I contacted them and they just keep saying I need to re-sign up and enter my billing information. Sounds like they're just trying to get me to pay for an account. So I'm probably either stuck with this one with the wrong email address which I won't connect any billing information to because...
Found my other one but it's saved to a screwed up email address. So can't change it since that anonymous one has the right email. This merge just ruined our boards and lost a lot of posters.