Shai is the first one up !!!!!

Apr 13, 2002
44,001
97,158
0
His 3pt shot is bad and has ugly form on it.Shai only made 23 on the year...not good

False. He shot a good percentage from 3, a great free tbeot shooter, and made some mid range pull ups.

He was so good at getting to the rim he was judicious about taking jumpers, which was smart. Wish more would think that way
 

bthaunert

Heisman
Apr 4, 2007
29,518
21,619
0
Question, because I really don’t know. Do first round picks ever go to G league? They get multi-year, multi-million $$$ guaranteed contracts. Do NBA teams pay that amount and send them to developmental league? I’d assume for the big bucks they’d expect a player that can contribute immediately.
The G League has completely transformed over the past few years. It's not the NBDL of 15 years ago. Teams are now mostly associated with an NBA franchise (very similar to MLB). 12 first round draft picks from 2017 have spent time in the G League. It's a way for guys to get minutes instead of sitting on the bench. The same way a MLB team might keep their top prospect at AA or AAA instead of making the MLB roster and playing part time.

As for Shai, huge congrats to him if he does leave. He was ranked in the 30's coming out of high school and has worked his *** off to become a 1st round pick in the NBA.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
False. He shot a good percentage from 3, a great free tbeot shooter, and made some mid range pull ups.

He was so good at getting to the rim he was judicious about taking jumpers, which was smart. Wish more would think that way
Shooting 40% doesn't make him a good 3pt shooter.. He could go 2-5 and shoot 40 %...His form is ugly..he won't make many 3's in the NBA and his drives will get bounced off his head.Would you call Hami a good 3pt shooter? he made more than Shai
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rupp'sRunt
Sep 13, 2003
23,905
33,655
113
The G League has completely transformed over the past few years. It's not the NBDL of 15 years ago. Teams are now mostly associated with an NBA franchise (very similar to MLB). 12 first round draft picks from 2017 have spent time in the G League. It's a way for guys to get minutes instead of sitting on the bench. The same way a MLB team might keep their top prospect at AA or AAA instead of making the MLB roster and playing part time.

As for Shai, huge congrats to him if he does leave. He was ranked in the 30's coming out of high school and has worked his *** off to become a 1st round pick in the NBA.

Derek Willis said the G-League SUCKS!!![laughing]

However, he wasn't a 1st round pick getting guaranteed money. Shai will need time to develop PG skills. He needs to work on his passing and floor awareness. He has the work ethic and demeanor to thrive once he develops more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dablueman

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
I guess Doron Lamb and Tony Delk aren't good 3 point shooters then.
ok, good point Maybe i should have said 75-100 on the year... Lamb made 3x as many 3's as Shai though..It's ok if you think a guy that makes 23 on the year is a 3pt shooter..like i said Hami made more 3's than Shai..that's all i need to know..Heck, Briscoe made almost as many as Shai in a season..3pt shooting is not Shai's game at all..He does 1 thing well as far as scoring..That's drive for layups..And that won't work in the NBA ..imo..I think of guys like Murray and Monk as good 3pt shooters ..they made over 100 and shot 40%
 

TheDude73

Heisman
Jan 7, 2006
24,469
24,474
113
The G League has completely transformed over the past few years. It's not the NBDL of 15 years ago. Teams are now mostly associated with an NBA franchise (very similar to MLB). 12 first round draft picks from 2017 have spent time in the G League. It's a way for guys to get minutes instead of sitting on the bench. The same way a MLB team might keep their top prospect at AA or AAA instead of making the MLB roster and playing part time.

As for Shai, huge congrats to him if he does leave. He was ranked in the 30's coming out of high school and has worked his *** off to become a 1st round pick in the NBA.
Indeed. People somehow think that slapping together a minor league, complete with stadiums and all, is something that can be done over a weekend. It's taken the MLB decades to build their network of minor league teams across the US - I would think it might take a bit for the NBA to get their farm system up and running as well.
 

TheDude73

Heisman
Jan 7, 2006
24,469
24,474
113
Derek Willis said the G-League SUCKS!!![laughing]

However, he wasn't a 1st round pick getting guaranteed money. Shai will need time to develop PG skills. He needs to work on his passing and floor awareness. He has the work ethic and demeanor to thrive once he develops more.

I've had 4-5 high school buddies I played baseball with that played in the MLB's minor league system - one was the next one in line for shortstop at the Mariners back when ARod was there (he ended up quitting due to the effects the strict demands the teams had on he and his wife's new family). They all said the minor league absolutely sucked. ****** schedule, horrible per diem, garbage salary, and so much work that they thought they were going to die. About the best part of it, they said, were the crazy fans and the small stadium excitement that minor league parks bring.

