Recruiting rankings back then were wildly inaccurate and more of a crap shoot than the modern recruiting rankings. Still not a perfect system but better than it was back then.
""I've never placed a lot of confidence in those rankings," Osborne said.
Thanks to John Talman of Rivals.com, we can get a good read on how analysts regarded Osborne's recruiting classes in the early 1990s — the classes that ultimately helped produce three national championships.
The class of 1990 was ranked 10th by SuperPrep, but only 34th by the National Recruiting Advisor and 41st by Tom Lemming. The class of 1991 was ranked 28th by SuperPrep. However, Osborne did have a top-10 class in 1992 (Tommie Frazier, Toby Wright, Mike Minter, Chris Dishman, et al) — it was ranked fifth by Max Emfinger and 10th by Tom Lemming.
The 1993 class was ranked 18th by SuperPrep, and the 1994 group 22nd by Lemming and 20th by SuperPrep."