Indiana v Oregon

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
1,469
2,499
113
Obviously still have a national championship game and a half to go. But I don’t think it’s hyperbole to discuss where does Indiana fit in/rank as far as the greatest college football team in modern football?
 

2D

All-American
Oct 8, 2013
2,512
5,123
113
Sarrat had no D1 offers. Mendoza only had 2…Yale and Cal. Hemby was a Maryland castoff.

We can do what they’re doing. Hell, we damn near did at Kinnick.
Can we? We've been struggling with a bad Iowa State program for years. We collapsed against USC. Couldn't get over the hump with Oregon. I think there's a clear difference between Iowa and Indiana at this time.

Could we beat Indiana on a neutral field? I'd argue we'd lose by 2-3 touchdowns.

Sure it was p****
Dumbass doesn't even know how to quote correctly lmao
 

Laker3588

Junior
Feb 22, 2006
127
261
63
Sorry I don't know how to quote correctly but at least I ain't stiffen my f****** jock since the last time I put it on in 7th grade
 

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
580
1,527
93
Can we? We've been struggling with a bad Iowa State program for years. We collapsed against USC. Couldn't get over the hump with Oregon. I think there's a clear difference between Iowa and Indiana at this time.

Could we beat Indiana on a neutral field? I'd argue we'd lose by 2-3 touchdowns.


Dumbass doesn't even know how to quote correctly lmao
We couldn’t get over the hump because we lacked play makers at winning time. Maybe Heck is our Mendoza. Maybe Diaz is our Sarrat. We’ll see, but we’re not as far away now as you seem to think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kwik44

SoDakHawk

Senior
Sep 14, 2006
224
413
63
I know this is sarcasm and get it…

Thing is, Kirk did come close to doing this when he took over. Look at his staff….winners. Could make comparisons to Fry’s staff early on.

And Kirk hit the JUCOs a lot back then and got a lot of very good skill players.

Iowa and Kirk used to have an attitude and fire to them in those 2001-2004 years. Little bit of it came back in 2008-2010….but Kirk started going into a shell and recruiting ******* died off on offense

Now, Kirk is so stubborn he believes a 12-9 phone booth fight is THE only way football can be played.

Yes, Iowa hung with IU and OR….Iowa is king of moral victories

gotta win them at some point, but it’s always next year
Stop. Iowa averaged 29 ppg this season. Stop with the "no offense" thing.

Watching these playoffs it is clear that running the ball, playing defense, and just playing straight bully ball wins. That's right in Iowa's wheel house. Need to add a few playmakers is all.
 

Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo

All-Conference
Oct 1, 2001
789
2,230
93
These MFers beat Iowa by five points
The question is this....are we seeing a perfect storm type of situation that will rage for a couple of years before subsiding and eventually regressing to the mean? Or are we witnessing the rise of a new superpower in college football?

Yes, we were competitive with them ON the field this year. Now ask yourself how competitive we are likely to be from this point forward OFF the field. How many recruiting battles do you think we ever lost to Indiana over the last 40 years? How many do you think we'll win from now on?
 

2D

All-American
Oct 8, 2013
2,512
5,123
113
We couldn’t get over the hump because we lacked play makers at winning time. Maybe Heck is our Mendoza. Maybe Diaz is our Sarrat. We’ll see, but we’re not as far away now as you seem to think.
I think that's part of it, yes. Lester has improved our offense too. I think Wetjen is likely the closest comparison to Sarrat. But what I'm concerned about is Iowa's place in the overall hierarchy of the B1G. In fact, I'd be interested in hearing everyone's B1G tier list. It used to be Ohio State and Oregon, followed by PSU, Mich, USC, then Iowa. An elite Indiana only pushes us down further, which means losing out on possible recruiting battles or transfer portal offers.

I've always felt Iowa was close to taking that next step, competing with the likes of PSU and USC for recruits and overall competitiveness. This year solidified my opinion that we're definitively better than our B1G rivals.

Sure buddy go back to your Junior High days of Glory
Ok schizo, keep making up scenarios in your head.
 

Laker3588

Junior
Feb 22, 2006
127
261
63
I think that's part of it, yes. Lester has improved our offense too. I think Wetjen is likely the closest comparison to Sarrat. But what I'm concerned about is Iowa's place in the overall hierarchy of the B1G. In fact, I'd be interested in hearing everyone's B1G tier list. It used to be Ohio State and Oregon, followed by PSU, Mich, USC, then Iowa. An elite Indiana only pushes us down further, which means losing out on possible recruiting battles or transfer portal offers.

I've always felt Iowa was close to taking that next step, competing with the likes of PSU and USC for recruits and overall competitiveness. This year solidified my opinion that we're definitively better than our B1G rivals.


Ok schizo, keep making up scenarios in your head.
Thank you for confirming my suspicions with your response
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 2D

Denmar

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2006
2,002
1,542
113
Mendoza is accurate as hell. I believe that former NFL scout was wrong on his assessment about this guy.
 

HawkBall23

All-American
Oct 6, 2001
4,560
8,629
113
IU just clowning 'em now.

 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkdave007

Herky T Hawk

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
215
501
93
I haven’t been watching much of the game or reading the game thread, but saw that last touchdown. Have they been playing train horn noises every time Indiana scores a touchdown? Someone at the stadium a Purdue fan trying to troll them?
 

HawkBall23

All-American
Oct 6, 2001
4,560
8,629
113
I haven’t been watching much of the game or reading the game thread, but saw that last touchdown. Have they been playing train horn noises every time Indiana scores a touchdown? Someone at the stadium a Purdue fan trying to troll them?
Doing it on all scores, for both teams.
 

Denmar

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2006
2,002
1,542
113
Thought it was okay to hold inside the pads or breastplate. Guess not tonight
 

longliveCS40

All-American
Oct 25, 2002
1,884
6,700
113
The question is this....are we seeing a perfect storm type of situation that will rage for a couple of years before subsiding and eventually regressing to the mean? Or are we witnessing the rise of a new superpower in college football?

Yes, we were competitive with them ON the field this year. Now ask yourself how competitive we are likely to be from this point forward OFF the field. How many recruiting battles do you think we ever lost to Indiana over the last 40 years? How many do you think we'll win from now on?
Depends how much money they get from donors. That's what it takes to have continued success.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo