 at Rhode Island. Yep Hurleys been “one of the best in the last couple decades”. Is that still multiple 10 year periods? 20 years?
Did you know that before you wrote?

But yeah CMP needs to win that title in his first 2 years after inheriting zero players and battling injuries to show he’s a good coach. That correct? Only got to the Sweet 16 in his first year. Jesus man. I swear some fans.

UK fan?
 
Last edited:

TomTraubertsBlues

All-American
Oct 13, 2014
4,891
8,204
113
How long can the current recruiting situation continue before there is no choice but to make a change? Pope is a really good coach, but not a great one. He might even be able to win a title in the right circumstances. But it seems we are far from those circumstances. You need shooters in his system. Getting a Brea is fine, but one of those isn't enough.

IMO, Pope needs to get stud PGs and wing shooters from recruiting, and pick up a few role players in the portal. But how do we get there? Something is seriously broken with recruiting. Not a single player at this point? Not one? How is that even possible at Kentucky?
 

Tim0808

All-Conference
Apr 4, 2013
699
1,120
93
He was headed to Duke if Rip didn’t go there. It was always Arkansas or Duke. He’s an NBA fast track guy, Pope’s system isn’t landing those because he’s made it clear that’s not what we’re doing here. Calipari has a lot of fire power to use against Kentucky. “They don’t want NBA guys anymore it’s why I’m not there”. This is going to be used over and over.

The one good thing here is Calipari hasn’t got a chance in hell at winning a championship with his system. He’s got 2 years left and he’s out. Nothing he does is cutting down nets at Arkansas. Most freshman classes of late don’t have the caliber of player to get it done and Calipari gets what Duke doesn’t want. You’re not winning with that. Duke is Nike #1, not Calipari. It’s why he had to go his system cannot win championships unless Nike decides he is their choice and he’s not. Bad floor coaching and Dukes 2nd and 3rd choices + young team = not a chance in hell at a title.
Cal may not win another championship. However, he has taken 3 different programs to the final four. It takes a lot of luck to win the championship. Ask Dean Smith. It took Georgetown throwing the ball to them at the end of the game for Dean Smith to win the championship with some of the greatest players to ever win a game. JORDAN, WORTHY, PERKINS

Cal will get his players. Kentucky help build that reputation and he is going to benefit for it. We now have to find our path and rebuild our reputation by putting some players in the league if when want top level high school talent.
 

paulcalhoun_rivals397471

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2024
1,588
4,319
113
It’s not that Pope is telling them no, and he is recruiting them, but Pope’s system is not designed for a freshman fast track NBA guy. He’s recruiting for a system, it’s one of the things that hurting him with those guys. Selling 20 minutes per game and the program itself is not what you’d normally see from a coach trying to land elite freshman talent.

Calipari landed them because he sells NBA and the ball in your hands. That’s how he gets these guys. That’s not what we do here. Then removing their pictures from the practice facility, being billed as brought in to stop the NBA Calipari era….

Not that I think he necessarily did wrong. Pope is selling to the fans desires, and although I do think he’s mismanaged it to some degree, he only put the posters in another place. But when the headlines read “pope removes NBA players from practice facility” and guys like calipari are definitely saying Kentucky doesn’t want the NBA guys, all in all, I’m not surprised it’s gone south with those players. We need moderation on all fronts.
Last season Oweh, Brea, Williams, Robinson, Butler, and Carr all averaged over 20 minutes per game. This season so far Oweh, Aberdeen, Chandler, Moreno, and Dioubate are averaging over 20 mpg. This is a stupid and inaccurate mantra. If a standout freshman commits here his chances of averaging over 20 minutes a game is pretty well a given.
 

gonefishin

Senior
Jul 7, 2025
252
763
93
If I could quote the legendary Col Angus…
Just fu**ing win. To do that you have to have talent. Young or older, I don’t give a fu**…just WIN. He isn’t doing that at the level required of a UK coach. He has good stretches followed by mini stretches of head scratching horrible play (mostly led by the team showing really bad effort), and he has zero HS recruits he will bring in next year that will make a splash. He had two top players knocking in the door and it didn’t get done. I don’t give a damn if you want to blame pope or JMI but something needs to change.
My fear is that his corniness combined with the negative recruiting against him
Will prevent him from getting any top talent.
It’s not confusing, just win damn it, at the level we expect here. Be in the top 10 consistently with a chance in March. It’s not rocket science.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TFCat11

UKBB4Ever

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
1,749
3,049
113
What are his methods?

