No what is absolutely horse crap is for a middle class person to be paying 22% of their income in taxes and a billionaire only paying 16% of their income. Which one of these people do you think is being affected more? I will bet my house you are closer to the middle income bracket than you are the billionaire bracket, but yet you defend the billionaire's bank account?
![]()
Yikes. You do realize a change in an upper-level income tax rate increase has zero impact on the comparative tax scenario you described?
That scenario (Romney's tax rate during his presidential run for example) is a result of income being treated as long-term capital gains or dividends. It's not ordinary income.
If it were all ordinary income, the billionaire would pay a significantly higher effective rate than middle America (many of which pay an effective rate close to zero).
If you want to fix that problem, cap the amount that can be treated as cap gains or dividend income. Problem solved.
And it's fundamentally wrong to create a tax scenario under which the majority of someone's earnings would go to the government. I don't care if it only applies to amounts above eleventy gagillion dollars. It's un-American.