Matthews - Michagan vs Indiana

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
I wish these guys would be patient. Matthews could have had a great career at UK.

I think he could have played major minutes at SF on the 2017 team. Would have given us some size (compared to Briscoe) at SF.

Then he would have been a Junior in 2018. Would have provided some experience.

This year, he would be a Senior and the leader of this team. Imagine our defense with Hagans, Johnson, and Matthews on the perimeter?

Just wish guys like Matthews, Gabriel, SKJ, etc. would stick around as Juniors and Seniors so we could have some veterans to lean on.

Really want to see Quickley, Baker, and Richards stick around and give us that over the next few years.

I wish it was okay for players to be four year players before going off to the pros again. I miss those days, sometimes.
Got to look at it from their point. Hump and Mathews both sat on the bench and when they did get in the game and screwed just once, they were pulled, meanwhile watching Skal give us absolutely nothing. Then watch Cal recruit over them. They leave. And I don’t blame them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chuckinden

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
I don't have a problem with him not playing much his time here, but him leaving highlights a problem.

I wish there was more emphasis to focus on player retention and reduce transfers.
Yea. Maybe Cal could tell them to enjoy the process and their turn will come if they work hard and compete.
 

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
Mathews is a good upperclassman. But he would have been crucified here because he is a wing who couldn't shoot well outside or at the free-throw line - and he still can't. I actually thought Mathews would develop into a better shooter, as his form looked ok to me. But he has not. Nevertheless, he is a good college player and would have been a good player at UK - but, as he surmised, maybe never quite as good as other players in front of him.
No way in hell Mathews could be any worse shooting than Briscoe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poppycat

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
Yea. Maybe Cal could tell them to enjoy the process and their turn will come if they work hard and compete.

At the end of the day you have to make a commitment to upperclassmen with playing time. There are plenty of arguments to why you do or don't do that with this program. But no kid we recruit in our current strategy is going to wear the UK uniform because he bleeds blue. Every one of them is marking the days on the calendar until they don't have to put on that uniform.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
No way in hell Mathews could be any worse shooting than Briscoe.
While Mathews was here - and I was a big supporter of Mathews, as I thought he was going to develop into a solid SF - Briscoe was clearly better and made the team much better than Mathews could have at that point. A person didn't really have to be too astute basketball wise to see that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ukfan041

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
While Mathews was here - and I was a big supporter of Mathews, as I thought he was going to develop into a solid SF - Briscoe was clearly better and made the team much better than Mathews could have at that point. A person didn't really have to be too astute basketball wise to see that.
Don’t disagree. I just said Mathews was no worse shooter than Briscoe.
 

RichardCory

Senior
Nov 28, 2007
1,075
842
113
Richard Cory, you average about 30 posts a year and this is what you come up with? Ok then
yeah, caught the game he was playing in this afternoon on CBS and he was playing pretty good and couldnt recall why he had transferred. Had time today to post and possibly respond in real time unlike most of the time.
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
Why did he transfer? I don't recall, but wish it could have worked out for him to stay with our team.
Because Cal started a player over him who he was better than. Not to mention that player was 4 inches shorter atleast and had no business at sf. I don’t blame Charles. Cal screwed that one up.
 

RichardCory

Senior
Nov 28, 2007
1,075
842
113
Because Cal started a player over him who he was better than. Not to mention that player was 4 inches shorter atleast and had no business at sf. I don’t blame Charles. Cal screwed that one up.
Not blaming either of em, was thinking it would have been nice if it had worked out to still have him and also the big Aussie from that class still around.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

Sparkaces

All-American
Sep 19, 2012
6,157
6,289
0
Because Cal started a player over him who he was better than. Not to mention that player was 4 inches shorter atleast and had no business at sf. I don’t blame Charles. Cal screwed that one up.
Of all the things Cal has done, the Briscoe starting at SF experiment maybe tops for me. Just imagine if Matthews played Briscoe minutes as a Freshman, we prob win the title the Fox/Monk year.
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
[laughing] @ those saying Matthews was a better player than Briscoe.