I think he’s doing a great job with fr Moreno. Chandler’s improving. Kam W was starting to perk. Oweh’s up for POY honors. Aberdeens better. Johnson will improve as he gets stronger. Hell I think all of his guys last year are playing professionally. Amari Williams had no shot and he’s with the Celtics.
He’s proving to be a good coach in development.
I’m surprised you aren’t aware.
I’m very aware. As is everyone with eyes open.

If what you say is true then why aren’t recruits flocking to Pope?

There is some awareness missing. But it’s not on my end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TFCat11

UKBB4Ever

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
1,749
3,049
113
I keep seeing JMI get blamed for basketball recruiting but football recruiting seems to be on the fast track, I guess I just don’t understand the difference.
JMI being a problem is nothing but Matt jones propaganda.

Pope has a blank checkbook.

The problem is simply the coaching staff.

The Matt Jones minions will cry about JMI until JMI until the next coach comes in and recruits like mad with JMI still in place.

I don’t know they will try to explain that away but they will find a way.
 

mhs1964

Junior
Feb 8, 2018
299
317
58
We’re still in extremes. How about some nuance. We want players to at least want to be here and respect the tradition, but we also want NBA Caliber players. “Succeed and proceed” was applauded. The issue became when Calipari stated “great night in UK history”, “I’m not here to win for the program”, “calipari doesn’t give a sht about winning basketball games” and allowed Duke to sell the program and laughed at the idea? That’s a problem.

Dan Issel played for the name and had a great NBA Career. Michael Jordan played for the name on the front and had a great NBA career. Guy cried during a UNC game and he’s the greatest NBA player of all time. The idea that it cannot be both was ONLY seen when Calipari did it. Pitino guys played for the name and had great careers. They love this place. Calipari is a divide and conquer personality type. Nobody, ever, said they no longer want elite talent. We want what everyone else has done in this sport since the beginning. Respect the institution and the tradition, and to represent us in the pros. This constant attack on anyone who points out Pope’s failures and misrepresent the facts aren’t going to get very far. It is squarely on Pope and potentially Barnhart that we aren’t getting these guys. Fans have nothing to do with it.
You are correct that Cal was a divide but correlation does not equal correlation. In Issel’s day virtually no one went pro until their eligibility expired. Even with Pitino Mash stayed for three years. Cal seized the desire of many to forgo college or minimize the college experience. I don’t believe the previous era of loyalty and love of the institution will ever exist again in the NIL and Portal age. Any iota of loyalty will be for the coach 98% of the time. We have seen what freshmen can do in the tournament when pressure hits just like the ice skater did yesterday in his first Olympics. Most on this board blame the coach for this kind of meltdown but there are some that will rise to the occasion. You may never know who will or won’t until they are placed in the pressure cooker.
 

Monday Nitro

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
4,044
6,886
112
a bald man in a red uniform with a star trek logo on his chest .
 