So of course the minor leagues suck to a player who'd prefer being up with the big boys and making the big bucks. Not a shocker.
 

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,718
30,246
113
Shooting 40% doesn't make him a good 3pt shooter.. He could go 2-5 and shoot 40 %...His form is ugly..he won't make many 3's in the NBA and his drives will get bounced off his head.Would you call Hami a good 3pt shooter? he made more than Shai


So what you trying to say? He should walk away from being a lottery pick? Why not secure the big contract and work on your game while you're making a lot of money? And all you have to focus on is playing basketball no classes etc...I guess that makes too much sense!
 

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,718
30,246
113
ok, good point Maybe i should have said 75-100 on the year... Lamb made 3x as many 3's as Shai though..It's ok if you think a guy that makes 23 on the year is a 3pt shooter..like i said Hami made more 3's than Shai..that's all i need to know..Heck, Briscoe made almost as many as Shai in a season..3pt shooting is not Shai's game at all..He does 1 thing well as far as scoring..That's drive for layups..And that won't work in the NBA ..imo..I think of guys like Murray and Monk as good 3pt shooters ..they made over 100 and shot 40%


BTW... his form is fine. Follow-through & release are great. He just has to work on shooting the ball quicker and learning how to elevate when he shoots it....thats it. It's not like he needs entire mechanics overhaul. It'll take work...but he will work. But the good news is that his release and follow-through are great.

You're just itching to find why players should stay. If shai can't fix any weak parts of his game in the NBA he wasn't going to fix it in college either. Why you can get paid you get paid.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat
Sep 13, 2003
23,905
33,655
113
I've had 4-5 high school buddies I played baseball with that played in the MLB's minor league system - one was the next one in line for shortstop at the Mariners back when ARod was there (he ended up quitting due to the effects the strict demands the teams had on he and his wife's new family). They all said the minor league absolutely sucked. ****** schedule, horrible per diem, garbage salary, and so much work that they thought they were going to die. About the best part of it, they said, were the crazy fans and the small stadium excitement that minor league parks bring.

So of course the minor leagues suck to a player who'd prefer being up with the big boys and making the big bucks. Not a shocker.

It all depends on guaranteed money and how important the player's development is to management.

For kids in both sports that were drafted high and have a great contract, it can be a step along the way to the Bigs in either sport. However, if there is no guaranteed money and the player has to prove himself to the organization while making very little money, it most definitely would suck.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
So what you trying to say? He should walk away from being a lottery pick? Why not secure the big contract and work on your game while you're making a lot of money? And all you have to focus on is playing basketball no classes etc...I guess that makes too much sense!
I never said he should come back..I think if you're a 1st rounder you go, but i think Shai will be a bust as a lottery pick
 

Rupp'sRunt

Heisman
Apr 19, 2008
14,675
20,094
0
Some of you all make SGA out to be some great 3 pt shooter. He wasn't even the best 3pt shooter on a poor 3pt shooting team. Decent to good midrange, great free throw shooter, Ok 3pt shooter, superb slasher.
 

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,718
30,246
113
I never said he should come back..I think if you're a 1st rounder you go, but i think Shai will be a bust as a lottery pick


I agree that he will not be an immediate impact player. I don't think he'll a bust I think he'll end up being a very contributable role player at some point time his career. His attitude and work ethic will see him through.
 
A

anon_9qtxg60vqzy0y

Guest
I never said he should come back..I think if you're a 1st rounder you go, but i think Shai will be a bust as a lottery pick
We've heard enough of your nonsense. Professional talent evaluators love Shai's game. Tim Legler, former NBA player and ESPN NBA analyst, raves about Shai's development and his potential in the NBA. He said Shai is the 2nd point guard taken in the draft. You on the other hand have never seen Shai compete in a game or practice other than from the friendly confines of your recliner.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
We've heard enough of your nonsense. Professional talent evaluators love Shai's game. Tim Legler, former NBA player and ESPN NBA analyst, raves about Shai's development and his potential in the NBA. He said Shai is the 2nd point guard taken in the draft. You on the other hand have never seen Shai compete in a game or practice other than from the friendly confines of your recliner.
Shut it moron..Ive said IMO..do you know what that means?And I've seen Shai play more than you i bet..
 

thepip

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2009
7,467
2,351
0
And I'm already gone
And I'm feelin' strong
I will sing this vict'ry song, woo, hoo, hoo, woo, hoo, hoo
Well I know it wasn't you who held me down
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
He's on the clock ... we should hear
from him today or tomorrow . GONE

Unless players sign with an agent, hearing that they will enter the draft means little. I expect 6-9 of them to do that. No reason not to.
The real questions will come the week or two after the draft combine.
 

