OT: Income tax changes

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
No what is absolutely horse crap is for a middle class person to be paying 22% of their income in taxes and a billionaire only paying 16% of their income. Which one of these people do you think is being affected more? I will bet my house you are closer to the middle income bracket than you are the billionaire bracket, but yet you defend the billionaire's bank account?


Yikes. You do realize a change in an upper-level income tax rate increase has zero impact on the comparative tax scenario you described?

That scenario (Romney's tax rate during his presidential run for example) is a result of income being treated as long-term capital gains or dividends. It's not ordinary income.

If it were all ordinary income, the billionaire would pay a significantly higher effective rate than middle America (many of which pay an effective rate close to zero).

If you want to fix that problem, cap the amount that can be treated as cap gains or dividend income. Problem solved.

And it's fundamentally wrong to create a tax scenario under which the majority of someone's earnings would go to the government. I don't care if it only applies to amounts above eleventy gagillion dollars. It's un-American.
 

1Clemson

All-American
Aug 25, 2003
27,462
7,234
63
I already explained to you how we have been double taxed for forever. Even if you only want to go since income tax has become a thing, we've been paying sales tax, corporate taxes, property taxes, and income taxes for 100 years. How is taxing income fundamentally different?

There has always been some, but it has been constrained by deductibility. Property and state taxes were exempt from federal taxes, individuals have a choice in sales tax.

Taxation is inherently stealing from one group to pay for the wants of another. Earlier I gave an example of a real fair tax methodology, I could also agree to a single national sales tax.
 

ArmyTiger27

Heisman
May 22, 2005
109,832
21,554
113
Yes. The increase in the Standard Deduction from $12,700 to $24,000 coupled with the loss of the Personal Exemption means that the overall deduction is +$3,200 for Married Couple, -$850 for Married Couple with 1 Kid and -$4,900 for Married Couple with 2 kids and gets worse by $4050 for each addition child.

Single with no kids and you get an extra $1,600.

You do get an extra $1,000 Child Tax Credit, which basically makes it a wash for 1 child and the brackets in general are a little bit lower, so for some they will save some and others will owe a little bit more.

All in all the biggest winners were rich and corporations.

Thank you for stating what I couldn't. I have two children. So, again, this sucks.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,066
5,734
113
There has always been some, but it has been constrained by deductibility. Property and state taxes were exempt from federal taxes, individuals have a choice in sales tax.

Taxation is inherently stealing from one group to pay for the wants of another. Earlier I gave an example of a real fair tax methodology, I could also agree to a single national sales tax.

Ok, we have fundamentally different senses of reality. I won't waste either of our time any longer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1Clemson

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,066
5,734
113
Yikes. You do realize a change in an upper-level income tax rate increase has zero impact on the comparative tax scenario you described?

That scenario (Romney's tax rate during his presidential run for example) is a result of income being treated as long-term capital gains or dividends. It's not ordinary income.

If it were all ordinary income, the billionaire would pay a significantly higher effective rate than middle America (many of which pay an effective rate close to zero).

If you want to fix that problem, cap the amount that can be treated as cap gains or dividend income. Problem solved.

And it's fundamentally wrong to create a tax scenario under which the majority of someone's earnings would go to the government. I don't care if it only applies to amounts above eleventy gagillion dollars. It's un-American.

I agree with you on taxing capital gains as income (aren't dividends already taxed as regular income?). I think that would solve a lot of problems.

Your statement on a certain tax rate being fundamentally wrong is you just spouting your opinions that aren't based on anything. "It's fundamentally wrong to have more than $500k in assets when people are starving to death. It's un-Christian." My statement is just as fair as yours.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iceheart08

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
For the record, I don't believe you or I have ever been "drilled' by our effective tax rates. I don't think it makes sense to lower already low taxes just for the sake of doing it.

I do agree that the majority of the country has very low taxes. The middle 20% pays a low single digit effective rate. Those below that pay zero. The country relies on the achievers to actually foot the bill.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Dackel

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,066
5,734
113
I do agree that the majority of the country has very low taxes. The middle 20% pays a low single digit effective rate. Those below that pay zero. The country relies on the achievers to actually foot the bill.


That's mathematically true and I'm fine with it. I might not be quite the "achiever" that you are but it'd be disingenuous to say that I'm middle class. I'm happy to pay more in taxes in exchange for certain services (the typical liberal ones).
 

1Clemzunfan

Heisman
Nov 7, 2001
65,555
13,541
0
Yikes. You do realize a change in an upper-level income tax rate increase has zero impact on the comparative tax scenario you described?

That scenario (Romney's tax rate during his presidential run for example) is a result of income being treated as long-term capital gains or dividends. It's not ordinary income.

If it were all ordinary income, the billionaire would pay a significantly higher effective rate than middle America (many of which pay an effective rate close to zero).

If you want to fix that problem, cap the amount that can be treated as cap gains or dividend income. Problem solved.