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
50,486
70,688
113
i think that argument is flawed for a couple reasons

1. uconn has dan hurley as their coach,
who is one of the best in the last couple decades
2. weve seen time and time again that coaches work with certain players well, popes gone the older less talented route for 2 years and it hasnt been pretty
Up until Hurley won his first title, he wasn't very good at all and heck, wasn't UConn an 8 seed last year? Had 11 losses.
Hurley's first season at UConn, he went 16-17, no post season tournament.
2nd season, he went 19-12. Mind you, UConn played in the AAC back then, that conference wasn’t exactly 2025 SEC caliber.
Year 3 was better, only 8 losses, but lost in the first round.
Year 4, lost 10 games and again, lost in the first round.
It’s very possible Hurley caught lightning in a bottle those 2 years. Scott Drew did the same thing in 21 and 22, now look at him.
I don't know if Pope will ever win a title, but Pope's first 2 seasons at UK, are going a heck of a lot better than Hurley's first 2 seasons at UConn did.
 

Monday Nitro

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
4,044
6,886
112
Up until Hurley won his first title, he wasn't very good at all and heck, wasn't UConn an 8 seed last year? Had 11 losses.
Hurley's first season at UConn, he went 16-17, no post season tournament.
2nd season, he went 19-12. Mind you, UConn played in the AAC back then, that conference wasn’t exactly 2025 SEC caliber.
Year 3 was better, only 8 losses, but lost in the first round.
Year 4, lost 10 games and again, lost in the first round.
It’s very possible Hurley caught lightning in a bottle those 2 years. Scott Drew did the same thing in 21 and 22, now look at him.
I don't know if Pope will ever win a title, but Pope's first 2 seasons at UK, are going a heck of a lot better than Hurley's first 2 seasons at UConn did.

Same nonsense, different day. All the incessant "Pope isn't good enough" people would have fired Hurley after year 2 (by their very own definition of failing) at Ucon and his success wouldn't have happened. These people just love hearing themselves talk. Armchair QB's know it all. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

Anon1759768907

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2025
2,282
3,691
113
Same nonsense, different day. All the incessant "Pope isn't good enough" people would have fired Hurley after year 2 (by their very own definition of failing) at UCONN and his success wouldn't have happened. These people just love hearing themselves talk. Armchair QB's know it all. :rolleyes:
i think when a coach goes back to back you can throw previous results out the window
 

UKCowboys

All-American
Oct 14, 2019
3,337
5,648
113
No disrespect meant but Hurley was 16-17 and 19-12 in his first 2 years at U Conn. Didn’t make the tourney. Then 15-8, 23-10 and in his 5th year a title at 31-8. Took him 5 years. Won it in 2023.

Was a superb 113-82 in his 6 years prior 2012-2018 at Rhode Island. Yep Hurleys been “one of the best in the last couple decades”. Is that still multiple 10 year periods? 20 years?
Did you know that before you wrote?

But yeah CMP needs to win that title in his first 2 years after inheriting zero players and battling injuries to show he’s a good coach. That correct? Only got to the Sweet 16 in his first year. Jesus man. I swear some fans.

UK fan?
This post is of course, based in truth, which makes the commented on post look even more absurd than it did before
 
  • Like
Reactions: theKybluedude

HipTer

Senior
Apr 11, 2012
968
663
93
How long can the current recruiting situation continue before there is no choice but to make a change? Pope is a really good coach, but not a great one. He might even be able to win a title in the right circumstances. But it seems we are far from those circumstances. You need shooters in his system. Getting a Brea is fine, but one of those isn't enough.

IMO, Pope needs to get stud PGs and wing shooters from recruiting, and pick up a few role players in the portal. But how do we get there? Something is seriously broken with recruiting. Not a single player at this point? Not one? How is that even possible at Kentucky?
If you look at the composition of teams that win titles and get to Final Fours in the portal era (and even before) doesn’t it suggest that your roster construction method should be flipped? And instead get stud PGs and wing shooters from the portal, and maybe pick up a “talented” OAD role player in high school recruiting.
 