Some of you would rather choke on dog crap than admit you're wrong.

I wished Charles would have stuck it out here too but it's far from a mystery as to why he didn't play more as a freshman.
So he sucked here and couldn’t play over a guy who can’t shoot worth a crap and stepped on the baseline as much as he made a big play for us, yet at Michigan hes gotten better every year and is a great player? Matthews is better than Briscoe will ever be.

Like the poster said above, if the 2017 team had Matthews starting at SF we likely win that title. Would have gave us a legit option to guard Justin Jackson.
 

JohnBlue

Heisman
Jul 22, 2003
188,376
14,335
0
So he sucked here and couldn’t play over a guy who can’t shoot worth a crap and stepped on the baseline as much as he made a big play for us, yet at Michigan hes gotten better every year and is a great player? Matthews is better than Briscoe will ever be.

Like the poster said above, if the 2017 team had Matthews starting at SF we likely win that title. Would have gave us a legit option to guard Justin Jackson.

No one was stopping Jackson, certainly not freshman Matthews. No one has ever said Briscoe was the best player here but you can't factually make a case that at that time he wasn't better than Matthews. Sure Matthews got better by what we would be his jr. year but you never got to see a jr. Briscoe play either.

Some of you seem to follow Matthews pretty close so I'll ask you the obvious question. How many 6'8 lottery picks has Matthews shut down in his career?
 

SkyPrince1

All-Conference
Aug 17, 2004
4,793
3,764
0
So he sucked here and couldn’t play over a guy who can’t shoot worth a crap and stepped on the baseline as much as he made a big play for us, yet at Michigan hes gotten better every year and is a great player? Matthews is better than Briscoe will ever be.

Like the poster said above, if the 2017 team had Matthews starting at SF we likely win that title. Would have gave us a legit option to guard Justin Jackson.
Gotta totally disagree.
Briscoe was better hands down.
Watched IB take over @Vandy on a night when Fox/Monk we're not getting it done. Matthews was not that type player.
The Beilein system makes Charles appear better than he actually is
JB is a great college coach.
IB had his shortcomings but he was a dog. I'm sure he kicked CM's *** in practice.
 

KingOfBBN

Heisman
Sep 14, 2013
39,077
38,403
0
I wish these guys would be patient. Matthews could have had a great career at UK.

I think he could have played major minutes at SF on the 2017 team. Would have given us some size (compared to Briscoe) at SF.

Then he would have been a Junior in 2018. Would have provided some experience.

This year, he would be a Senior and the leader of this team. Imagine our defense with Hagans, Johnson, and Matthews on the perimeter?

Just wish guys like Matthews, Gabriel, SKJ, etc. would stick around as Juniors and Seniors so we could have some veterans to lean on.

Really want to see Quickley, Baker, and Richards stick around and give us that over the next few years.

I wish it was okay for players to be four year players before going off to the pros again. I miss those days, sometimes.

I’d say it paid off for him considering he played in the national championship while we got sent packing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
Here's what I remember about CM. he was a somewhat typical Cal recruit in that he was very athletic but couldn't throw it in the ocean. He was given opportunities but not EVERY opportunity as some have said. He was on a very short leash.

Was it incorrect of him to think if he couldn't get minutes as a frosh that he would later on, as being recruited over has been a way of life under Cal. Only way he was going to play was if the new guy failed. See Wenyen who got way more of Willis's minutes than he should have until it was apparent he wasn't going to cut it. If Derek hadn't been a Kentucky kid, seems likely he wouldn't have been around to fill in.

When Charles left my feeling was, he's not a shooter, so it could be worse. Glad he's succeeded but no one should suggest that he would have been given the chance to improve. Cal's approach is to recruit someone better, not to coach someone up. He didn't care that CM left or Hump are others who aren't on the fast track.

