I've stayed out of all the HD threads until now.
I can say in all honesty I see both sides of the issue.
On the one hand another poster made a great point, and I had a similar situation: I hired two friends last month. My company spent @ $1,500 on each one before they ever worked the first day.
My time interviewing them both; drug screens, national background checks, uniforms, training, etc. They both spent one day in on the job training and then promptly quit. We lost $$ on those two bums but you can never predict what people are going to do, so it is what it is I suppose.
Neither of them left us for a better job; they just came for the training pay.
In regards to HD, IF....IF he led Cal to believe he would be back, and he ends up leaving, then Cal was hoodwinked, no doubt about it, and it may leave the team in a bad situation.
On the other hand, were it me or my son, and I knew we could leave and make millions, then the obvious choice is to leave.
He hasn't left the team yet, so this is all speculation at this point. We HAVE to have HD or Johnson, no question. Bringing in Bamba would be huge, but not quite as important as getting one, or even both of these guys on the team next year.
We're in better shape on the front line, but we're in a precarious situation at the guard spot, as it stands right now.
As I said, I see both sides, but I strongly suggest we refrain from crucifying the young man until he makes a decision one way or another.
Peace. WW.