mdluk1

All-Conference
Oct 28, 2007
889
4,114
93
Last season Oweh, Brea, Williams, Robinson, Butler, and Carr all averaged over 20 minutes per game. This season so far Oweh, Aberdeen, Chandler, Moreno, and Dioubate are averaging over 20 mpg. This is a stupid and inaccurate mantra. If a standout freshman commits here his chances of averaging over 20 minutes a game is pretty well a given.
Yeah, the 20 minutes a game crap is dumb. Moreno is a freshman and gets all the pt he can handle. JJ doesn’t get as much because he hasn’t earned it, although he has been playing more and better of late. Oweh and Aberdeen get all the minutes they want. If Stokes can’t see he would get all of the Oweh’s minutes he wants, he’s blind. PT will not be the reason if he doesn’t pick UK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: davtay and kyjeff1

Son_Of_Saul

Heisman
Dec 7, 2007
45,135
98,011
113
Never in my life would I ever foresee large portions of the fan base simp for a coach who's started out his UK career 41-19 with no top ten recruits committed in two cycles.

Pope cannot relate to elite recruits. He needs to fix that by next fall and demonstrate it with actual elite commitments, otherwise he won't make it here.

If you cannot recruit at UK, you should not be at UK.
 

Dexterdru71

Senior
Aug 11, 2010
188
426
63
I was burned out on HS recruiting the last few years under Cal. Mainly because all of our focus was there, and the guys that we were getting later on, weren’t as good as the players that he was getting early on. Got tired of the endless hype.
Fast forward to the Pope era, and I was fine with the retention and portal approach. This year changed my tune on that somewhat. This freshman class has so many elite, difference making freshman in it, that you have to throw a bag at the elite ones, retain some of your roster and fill the rest with key portal pieces.
Every freshman class is different obviously, but we have to become more than a hat on the table of the elite ones. We need a GM in the worst way I believe to achieve this.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
38,854
60,891
113
When Cal left I vowed to not worry one bit about HS recruiting anymore. Because what had it really gotten us the past 10 years? I’m gonna stick to that, until Pope starts missing big on the portal. Then I’ll get pretty worried.

He kind of is missing big in the portal, though. We got turned down by a lot of the elite transfers.

Kentucky got just ONE top35 guy, and that was JQ, who i think we are all realizing got a huge offer from UK when a lot of other teams maybe didnt pursue him all that hard due to injury.

You are not going to win final fours if you cant get a top25 recruit OR a top25 transfer. Forget about our transfer class ranking, because Kentucky is always going to be able to fill the roster with 3 and 4* players.. but we have got to find a way to get a few high end guys or Pope just isnt going to work.
 

TigerMoving

Heisman
Jul 13, 2014
7,900
21,863
113
Is next year's class elite like this year? Im still all in on portal over high school recruits. Maybe I'll be proven wrong in March but I still think it will be the upperclassman leading their team to the title like usual. Ament is amazing and Tennessee is having their worst season in years. Maybe the top 5 guys but after that it's really a crapshoot. Stokes kid sounds like another potentially massive headache instead of a savior. Michigan, Iowa St, UConn, Nebraska, Mich St, Gonzaga, Purdue and Florida all built title contenders without relying on freshman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: davtay and kyjeff1

UKWildcats1987

Heisman
Sep 9, 2021
19,669
34,292
113
Is next year's class elite like this year? Im still all in on portal over high school recruits. Maybe I'll be proven wrong in March but I still think it will be the upperclassman leading their team to the title like usual. Ament is amazing and Tennessee is having their worst season in years. Maybe the top 5 guys but after that it's really a crapshoot. Stokes kid sounds like another potentially massive headache instead of a savior. Michigan, Iowa St, UConn, Nebraska, Mich St, Gonzaga, Purdue and Florida all built title contenders without relying on freshman.

Then we have to start recruiting better n the portal. Not getting it done there either to compete for a title.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

Skyguyb27

All-American
Feb 12, 2008
4,654
7,736
113
It’s not that Pope is telling them no, and he is recruiting them, but Pope’s system is not designed for a freshman fast track NBA guy. He’s recruiting for a system, it’s one of the things that hurting him with those guys. Selling 20 minutes per game and the program itself is not what you’d normally see from a coach trying to land elite freshman talent.

