It was indeed at Hooters. I think I scored a sweet pair of boxers and a wife beater as my swag. We certainly could have been teammates... I just remember laughing about the mustard as I couldn't have cared less about a jacket from Goodwill.
Carmen was Carmen Tevis and was behind us in law school. She may have been in Todd Ellis' class, I can't recall.
My only good AM story was that he sprayed mustard all over the goodwill blazer I was wearing after my team won a golf tournament we played at Sedgeweed...