Honestly, Rosey Baby is the hidden gem of Starkville. As a resident fat guy, the tiers of Starkville restaurants (based on food) are as such:
Tier 1: Camphouse, Rosey Baby, Older Brother, Tyler, Taste
Tier 2: Harvey's, The Grill, Georgia Blue, The Ranch, 2 Brothers
Lots of good options in Tier 3...