Doesn't matter whether fans like it or not. Cal isn't going to change.
 

Catluv

All-Conference
Dec 18, 2018
3,546
4,692
0
He played 369 minutes his freshman year. Willis played around a 150 his fresh and soph years togeather. I couldn't believe he left I thought he would be a very good player. Cal didn't want him to leave.
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
Mathews had great physical tools but was incredibly raw as a freshman. He was a project. A year off to develop did him well.
 

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
No one was stopping Jackson, certainly not freshman Matthews. No one has ever said Briscoe was the best player here but you can't factually make a case that at that time he wasn't better than Matthews. Sure Matthews got better by what we would be his jr. year but you never got to see a jr. Briscoe play either.

Some of you seem to follow Matthews pretty close so I'll ask you the obvious question. How many 6'8 lottery picks has Matthews shut down in his career?
Matthews would have been a sophomore that year. A sophomore Matthews would have been a much better option to defend him than Briscoe.
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,208
21,204
103
I don't have a problem with him not playing much his time here, but him leaving highlights a problem.

I wish there was more emphasis to focus on player retention and reduce transfers.

He actually averaged 10 minutes a game his freshmen year despite having horrible stats. Shot 44% from the field, 1 of 4 from 3, and was a 41% free throw shooter. 19 turovers vs 13 assist. He simply was just not that good of a player then as he was still transitioning into the college game.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Don’t disagree. I just said Mathews was no worse shooter than Briscoe.
I agree. And like I said, I'm still surprised that Mathews didn't develop better as a shooter (although I think he is shooting a little better lately). I expected that he would. Regardless, he is a good college player now. But here's a question: Would we rather have freshman Johnson or senior Mathews this season?
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
He actually averaged 10 minutes a game his freshmen year despite having horrible stats. Shot 44% from the field, 1 of 4 from 3, and was a 41% free throw shooter. 19 turovers vs 13 assist. He simply was just not that good of a player then as he was still transitioning into the college game.
yea I get that - I'm not commenting on whether Matthews earned or was talented enough to be in the rotation while he was here

but he really is the poster child for a guy that would be adding very valuable minutes to our program had he stayed. And its not like he went off to the abyss of the G-League, but there was something about our handling or messaging that didn't resonate with him

and I wish we'd put more emphasis on it.

I firmly believe we won't have another championship until we have 2, maybe 3 Charles Matthews type players on the team as Juniors/Seniors
 
Last edited:

eppsfan

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2010
826
1,508
0
Maybe Matthews has been coached up? (That sort of thing really does still happen in college bb believe it or not) Or perhaps it's a better offensive system? Possibly both.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

Chuckinden

All-American
Jun 12, 2006
19,008
5,958
113
The goal here is to get into the NBA as a OAD. That didn't happen for Matthews and IMO, if he had to go through the "process", he would rather do it closer to home.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
His *** got blisters riding the pine. Cal gave him zero chance to play thru mistakes.

I disagree with this. He played 10 mpg. Not bad for a FR. I don't think any/many of us thought he would be a key player on that team, but instead would be a 3-4 year guy. But as others have noted, under Cal if you don't start/star as a FR and are a OAD, you consider yourself a failure. He had very little offensive ability as a FR, and was playing behind Murray and Briscoe. Basically, he just wasn't patient!
 

Comebakatz3

Heisman
Aug 8, 2008
44,399
34,289
113
So maybe it went like this and he could be a 5th year Senior for 19-20 at Mich if he wanted to?
15-16 Freshman at UK
16-17 Redshirt Sophmore at Mich
17-18 Junior at Mich
18-19 Senior at Mich or here if he had stayed.

Close... I think it is actually this:

15-16: Freshman at UK
16-17: Redshirt year at Michigan (sat out)
17-18: Redshirt sophomore at Mich
18-19: Redshirt junior at Mich
19-20: Redshirt senior.