Soupbean

All-American
Jan 19, 2007
5,945
8,109
0
I don't get it. I love him and hope he does well in the NBA but I just don't see it happening.

He's a good, not great shooter. He's not fast or jump exceptionally high. He's not a great passer.

What he does well is taking it to the basket on college players. Will he have the same success at that in the NBA?

Again, If he goes, I support him but I think he needs another year. If you had a top 10 pick, would you take him?
Tend to agree. Love him all day in college but he's a little one dimensional with his drive game and that will be much tougher next level. They allow much more slapping and reaching there too and he sometimes struggled with tight physical play. Gotta get stronger and quicker and get the feel for dropping the ball off to open guys on his drives.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdlUK.1

JC CATS

Heisman
Jun 18, 2009
23,517
12,221
0
ok, good point Maybe i should have said 75-100 on the year... Lamb made 3x as many 3's as Shai though..It's ok if you think a guy that makes 23 on the year is a 3pt shooter..like i said Hami made more 3's than Shai..that's all i need to know..Heck, Briscoe made almost as many as Shai in a season..3pt shooting is not Shai's game at all..He does 1 thing well as far as scoring..That's drive for layups..And that won't work in the NBA ..imo..I think of guys like Murray and Monk as good 3pt shooters ..they made over 100 and shot 40%
Ridiculous take. The man hit 40 t percent, give him credit he took more than 5 shots
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

billoliver40

All-American
Dec 16, 2015
6,736
9,444
0
I will agree he was the best player on this team, but I believe he's a G league player for a time until his consistency improves even more. Likely will be a first round pick, based on potential.
 

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
Time is right to go , I dont blame him . I dont think his game translates that well to the pro's though . Best of luck , and from Queen .. " and another one's gone , another one bites the dust" with one being the point of emphasis .
 
  • Like
Reactions: CalipariCapo

Dablueman

All-American
Feb 5, 2003
16,981
5,703
0
Derek Willis said the G-League SUCKS!!![laughing]

However, he wasn't a 1st round pick getting guaranteed money. Shai will need time to develop PG skills. He needs to work on his passing and floor awareness. He has the work ethic and demeanor to thrive once he develops more.
SGA does intrigue me he wasn't tagged as a one and done so he hasn't sat and dreamed about for years. He Knox and Vanderbilt could all go 8 to ten spots higher in the draft coming back. Just not as sure as eveyever else that he is leaving and that may be why we are hearing Green transfer rumors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,348
67,242
113
James Young.

Only if you are predicting he will struggle like Young. Shai is the hardest worker on this team and has skills and a basketball IQ Young never developed. From a skill-perspective, I see Chauncey Billups much more than Young. It too Billups years to mold himself into an all-star and a champion. Hope Shai has years of NBA ahead of him.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
Ridiculous take. The man hit 40 t percent, give him credit he took more than 5 shots
So you basing him being a good 3 pt shooter on making 40%? Would you call Hami a good 3pt shooter?He made more than Shai...Maybe Cal should have had Shai shooting more 3's?I never said he was a bad shooter..Just my opinion of a good 3pt shooter is based on how many he makes on the season..I'd rather have a guy shoot 37% and make 100 than a guy shoot 40% and make 23.A great /deadly 3 pt shooter is a guy that shoots 40+% and makes 100+...but enough with this..if you guys think Shai is a great shooter then fine...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anthony B

Beatle Bum

Heisman
Sep 1, 2002
44,348
67,242
113
Shooting 40% doesn't make him a good 3pt shooter.. He could go 2-5 and shoot 40 %...His form is ugly..he won't make many 3's in the NBA and his drives will get bounced off his head.Would you call Hami a good 3pt shooter? he made more than Shai

LOL

So much good stuff here. 40% from the outside is not good shooting? He could go 2/5 and shoot 40% (as if there was a choice in percentages)? Yes, 2/5 will always be 40%. As will 20/50 and 40/100. (Just having some fun)

40% from 3 for a season is good shooting even if you always bounce the ball off your head or shoot with two hands. Whether he can get that shot consistently in the NBA or make it translate from the deeper three is a different question. But, 40% with significant attempts is damn good.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  2. 02 KSR Football Playoff Viewing Guide: What games Kentucky fans need to follow in Week 11
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Kentucky vs. Indiana: Preview, Odds & How to Watch
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Kentucky vs. Indiana and the latest in recruiting
  5. 05 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: What to know about Thursday's update