Calipari landed them because he sells NBA and the ball in your hands. That’s how he gets these guys. That’s not what we do here. Then removing their pictures from the practice facility, being billed as brought in to stop the NBA Calipari era….

Not that I think he necessarily did wrong. Pope is selling to the fans desires, and although I do think he’s mismanaged it to some degree, he only put the posters in another place. But when the headlines read “pope removes NBA players from practice facility” and guys like calipari are definitely saying Kentucky doesn’t want the NBA guys, all in all, I’m not surprised it’s gone south with those players. We need moderation on all fronts.
Riddle me this Batman, why does Pope recruit 5th year seniors if he wants system guys?
 

UKGrad24

All-American
Apr 2, 2024
2,814
6,791
100
No disrespect meant but Hurley was 16-17 and 19-12 in his first 2 years at U Conn. Didn’t make the tourney. Then 15-8, 23-10 and in his 5th year a title at 31-8. Took him 5 years. Won it in 2023.

Was a superb 113-82 in his 6 years prior 2012-2018 at Rhode Island. Yep Hurleys been “one of the best in the last couple decades”. Is that still multiple 10 year periods? 20 years?
Did you know that before you wrote?

But yeah CMP needs to win that title in his first 2 years after inheriting zero players and battling injuries to show he’s a good coach. That correct? Only got to the Sweet 16 in his first year. Jesus man. I swear some fans.

UK fan?

I get it seems too good to pass up, but Kentucky isn’t hiring coaches 5 year and waking to see if a crappy coach has a miracle. Also, again, the was BEFORE the NIL era. Since the NIL era, he hasn’t skipped a beat. That’s all pre NIL era.

“Let’s all suck for 5 years because that’s what Hurley did before the NIL and somehow won championships” no.That’s not happening here and it doesn’t make sense anyway.

What about the hundreds of average / below average guys who remain average / below average and never improve?
 
Last edited:

UKGrad24

All-American
Apr 2, 2024
2,814
6,791
100
Last season Oweh, Brea, Williams, Robinson, Butler, and Carr all averaged over 20 minutes per game. This season so far Oweh, Aberdeen, Chandler, Moreno, and Dioubate are averaging over 20 mpg. This is a stupid and inaccurate mantra. If a standout freshman commits here his chances of averaging over 20 minutes a game is pretty well a given.
Popes beginning vision from this team and what he was selling vs. where we are today is hot even remotely the same thing. He was selling something totally different before the season started.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

UKGrad24

All-American
Apr 2, 2024
2,814
6,791
100
JMI being a problem is nothing but Matt jones propaganda.

Pope has a blank checkbook.

The problem is simply the coaching staff.

The Matt Jones minions will cry about JMI until JMI until the next coach comes in and recruits like mad with JMI still in place.

I don’t know they will try to explain that away but they will find a way.
Barnhart and Pope and 22 mil is a story all in and of itself. Just telling everyone, it’s one of the reasons I want a change as fast as we can get on all fronts. Now that’s just my personal hope based off of what I’ve heard and believe it 100%. If Barnhart and those guys are in control of Mark you aren’t winning anything unless you get lucky.
 

TigerMoving

Heisman
Jul 13, 2014
7,900
21,863
113
Then we have to start recruiting better n the portal. Not getting it done there either to compete for a title.
Yeah definitely agree. We shoulda paid whatever it took to get Yaxel instead of Michigan. Get Yaxel instead of wasting money on JQ, BG, etc and we are probably top 10.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mossip

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
50,486
70,688
113
i think when a coach goes back to back you can throw previous results out the window
Would you say the same thing about Scott Drew? He had the best team in 2020 and won it all in 21. He’s a sh*t coach, he just caught lightning in a bottle.

Hurley did a great job in 23 and 24, but the players on those teams had as much, or more to do with those titles as Hurley did.

Then, Hurley followed those titles up with an 11 loss season and a 2nd round exit.

But, for this excersize, we are talking about Pope in year 2. Why would we compare Pope in year 2, to Hurley in years 7 and 8 at UConn?

In my mind, it's fair to compare resume's from the beginning. Pope was at Utah State and BYU, then UK and Hurley stunk at Rhode Island and he stunk his first 2 years at UConn, that's not going to go away just because he had 2 great years.

We all understand it, this season is not acceptable, but Pope, through injuries, has turned this thing around and we should give him credit.

Take 3 starters off any team and they don't usually win 8 of 9 in a power conference. That's a heck of an accomishment, there aren't many coaches that can do this.

Last point, Pope didn’t have the resume for this job, he shouldn't have been hired, but he’s getting a 3rd year, whether we like it or not. Yes, there are red flags, but there are a lot of blue flags too and to me, the fact that Pope will put UK first, work harder than anyone else and has and intelligent basketball mind, is good enough for me at this point in time.

Lose 10+ games next year, the Pope experiment probably needs to end.
 

Padsfs07

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2013
3,566
3,266
108
He kind of is missing big in the portal, though. We got turned down by a lot of the elite transfers.

Kentucky got just ONE top35 guy, and that was JQ, who i think we are all realizing got a huge offer from UK when a lot of other teams maybe didnt pursue him all that hard due to injury.

You are not going to win final fours if you cant get a top25 recruit OR a top25 transfer. Forget about our transfer class ranking, because Kentucky is always going to be able to fill the roster with 3 and 4* players.. but we have got to find a way to get a few high end guys or Pope just isnt going to work.


Quaintance was #2 to Lendeborg's #1 ranking. It certainly sucks that he will end up being hurt all year, but we did get the #2 player in the portal. (Or JQ was #10th per 247)

From Quaintance to the top 25, the portal is also hit or miss with players:

#3 is Cluff of Purdue, role player. Also, Wooley, Dent, Ian Jackson, Fland, Thiam, Freeman, Dix, McKneely, Bailey, Folguieras, Watts, Yates, Murphy, Sason, Lee~ all role players.

Stirtz, Haggerty, D Williams, Gillespie, Wright, Reneau, Conwell, Hall, Stojakovic, Demary, Nick Boyd, Hopkins, Wilkerson, D Thomas, Baker-Mazara, Veesaar ~ Stars.

Essentially, Louisville might be smart by getting 2-3 of the top guys. One will work out. One will be a role player.
 

Anon1759768907

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2025
2,282
3,691
113
Would you say the same thing about Scott Drew? He had the best team in 2020 and won it all in 21. He’s a sh*t coach, he just caught lightning in a bottle.

Hurley did a great job in 23 and 24, but the players on those teams had as much, or more to do with those titles as Hurley did.

Then, Hurley followed those titles up with an 11 loss season and a 2nd round exit.

But, for this excersize, we are talking about Pope in year 2. Why would we compare Pope in year 2, to Hurley in years 7 and 8 at UConn?

In my mind, it's fair to compare resume's from the beginning. Pope was at Utah State and BYU, then UK and Hurley stunk at Rhode Island and he stunk his first 2 years at UConn, that's not going to go away just because he had 2 great years.

We all understand it, this season is not acceptable, but Pope, through injuries, has turned this thing around and we should give him credit.

Take 3 starters off any team and they don't usually win 8 of 9 in a power conference. That's a heck of an accomishment, there aren't many coaches that can do this.

Last point, Pope didn’t have the resume for this job, he shouldn't have been hired, but he’s getting a 3rd year, whether we like it or not. Yes, there are red flags, but there are a lot of blue flags too and to me, the fact that Pope will put UK first, work harder than anyone else and has and intelligent basketball mind, is good enough for me at this point in time.

Lose 10+ games next year, the Pope experiment probably needs to end.
well no because scott drew hasnt been at the top or near it since the title

uconn has been a legit title contender for a while

to win in this current landscape you have to be an amazing coach or have amazing players