Had he stayed then he would be a senior for UK this year because he wouldn't have taken a redshirt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Richard Cory

fisherscat

All-Conference
Feb 9, 2005
11,283
4,714
0
Briscoe was better and more ready to contribute as a frosh. Matthews may have been as good or better than Briscoe as a sophomore and helped us in 2017 and last year. Can’t all of those things be true?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZaytovenCat

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
My memory isn't as clear as it should be regarding Briscoe, but I always felt Briscoe brought a very specific skillset into the game - to drive the lane and create a shot as a slasher

but that wasn't always the strength we were playing to during a game so , to me anyways, his playing time was situational, not a rotation thing.


but again, if someone wanted to argue otherwise, I wouldn't debate it. Just my recollection.
 

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
I agree. And like I said, I'm still surprised that Mathews didn't develop better as a shooter (although I think he is shooting a little better lately). I expected that he would. Regardless, he is a good college player now. But here's a question: Would we rather have freshman Johnson or senior Mathews this season?
KJ hands down
 
  • Like
Reactions: G-PIP

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
My memory isn't as clear as it should be regarding Briscoe, but I always felt Briscoe brought a very specific skillset into the game - to drive the lane and create a shot as a slasher

but that wasn't always the strength we were playing to during a game so , to me anyways, his playing time was situational, not a rotation thing.


but again, if someone wanted to argue otherwise, I wouldn't debate it. Just my recollection.
Yes. However his sophomore year teams learned how to defend him and he was rendered kinda useless for scoring, he was terrible at free throws, had no shot. That all said, I loved how hard he played. I can not say now that I had rather had Mathews over IB. Briscoe at the time was better than Mathews, IMO.
 

so_obvious

All-Conference
May 26, 2017
1,692
3,114
78
Just watched Matthews highlights from his year at Kentucky. He made some really good plays that I totally forgot about. You could see what kind of player he could become with more time.

Wish he would have chosen to develop here because he has gotten better and better. Was already great at driving to the rim, and once he found his outside shot he really became dangerous.

Anyways, I don’t think here is anyone to blame. He had the talent to play here. Cal has the knowledge to develop him much as JB has done. I guess sometimes the pieces don’t fit. It’s okay, it happens.

Side note: Michigan seems to be in a good place basketball wise. They aren’t expected to get the best of the best year in and out and the players they do get have time to develop without the pressures found here. Guess that’s why Cal says Kentucky isn’t for everyone. Matthews was an example of that. You have to grow up fast here as a lot is expected. People here are calling Herro a terrible shooter after 13 games for example. Some players don’t do well in an environment like that. Maybe that’s why Matthews decided to go elsewhere. Comfort and time. Takes a lot of confidence and maturity to excel here. Which is why our greats go on to do so many great things...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Richard Cory
Jan 30, 2018
16,155
24,636
0
He played, but very little. He was the quintessential 3-4 yr guy we craved, but he wanted to start from day 1. When that didn’t happen, the relationship soured and he left. He wanted to be the man, but that wasn’t going to happen here.
I don't remember did he start from the jump there? Either way I wonder if he would have as a freshman there.
 

HalHR2500

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2002
2,892
4,422
113
Matthews is the type of player that frankly should transfer, certain players develop a little later than others in his class (and gets less clock), then gets recruited over by incoming class. Matthews was raw as freshman, but showed vast potential/athleticism even in limited minutes.

It's just the way it works here. The 5 stars have to play, and for the marginal players transferring is a viable optioin, unless they have a clear avenue to start as sophomores
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football WATCH: KSR's Rapid Reaction to Kentucky's loss at Mizzou, live from Faurot Field
  2. 02 KSR Football Kickoff time announced for the Governor's Cup
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein had little to report on Kentucky's injuries after Missouri loss
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky Loses Third Straight, Falls 28-14 at Missouri
  5. 05 KSR Football LIVE BLOG: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri