He'll be able to recruit as well as Stan's did. I want you to adore the hire...up until the results aren't what you expected and then you have to question whether the ninja is even remotely the AD that Byrne was or whether he should stick to billboards and hash tags.
Perception is reality and the reality is this guy isn't his brother and has coached at the equivalent of a junior college for one year(I've spent time on Valpo's campus...I've honestly seen more impressive high schools).
Why in the hell would you make a decision like this based simply on who your rival will hate the most? Your little brother syndrome is about to cause an overreach of epic proportions.