UK is Hagans commit away from passing Duke

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
But, will the team be better for it? Just a question, I'm not suggesting that it won't. In fact, if Gabriel or Green were leaving, then I think these pickups are very needed (not just icing). However, assume for a minute (just for the sake of argument) that Montgomery and Haggans choosing UK means we lose Green and Gabriel. Is UK a better team?

Well, of course, we can't yet really answer that for sure. But I think there's a good argument that the answer may be "No." So, while I love adding more good young players, all the while I'm always keeping one eye on who is coming back. To me that's the key. In my opinion, if UK lost no more than Knox, SGA and Diallo, then they don't need any more players to be a contender.
 
Sep 27, 2015
17,530
30,503
98
But, will the team be better for it? Just a question, I'm not suggesting that it won't. In fact, if Gabriel or Green were leaving, then I think these pickups are very needed (not just icing). However, assume for a minute (just for the sake of argument) that Montgomery and Haggans choosing UK means we lose Green and Gabriel. Is UK a better team?

Well, of course, we can't yet really answer that for sure. But I think there's a good argument that the answer may be "No." So, while I love adding more good young players, all the while I'm always keeping one eye on who is coming back. To me that's the key. In my opinion, if UK lost no more than Knox, SGA and Diallo, then they don't need any more players to be a contender.

Just assume Kentucky will lose a lot of guys. I would say the icing is any returnees more than any recruits. This is pipeline and keeps him away from other schools
 

caneintally

Heisman
Oct 1, 2002
27,455
17,056
0
If we get Hagans I would take our class all day over Dukes class of small forwards
Yep . Will love to see Duke's 2 SF , College center who thinks he is SF and tre jones ( who isn't as good as Quickley or Garland or grimes IMO ) have more success next season then UK with all UK has coming back. Duke's big returnee is Bolden - AHAHAHA.
 

caneintally

Heisman
Oct 1, 2002
27,455
17,056
0
But, will the team be better for it? Just a question, I'm not suggesting that it won't. In fact, if Gabriel or Green were leaving, then I think these pickups are very needed (not just icing). However, assume for a minute (just for the sake of argument) that Montgomery and Haggans choosing UK means we lose Green and Gabriel. Is UK a better team?

Well, of course, we can't yet really answer that for sure. But I think there's a good argument that the answer may be "No." So, while I love adding more good young players, all the while I'm always keeping one eye on who is coming back. To me that's the key. In my opinion, if UK lost no more than Knox, SGA and Diallo, then they don't need any more players to be a contender.
That ain't going to happen. But no it wouldn't be better but that is literally the worst case never going to happen scenario. I wish people would let the Green thing die as it has not one iota of fact behind it . Just like the SKJ transferring talk did last off season. Tai is transferring . No one else will. UK needed 1 more scoring big man and another guard considering they are losing Shai , Diallo and KNox . They needed EJ this season but didn't have a guy like him. PJ was our only scoring threat inside .Now we have 2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,132
73,723
113
That's insane to think about. I mean, if you sign the #1, #2, #3 and #9 recruits you would think you would have the #1 class and it wouldn't be close. It's funny as hell to say that Duke will have the 2nd rated class with what they brought in.
Wow.
 

isonator35

Junior
Sep 8, 2015
359
328
0
Honestly, I was pretty pissed after Zion committed to Duke. Having the #1, 2, and 3 players and the #1 PG and I assumed some people would return. If Carter leaves Duke, they are going to really struggle IMO. With Trent and Duval leaving unexpectedly, their roster is looking really thin next year.
 

BBUK_anon

Hall of Famer
May 26, 2005
52,358
124,843
0
Honestly, I was pretty pissed after Zion committed to Duke. Having the #1, 2, and 3 players and the #1 PG and I assumed some people would return. If Carter leaves Duke, they are going to really struggle IMO. With Trent and Duval leaving unexpectedly, their roster is looking really thin next year.

They family maine....they be fine....
 

jwheat

Heisman
Aug 21, 2005
97,626
24,206
42
Ranking is irrelevant...more interested in whether the class combined with our returnees has the makings of a legit title contender.
We have quick guards, guards that can shoot, forwards that can shoot, forwards that can rebound. If we can get improvement from Richards/SKJ we will be one of the best teams in the country next year
 

BBUK_anon

Hall of Famer
May 26, 2005
52,358
124,843
0
We have quick guards, guards that can shoot, forwards that can shoot, forwards that can rebound. If we can get improvement from Richards/SKJ we will be one of the best teams in the country next year

AND, Cal can get them to play for their teammates instead of themselves....
 

fisherscat

All-Conference
Feb 9, 2005
11,283
4,714
0
AND, Cal can get them to play for their teammates instead of themselves....
Not being pessimistic but want to see how it comes together. We lose our two best offensive players...if for some reason Vandy and/or PJ leave then we would be losing 3 or 4 of our best players. In this scenario it would seem that we would need big improvements from our returnees and for our new guys to all contribute at a high level...especially offensively.
 

