POLL: Should this season be Tom Brands last as HC at Iowa?

Should this season be Tom Brands last as HC at Iowa?


  • Total voters
    750
  • Poll closed .

el dub

All-Conference
Nov 2, 2005
576
1,495
93
So all things considered and largely based on results, following Gable (Zadick included), you believe there has never been a better head coach option for Iowa wrestling than the Brands, which could be practically had, and that continues to be the case today. In part, it's more circumstances beyond their control that are limiting the Brands (circumstances that PSU and Ok St are unfettered by).

Furthermore, you think this will continue to be the case until the Brands decide to retire. That's when the inevitable delayed decision for Iowa' wrestling's next head coach will be forced. Only then will the whiners need to find something new to whine about.

Meanwhile, the whiners are bored AF and looking for something new to whine about sooner rather than be held hostage to boring AF wrestling under Brands until the Brands choose to retire.

It is very easy to look for yourself. It’s not like there are 50,000 votes. There aren’t even 500…as far as the rest goes, they may not be finishing 1st or 2nd every year but EVERY other program but PSU has multiple finishes OUTSIDE the top 10. Iowa’s average finish destroys everyone else.

Yes, OkState is poised to make that much harder. Yes, Brands should have a bunch of pressure on him this season. I have faith his team will show up in March.

After that, the argument has gone back and forth so much, I will simply say it comes down to who really is there to replace him with. I just do NOT see one and those against Brands want him gone so badly they simply believe one will magically appear because the Iowa job guarantees it.
We’re really close to being the best of the rest and that would be top shelf with many programs, like, MSU, for instance…
 

el dub

All-Conference
Nov 2, 2005
576
1,495
93
come on man... you know thats how you sound... I have never seen anyone accept being average more than you have... nothing to feel bad about. you seem really nice.
Keep deflecting with personal attacks. You’ve got this!
 

grasshawk40

All-Conference
Iowa Swarm member
Dec 16, 2022
448
1,006
93
Keep deflecting with personal attacks. You’ve got this!
Deflecting What? Im being serious. Deflecting that our wrestling team is as bad as we have seen it in years?? Enlighten me. "you got this"
 

grasshawk40

All-Conference
Iowa Swarm member
Dec 16, 2022
448
1,006
93
That was for MSU.
Feeling Dumb Jim Carrey GIF
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
965
2,560
93
They would get destroyed..The scrambling is so much higher level it isn't even the same sport. It is true in pretty much every sport and every athlete. Now you could argue (and so would I) that if they were born 35 years later and raised with the same advantages in training and nutrition that these top kids have today they would have been the same stone cold killers that they were back it the olden days.
You can't be serious. I don't think you realize just how good they both were in their prime. They weren't slog around beat you up and win on conditioning in the third period guys. They had incredibly versatile attacks to go along with great strength, conditioning and toughness. You don't win multiple world and Olympic championships (combined) without being elite talents.
My biggest frustration is how little our teams reflect this any more. What we saw from 08-2010 is really what I thought the long term identity of the program would be and for whatever reason(s) it has just slipped away.
Even the other night against Nebraska no one aside from 133, 149, and 165 showed the style that should be defining the entire team.
 

kingstown

All-Conference
Dec 7, 2025
651
2,015
93
You can't be serious. I don't think you realize just how good they both were in their prime. They weren't slog around beat you up and win on conditioning in the third period guys. They had incredibly versatile attacks to go along with great strength, conditioning and toughness. You don't win multiple world and Olympic championships (combined) without being elite talents.
My biggest frustration is how little our teams reflect this any more. What we saw from 08-2010 is really what I thought the long term identity of the program would be and for whatever reason(s) it has just slipped away.
Even the other night against Nebraska no one aside from 133, 149, and 165 showed the style that should be defining the entire team.
I watched them plenty and they were great. I just happen to be of the opinion that guys from 30 years ago dropped into pretty much any sport would not be nearly as effective as the current guys. Sports change quickly. Wrestling today barely resembles the wrestling I watched in the 80s and 90s. I do think if they were exposed to all of the current training methods,nutritional knowledge, and skills that these guys have now they would have had similar success. Athletes at the highest level are faster,stronger, and more skilled than ever imo. I also don't think Babe Ruth would hit as many home runs as other full teams so there is that. I respect your opinion I just simply disagree.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
965
2,560
93
I watched them plenty and they were great. I just happen to be of the opinion that guys from 30 years ago dropped into pretty much any sport would not be nearly as effective as the current guys. Sports change quickly. Wrestling today barely resembles the wrestling I watched in the 80s and 90s. I do think if they were exposed to all of the current training methods,nutritional knowledge, and skills that these guys have now they would have had similar success. Athletes at the highest level are faster,stronger, and more skilled than ever imo. I also don't think Babe Ruth would hit as many home runs as other full teams so there is that. I respect your opinion I just simply disagree.
1769636452463.gif
This man won a title 30 years ago fyi
 
  • Haha
Reactions: kingstown

Random4598375

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2020
599
1,723
93
So Tom’s contract expires in 3 yrs? I admit the loaded 2026 class was a disaster, even though they put a lot of effort and were willing to put a ton of money into it. Had one top 20 and one who isn’t ranked in top 100. But that didn’t discourage several very good 2027 and a few top 2028 guys from committing this fall. If these guys don’t bail on us and they can add at least 2 more top 2028 guys, do you really think Rome will be burning if Tom retires on 3-4 years like Smith did? I’m trying to think of a program that would have an opening for Nolf in the next few years that could keep him away from us, like okyst will keep Taylor away from everyone except PSU if Carl retires.
Nebraska seems like the obvious choice if Manning retires any time soon and they are willing to invest in the RTC side of it.
 

FF141

Junior
Mar 15, 2017
99
217
33
I watched them plenty and they were great. I just happen to be of the opinion that guys from 30 years ago dropped into pretty much any sport would not be nearly as effective as the current guys. Sports change quickly. Wrestling today barely resembles the wrestling I watched in the 80s and 90s. I do think if they were exposed to all of the current training methods,nutritional knowledge, and skills that these guys have now they would have had similar success. Athletes at the highest level are faster,stronger, and more skilled than ever imo. I also don't think Babe Ruth would hit as many home runs as other full teams so there is that. I respect your opinion I just simply disagree.
It’s unfair to compare eras.
 

FF141

Junior
Mar 15, 2017
99
217
33
You can't be serious. I don't think you realize just how good they both were in their prime. They weren't slog around beat you up and win on conditioning in the third period guys. They had incredibly versatile attacks to go along with great strength, conditioning and toughness. You don't win multiple world and Olympic championships (combined) without being elite talents.
My biggest frustration is how little our teams reflect this any more. What we saw from 08-2010 is really what I thought the long term identity of the program would be and for whatever reason(s) it has just slipped away.
Even the other night against Nebraska no one aside from 133, 149, and 165 showed the style that should be defining the entire team.
I think most of this boils down to the type of athlete that’s getting recruited. The more athletic kids they get do just fine. I think they do fine to a certain level with those guys but they just don’t get over the hump. Marinelli for example. They just lagged to far behind in the recruiting curve.
 

Libertylover

All-Conference
Dec 17, 2020
876
1,516
93
I'm not who you asked but to your point there are not many jobs like the Iowa job in wrestling. There is no question that the amount of interest in the head coaching positions at the University of Iowa will have everybody's attention. I would say Cael and DT would be the list of people without interest. It is THE job in many minds I'm guessing. Cael may have an empire that can't be toppled, but Iowa,Oklahoma State,Ohio State, and Michigan would be my best guess on who has a chance to overtake them at some future point. Michigan has the structure but it needs new leadership and I really like Sean Bormet. I think a guy like Nolf could make meatchicken dangerous.
Agree about Michigan. They don’t have our tradition, but they have a big head start on the RTC, which is important to him, and have enough money that they could make it impossible to steal him away.
 

BrianLafevre

Senior
Jun 30, 2025
222
787
93
I still think the answer is no, but if we don’t have 2 new assistant coaches next year then my answer will be yes.
What exactly do you think will change with new assistants? Do you think Tom is the kind of person that will allow someone else tell him how to “run his program?” You do know his staff is composed of his twin and people that do exactly as he wants.
 

HawkeyeHello

Redshirt
Nov 4, 2022
7
44
13
Sorry wrong


This. This alone separates PSU from Iowa in the room. Our guys wrestle scared to give up points. PSU wrestles knowing there is always enough time to score more. Recruiting aside, of course. I hate what PSU has become, but I think I’d almost rather tune in to watch them on TV than Iowa. And that’s painful. I had almost every Iowa dual and IAHSAA state finals broadcast on VHS growing up.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
965
2,560
93
The 191 people who've voted "No" need to detail exactly how TnT are going to lead Iowa to a wrestling championship in the next 4 years (maximum).
 
  • Like
Reactions: LetsGoHawks83

js8793

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2018
204
1,012
93
I can agree the landscape and talent has evolved and TnT have not done well at adapting. But don't agree the 'old style' doesn't work any more. Hell, I'd argue that crazy a$$ Messenbrink is just like TnT on the mat. Guarantee you if we could insert young TnT in this year's tournament, they'd piss pound most or all of the competition. But we seemingly can't even get many 'old style' recruits who can dominate like they did, let alone consistently enough of the high end 'new style' recruits.
This is a common misconception about what the “old style” was. You break people by scoring points. The old Iowa wrestlers knew how to attack and finish within the context of the sport at that time. Scrambling changed the game and TNT refused to change with it. Mesenbrink can attack mercilessly like an “old school” Iowa wrestler because he has no fear of being out-scrambled because he knows how to scramble himself!

PSU guys see scrambles as opportunities to score huge points. Iowa views them as dangerous situations to be avoided. That is reflected in the product on the mat.
 

Trapper85

Senior
Jun 22, 2020
178
640
93
This is a common misconception about what the “old style” was. You break people by scoring points. The old Iowa wrestlers knew how to attack and finish within the context of the sport at that time. Scrambling changed the game and TNT refused to change with it. Mesenbrink can attack mercilessly like an “old school” Iowa wrestler because he has no fear of being out-scrambled because he knows how to scramble himself!

PSU guys see scrambles as opportunities to score huge points. Iowa views them as dangerous situations to be avoided. That is reflected in the product on the mat.
I can generally agree with this. But plenty of guys who aren't funky scramblers still win titles (at least that's what my memory tells me). And well above 83% of current wrestlers are not elite scramblers. Finally, I consider aggressive chain wrestling, regardless of funkiness, to be scrambling. TnT might not dominate everbody today and win 4 titles, but I stand by my belief they would piss pound most of the competition today. But alas, we don't even have 'TnT type scramblers' on the team. And this is a totally separate question from whether they should remain our coaches.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
965
2,560
93
This is a common misconception about what the “old style” was. You break people by scoring points. The old Iowa wrestlers knew how to attack and finish within the context of the sport at that time. Scrambling changed the game and TNT refused to change with it. Mesenbrink can attack mercilessly like an “old school” Iowa wrestler because he has no fear of being out-scrambled because he knows how to scramble himself!

PSU guys see scrambles as opportunities to score huge points. Iowa views them as dangerous situations to be avoided. That is reflected in the product on the mat.
Scrambling is a big part of it but I don't think you can overlook strength and conditioning. Messenbrink also knows he's stronger and in better shape than everyone else so he's not afraid to be in about any position or risk getting behind early. We used to have guys like that. That used to be the strength of our program. Not anymore.
 

Reiterate

Senior
Dec 27, 2016
348
466
63
I can generally agree with this. But plenty of guys who aren't funky scramblers still win titles (at least that's what my memory tells me). And well above 83% of current wrestlers are not elite scramblers. Finally, I consider aggressive chain wrestling, regardless of funkiness, to be scrambling. TnT might not dominate everbody today and win 4 titles, but I stand by my belief they would piss pound most of the competition today. But alas, we don't even have 'TnT type scramblers' on the team. And this is a totally separate question from whether they should remain our coaches.
I remember when Nelson was wrestling in high school. I didn't see any matches but read on HR how he lacked technique but was relentless. Then he came here.... Tony Nelson 2.0 that's on Starr, imo. And tnt. The writing was on the wall.

I feel bad for Ayala, he needed someone to wrestle with. The night they let superman make him look bad told me the coaches no longer had the mental capacity to lead. Superman should of been able to heal but, I suspect, was talked out of it. It seems to have been detrimental to his post college career.

After Bassett left I said Angelo would go to Nebraska. I suspect DeLuca is going to decomit.

Buying mercs just causes room problems with unspoken resent.

Better get Nolf.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stick Kitty

86_90

Redshirt
Jan 4, 2010
9
22
1
He wouldn't be effective in todays game. He could likely stir up a recruiting class though off name alone. Would you hand Belichick an NFL head coaching job again or has that passed? It took awhile but we realized might have been more about Tom Brady. I think we need to accept Brands had two perfect storms- The double recruiting class which he inherited quite a bit by Z and the Iowa brand name- and the Spencer/ YG storm help by Strittmater which rebuilt the program for a short period. But take away those 2 storms and what you see is the reality. A lot of underacheiving.

To piggyback on the Iowa fans wanting it to be the perfect choice like Taylor in order to come to grips with where Brands is at..I say look no further than Vrabel in New England. He couldn't do anything with the Titans but now he is a great head coach in the right environment.

The Iowa brand makes Brands more than he makes the program. I would stop underestimating what a great coach who is at a lesser program could do if he was given a top job.

Do you really think Brands could go to Illinois or say Oklahoma and he would consistently beat Iowa and whomever replaces him at the helm?
Having witnessed the rise and fall of Brands and Company, it's time. Now is the time they step away from the program. Their strengths as coaches no longer can compensate for their deficiencies. Great, loyal, hard working guys who are no longer are a NET PLUS for the program.
 

86_90

Redshirt
Jan 4, 2010
9
22
1
Sometimes it needs to get worse to get better. I love TnT but I love Hawks wrestling more. We've looked flat for a few years now...change is needed.
Brands and Company are fully entrenched. The next coach doesn't need to the Final Answer, rather a necessary solution to end the current slow death that is Brands and Company.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nashville_Hawk

blcoach80

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2018
306
1,592
93
Am I the only one who sees one of this team's biggest issues is between their ears? Listen to Drake's interview last night. 141 and 157 are head cases so far. For some reason Gabe, Angelo, and Ben refuse to be offensive against good competition. It isn't an ability issue and Tom is right, we do have the right guys (at most weights when we wrestle starters) in the room. Tom is not reaching these guys mentally if they aren't wired already like he and Terry were/are. Who is the team psychologist?! That is the part of the current staff that is failing as much as anyone right now imo. All the technique in the world won't help you if you have a mental block to not shoot. All 6 losses last night had zero takedowns. Awful tough to win matches that way.