Basketball Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 7 Michigan State in OT heartbreaker

RAC93

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2023
2,965
4,890
113
ok - but his game plan for the first 59 minutes kept us in the game.

yes - it was a talent issues. We had an ideal chance to win at the buzzer - an east floater and we couldn’t convert. We couldn’t hit key FTs down the stretch.
But the end of game stuff is really, really important and it never has been a strong suit of Pike’s or late game execution of his RU teams.
 

RU MAN

Heisman
Oct 29, 2001
23,607
10,192
113
If they call the clear Fears push in the back for #5, we win.

Man.
Yes and no. Yes, Frears should have been called for that. No, because even though JaMichael missed the first FT and made the second, you have to guard the inbound passer and press up, denying them any leeway to get the ball up the court quickly. Even if they do, you foul immediately. Put the onus on them to make the first FT and decide to shoot the second FT or clang it off the basket to get the rebound and tie the game.
 

RU MAN

Heisman
Oct 29, 2001
23,607
10,192
113
If you pay any attention on the board I’ve advocated for him to be gone 85% of the time

my point was really a jab at the apologists who want to come on and say he’s doing great after a win but in my mind they looked better today than any of their 9 wins

that’s all… my stance remains he should be gone if they can’t get to 7 big ten wins which I don’t think they will
Understand. And I agree with you. Personally, after tonight's heartbreaking loss, we will be lucky to win 3 more games in the B1G.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,220
17,902
97
But the end of game stuff is really, really important and it never has been a strong suit of Pike’s or late game execution of his RU teams.

so is this first 59 minutes. Very very important as well
 

Ridge 22

Heisman
Jun 30, 2007
7,696
10,035
98
We lost because we couldn’t make the key FT down the stretch. We missed the key basket at the buzzer and couldn’t buy a bucket in OT. Our lack of talent is why we lost.

pike is a helluva coach, we just need better players. And sure, that’s on pike. But you can’t question his coaching after years and years of these huge upsets
Unfortunately for Pike, our lack of talent is on him and a big part of his job description. It's not like someone just handed him this roster and said go coach them. He picked these guys. And he gets judged on all of it, not just the aspects that you like and ignore the rest. And as far as his coaching, I have a hard time considering Pike a coaching genius when he literally ignores coaching offense, which is 50% of the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUChet

RexMantlepiece

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2008
832
1,866
61
This is not a game to get on Pike. Game plan was solid, plenty of coaches wouldn’t foul with more than 10 seconds up by three, and you don’t think the kids effort had something to do with Pike challenging/motivating them after the Indiana effort? I mean according to many in the board we have zero real big ten starters and yet this group have enough effort to play MSU in OT.
 

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
33,638
38,120
113
ok - but his game plan for the first 59 minutes kept us in the game.

yes - it was a talent issues. We had an ideal chance to win at the buzzer - an east floater and we couldn’t convert. We couldn’t hit key FTs down the stretch.

Arguably the least talented team in the B1G and we took 7 to OT and nearly beat Iowa on the road.

It sucks, but this is not the EJ era.
 

RUJMM78

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
26,187
12,443
113
Bottom line this game is just another bad loss..Rutgers dominated the game until crunch time where missed foul shots and poor guarding on the inbound pass allowed Michgan State to make a open 3 pointer to tie the score .In OT Michigan State suoerior talent came forth while Rutgers shot bricks.This could have been another game where Rutgers found a way to upset a highly ranked teram. and the fanss tormed the court.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,220
17,902
97
Unfortunately for Pike, our lack of talent is on him and a big part of his job description. It's not like someone just handed him this roster and said go coach them. He picked these guys. And he gets judged on all of it, not just the aspects that you like and ignore the rest. And as far as his coaching, I have a hard time considering Pike a coaching genius when he literally ignores coaching offense, which is 50% of the game.

1000%, but it was not in his original job description. I’ve heard he absolutely hates NIL and the state of college basketball. So fielding a team based on $$$$ was absolutely not in his job description.

And sure - if he hates the state of the sport - maybe he should resign. But to question his coaching ability is nonsense.
 

bethlehemfan

Heisman
Sep 6, 2003
15,098
16,376
113
Please. Don't start this kind of crap, pal.
Don’t claim some type of authority based on being a coach. You haven’t coached at pikes level and there’s lots of dopey coaches so it means nothing that you coached. That doesn’t help your argument. Michigan state had 17 seconds left when that possession started. Acting like it some no brainer that you press against I guy like fears is a terrible take.
 

RU MAN

Heisman
Oct 29, 2001
23,607
10,192
113
Don’t claim some type of authority based on being a coach. You haven’t coached at pikes level and there’s lots of dopey coaches so it means nothing that you coached. That doesn’t help your argument. Michigan state had 17 seconds left when that possession started. Acting like it some no brainer that you press against I guy like fears is a terrible take.
You're wrong, of course. But you seem to hunt me down in the past with your contrarian arguments. You're now on ignore.
 

Bob Chaewsky_rivals

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2008
7,401
4,776
113
Sorry but Francis was not good tonight. He shot 6-17!!! He also made a lot of shots very early when the clock is our friend when you are an underdog. He took some bad shots, multiple 3's too far out. So what if he gets 6 in, he missed 11! It's not good basketball and that's on the coaches to fix.
Chet - You know what you're looking at.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUChet

Ridge 22

Heisman
Jun 30, 2007
7,696
10,035
98
1000%, but it was not in his original job description. I’ve heard he absolutely hates NIL and the state of college basketball. So fielding a team based on $$$$ was absolutely not in his job description.

And sure - if he hates the state of the sport - maybe he should resign. But to question his coaching ability is nonsense.
This is a crazy take. I don't know of any high level, high paying job that has anything close to.a set job description. That is just not how it works. You are tasked with broad responsibiliites that you carry out regardless of the environment. You are expected to adapt and manage through change. It sucks for Pike that the rules changed and he isn't a great fit for the NIL era. If he hates NIL, he should quit. He gets no pass for that.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,220
17,902
97
This is a crazy take. I don't know of any high level, high paying job that has anything close to.a set job description. That is just not how it works. You are tasked with broad responsibiliites that you carry out regardless of the environment. You are expected to adapt and manage through change. It sucks for Pike that the rules changed and he isn't a great fit for the NIL era. If he hates NIL, he should quit. He gets no pass for that.

agree.

but to question his coaching ability is silly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUDiddy777

seansherm

Heisman
Feb 20, 2009
13,972
14,901
113
We didn't even guard the inbound passer. Total ********! We should have pressed them. Not let them get an easy inbound pass and then an even easier pass ot an open three point shooter. This endgame was on Pikiell.
We press and they may actually get up the court quicker than they did, they were running right past us by that point. The error was, for the 30th time recently, losing the guy in the corner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUSCFORMERLYRULOU

Fat Koko

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2022
3,545
2,942
73
Agreed, B1G has to reprimand that ref for swallowing the whistle there
College basketball referees are independent contractors. Unlike college football and the NBA, college bball refs are not affiliated with a conference or league.
 

PhillyRU

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
979
1,602
76
In fairness EJ beat #2 Wisconsin
A weirdly impressive start to conference play, looking back at it. Had beaten 12-2 Penn State in the previous home game and had a 57-51 lead over eventual No. 4 seed Maryland with seven minutes left in the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
33,638
38,120
113
In fairness EJ beat #2 Wisconsin

Fair. A great moment for us.

But you know what I mean, in general, this team has been competitive against everyone in the conference except 3 of the top 4/5 and the clunker against IU - despite being the least talented team in the conference.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
247,182
176,828
113
Fair. A great moment for us.

But you know what I mean, in general, this team has been competitive against everyone in the conference except 3 of the top 4/5 and the clunker against IU - despite being the least talented team in the conference.
Its better team than Eddies 3 because they do play hard above their talent level
 

RAC93

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2023
2,965
4,890
113
This is not a game to get on Pike. Game plan was solid, plenty of coaches wouldn’t foul with more than 10 seconds up by three, and you don’t think the kids effort had something to do with Pike challenging/motivating them after the Indiana effort? I mean according to many in the board we have zero real big ten starters and yet this group have enough effort to play MSU in OT.
It’s not about getting on Pike, it’s just acknowledging he executed poor late game strategy. The MSU shooter shot the ball with 12 seconds left, so if there 9 seconds or 10 when he caught it you would be ok with fouling? Makes no sense. It’s ok to foul with 12 or 13 seconds left. And we would have won had we done so.
 

RUDivision

All-Conference
Jan 6, 2023
2,300
1,808
42
This is not a game to get on Pike. Game plan was solid, plenty of coaches wouldn’t foul with more than 10 seconds up by three, and you don’t think the kids effort had something to do with Pike challenging/motivating them after the Indiana effort? I mean according to many in the board we have zero real big ten starters and yet this group have enough effort to play MSU in OT.
100 percent on Pike. If he had any understanding of situational basketball this game never gets close.

He is a HORRIFIC situational coach. How you don’t hunt Fears with 4 fouls with 5 mins to go in the game???

You run pick and roll to have Fears switched on to Francis and let him hunt. It’s either an easy bucket for Francis or Fears could out and the comeback never happens.

Late in game you inbound to Francis not JMike .

Two very simple coaching decisions cost us the game.

Pikes done
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyC80 and RAC93

RexMantlepiece

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2008
832
1,866
61
100 percent on Pike. If he had any understanding of situational basketball this game never gets close.

He is a HORRIFIC situational coach. How you don’t hunt Fears with 4 fouls with 5 mins to go in the game???

You run pick and roll to have Fears switched on to Francis and let him hunt. It’s either an easy bucket for Francis or Fears could out and the comeback never happens.

Late in game you inbound to Francis not JMike .

Two very simple coaching decisions cost us the game.

Pikes done
Figured you would come out… I mean they did lose so you can continue to drum up your Pike’s done mantra. One problem though he actually isn’t done at least not till he gets a chance to see what he can do with decent NIL.
 

RUDivision

All-Conference
Jan 6, 2023
2,300
1,808
42
Figured you would come out… I mean they did lose so you can continue to drum up your Pike’s done mantra. One problem though he actually isn’t done at least not till he gets a chance to see what he can do with decent NIL.
Did he lose this game? I was sitting 2 feet from him begging him to hunt Fears . He lost the game AGAIN!

Dead man walking
 

rsegall

Senior
Jul 28, 2001
457
456
63
We lost because we couldn’t make the key FT down the stretch. We missed the key basket at the buzzer and couldn’t buy a bucket in OT. Our lack of talent is why we lost.

pike is a helluva coach, we just need better players. And sure, that’s on pike. But you can’t question his coaching after years and years of these huge upsets
What exactly has he won? Other than an occasional upset he has won nothing. With 2 first round selections he had a losing record. Never won the BIG.
 

dark_check

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2022
2,601
3,129
113
Figured you would come out… I mean they did lose so you can continue to drum up your Pike’s done mantra. One problem though he actually isn’t done at least not till he gets a chance to see what he can do with decent NIL.
He’s already had two nba lottery picks
 

RAC93

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2023
2,965
4,890
113
He’s won one ncaa tourney game in ten years
It is crazy how much deference gets afforded to both our basketball and football coach. You would think that Nick Saban and Coach K. were here. Pike is a great guy and he’s adequate and competent, but we need dynamic and successful for our head coaches. Time to aim higher, come on now, the guy has had 10 years already. Does he need another 10 years until maybe we can think about being ready to pull the plug? The time has come, we need a change, even if we somehow blew out MSU tonight does not change the fact that the time has come for a change.
 
Feb 5, 2003
10,966
9,365
113
Yes and no. Yes, Frears should have been called for that. No, because even though JaMichael missed the first FT and made the second, you have to guard the inbound passer and press up, denying them any leeway to get the ball up the court quickly. Even if they do, you foul immediately. Put the onus on them to make the first FT and decide to shoot the second FT or clang it off the basket to get the rebound and tie the game.
You are off by one possession. Fears pushed off when they trailed by 3 with 25 seconds left. No basket, we shoot (Grant?). If we hit one FT there, it is a two possession lead with 25 to go and they have no PG.

But that didn't happen. Man.

We could have won in many other ways even with the no call.
 

seansherm

Heisman
Feb 20, 2009
13,972
14,901
113
It’s not about getting on Pike, it’s just acknowledging he executed poor late game strategy. The MSU shooter shot the ball with 12 seconds left, so if there 9 seconds or 10 when he caught it you would be ok with fouling? Makes no sense. It’s ok to foul with 12 or 13 seconds left. And we would have won had we done so.
I wouldn't foul at all, you are up 3, you can't lose. Play D, run the clock, force a tough 3. We didn't get set defensively, that was the mistake.
 

DHajekRC1984

Senior
Jul 20, 2025
1,031
922
113
For starters folks..watching on TV and several replays that was hardly a push on Buchanan. He kinda jumps under the basket for some crazy reason there at the same time Fears had his elbow in his back and yes..used a little pressure. Could they have called it? Of course.. should they have called it? Perhaps. .but it wasn't some aggreges shove.

Another "found a way to lose at the end" game by this coach who again finished regulation with a TO left and just said "wing it" with Francis. Don't understand EO on the bench with 3 fouls end game while fears is owning the lane and we need rebounds. I knew it was coming and I knew once we went OT it was over. Terrible huge missed opportunity for a team that played hard , very hard all game against #7. Coaches can't clap their way to victory, they need to add value, I'm sure the clapping helps motivate the team to play hard but when does this guy figure out the x-o's required to win these things?