BBUK_anon

Hall of Famer
May 26, 2005
52,358
124,843
0
Not being pessimistic but want to see how it comes together. We lose our two best offensive players...if for some reason Vandy and/or PJ leave then we would be losing 3 or 4 of our best players. In this scenario it would seem that we would need big improvements from our returnees and for our new guys to all contribute at a high level...especially offensively.

I understand your take but Cal has a track record. I will trust that.
 

MbergCat

Heisman
Nov 23, 2014
7,718
14,636
113
But, will the team be better for it? Just a question, I'm not suggesting that it won't. In fact, if Gabriel or Green were leaving, then I think these pickups are very needed (not just icing). However, assume for a minute (just for the sake of argument) that Montgomery and Haggans choosing UK means we lose Green and Gabriel. Is UK a better team?

Well, of course, we can't yet really answer that for sure. But I think there's a good argument that the answer may be "No." So, while I love adding more good young players, all the while I'm always keeping one eye on who is coming back. To me that's the key. In my opinion, if UK lost no more than Knox, SGA and Diallo, then they don't need any more players to be a contender.
I think Montgomery for Gabriel could potentially be a wash. However, I think Hagans for Green would be an instant upgrade.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
I think Montgomery for Gabriel could potentially be a wash. However, I think Hagans for Green would be an instant upgrade.
I don't agree with that opinion, but I understand it. Thankfully, since it was just a hypothetical, it probably doesn't matter anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MbergCat

Jmeeks54thebest

All-American
Apr 18, 2009
6,867
9,733
0
Definielty stings that we lost out of 4 guys this recruiting season (Barrett, Reddish, Williamson, and Bol). But Cal is his late recruiting season magic and getting us the best available that he can get.

I do believe E.J. was Cal’s #2 behind Bol. But we may better for it, and I don’t even know that for sure. Total speculation.
 

Catdaddygalore

Redshirt
Feb 20, 2018
100
27
0
I got bashed on here for saying I hope SGA goes to the NBA & we get Hagans. It would be best for SGA because he won’t improve his stock, it is a great recruiting tool for Cal (can’t beat the 4 star turned OAD lottery pick), & it will make room for Hagans. I really hope this happens because we’ll be REALLY good next season. Could be special!
 
  • Like
Reactions: KDCats11

bluedog79

All-American
Mar 4, 2008
6,015
5,290
0
I STILL to this very second wish Bol Bol would change his mind and decommit from Oregon. He should be a wildcat. It hurts my soul knowing he will not. We would be unstoppable with him. UNSTOPPABLE. Hurts bad man. We always seem to be missing that one guy. I hope it aint him.
 

WildcatDJ

All-Conference
May 20, 2007
4,798
1,877
113
Pretty ironic that Duke will be loaded with mostly freshman while we'll have an experienced squad, barring something unforeseen on our end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
Who has the #1 class is not really that important. When we play them right out of the box that will be important.

Suggested more than a month ago, in a perfect world, we would beat them in game 1 and end their season later on. Payback for their doing it to the Cats. I was at both those games and it was horrible.
 

School boy

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2007
5,506
3,865
0
They have a decent point guard in a down class and bolden to go with three small forwards who are going to be on the floor at the same time

I hope it does mess up for them. I think it could, but yeah we have a top class just like they do. It's close if we traded I think both coaches would be ok with it. It's that close.

Now I wouldn't trade the full roster, we are better in that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LineSkiCat14

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
They also have a very good point guard plus we all wanted ALL 3 of those forwards. So did Cal.
Certainly, Duke got four excellent top rated high school players that any program would want. Maybe they are the best 5 high school kids (but certainly not the best 5 college players) in CBB. But, if you were a fan of Duke would you feel comfortable about how the pieces fit? I mean, I love what freshman Anthony Davis brought, but I don't think UK wins anything with 5 ADs on the floor.

I think Duke's recruiting haul lacks good team balance; and if Duke starts Williamson, Barrett and Reddish - and that is the lineup that ends up playing almost all the minutes - I don't think Duke is a Sweet 16 team next season.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,954
63,161
113
I just don't see how Kentucky can overtake a class that has the literal top3 players going to one school, plus another in the top10.

the 6th, 16th, 17th, 25th.. and the 18th from (2018). I don't know... I don't think that beats Duke's class of 4 top ten players, none of which are coming in a year younger than normal either

I place more emphasis on having the elite guys, and yes, that slider is different every year.. but there's a reason the number 10 has been ingrained in everyone's mind. Top10 and everyone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Primedfor9
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Milan Momcilovic weighs in on Kentucky's issues after his epic 1st half goes to waste
  2. 02 KSR Basketball WATCH: KSR's Rapid Reaction to Kentucky's 90-76 loss to Indiana in Lucas Oil
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Kentucky couldn't stop fouling and Indiana made them pay
  4. 04 KSR Basketball FINAL: Indiana lives at the FT line, takes down Kentucky 90-76 in Indy
  5. 05 KSR Basketball IT'S A MILAN MOMCILOVIC PARTY AND YOU'RE INVITED!