And it's fundamentally wrong to create a tax scenario under which the majority of someone's earnings would go to the government. I don't care if it only applies to amounts above eleventy gagillion dollars. It's un-American.
The carried interest loop hole is one that should have been nixed completely instead of eliminating the ability of hard working middle class Americans like @ArmyTiger27 's ability to deduct legitimate job expenses. Or better yet, capital gains shielded by the lower rate should be capped for everyone to keep billionaires from having a lower effective tax rate than @ArmyTiger27 .

The sad thing is most of Trump's base have no idea how horrible a deal this tax reform bill was for this country and middle America long term.
 

allorangec

All-American
Aug 29, 2005
55,698
5,661
113
The carried interest loop hole is one that should have been nixed completely instead of eliminating the ability of hard working middle class Americans like @ArmyTiger27 's ability to deduct legitimate job expenses. Or better yet, capital gains shielded by the lower rate should be capped for everyone to keep billionaires from having a lower effective tax rate than @ArmyTiger27 .

The sad thing is most of Trump's base have no idea how horrible a deal this tax reform bill was for this country and middle America long term.

Don't worry, those companies throw lunches for both parties. So no matter who wins, they win.
 

twtiger03

All-Conference
Jan 4, 2006
4,678
1,861
0
Looks like my family will lose out on thousands of dollars in unclaimed mileage this year.

If you were previously claiming mileage to cover anything your company didn't, you're SOL.

This sucks!
You can still deduct mileage from running your own business correct? What was changed is the ability to deduct mileage when working for another company?
 

rabooze

All-Conference
Dec 5, 2001
1,955
2,347
0
It's funny that some people think that the people in the multi-million to billion status are some how getting a paycheck monthly for whatever it is you all believe is their annual wealth accumulation divided by 12. Bezos is considered the wealthiest man in the country. He doesn't have a billion dollars sitting in a bank account somewhere and he doest have some direct deposit where he receives $40mm monthly and can look at his SS and other deductions. And the crazy socialist who want to take all this money away from the wealthy are just jealous and don't have the drive or intelligence to build their own massive wealth themselves. They should be looking up to the industry elite, not down.
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
The carried interest loop hole is one that should have been nixed completely instead of eliminating the ability of hard working middle class Americans like @ArmyTiger27 's ability to deduct legitimate job expenses. Or better yet, capital gains shielded by the lower rate should be capped for everyone to keep billionaires from having a lower effective tax rate than @ArmyTiger27 .

The sad thing is most of Trump's base have no idea how horrible a deal this tax reform bill was for this country and middle America long term.

I'd certainly be up for capping it. Everything above some amount (say, $1M) in carried interest per person per year is ordinary income or something like that. There are areas other than hedge funds where this applies and I'm not sure a complete elimination is required. It's unfortunate that it wasn't addressed during tax reform.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1Clemzunfan

SixFiveTiger

All-American
Jan 11, 2003
6,150
6,007
113
Looks like my family will lose out on thousands of dollars in unclaimed mileage this year.

If you were previously claiming mileage to cover anything your company didn't, you're SOL.

This sucks!
This went into effect last year actually I lost out on tons of miles that use to be able to be written off I thought it was a Florida thing until my accountant told me that it's nation wide no tax reform. I am not looking forward to visiting her this year smdh
 

ArmyTiger27

Heisman
May 22, 2005
109,832
21,554
113
My question is what happens if the company can’t make a profit if it pays its employees the standard gov rate? This is terrible for small businesses.

Am I missing something here?
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
To those complaining, please review the tax rate changes below. Not only do you get a boost in your standard deduction, which helps a ton of middle income earners, but almost every dollar throughout the escalating brackets receives a 3-9% discount.



That's a 3% discount for every dollar $19K-$77K ($1,750 savings)
Another 3% discount for every dollar $77K-$156K ($7,000 savings)
A 6% discount from $156K-$165K ($540 savings)
A 4% discount from $165K-$238K ($2,920 savings)
A 9% discount from $238K-$315K ($6,930 savings)

If you made it this far, you have saved $19K through lower tax rates and outside of a narrow $25K window where you pay 1% more ($250), every additional dollar results in more savings.

Even at lower income levels, the rate savings and/or standard deduction should result in a net tax reduction.
 

whitesixmile

Heisman
Aug 30, 2015
6,362
11,052
107
I don’t understand how we keep going further and further in debt and people expect our taxes to go down. I don’t mind paying taxes I hate all the loopholes that certain people use to get out of paying taxes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ArmyTiger27

Goin Coastal

All-Conference
Apr 27, 2016
2,161
2,681
68
I don’t understand how we keep going further and further in debt and people expect our taxes to go down. I don’t mind paying taxes I hate all the loopholes that certain people use to get out of paying taxes.
The average American can't think further into the future than the tax statement in front of them. On another note, if their is a strategy that I can use to reduce my tax bill, I am going to use it.
 

cuandcofcfan

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,445
3,364
113
Looks like my family will lose out on thousands of dollars in unclaimed mileage this year.

If you were previously claiming mileage to cover anything your company didn't, you're SOL.

This sucks!
You should provide employer mileage logs, meals, hotels receipts, etc. and than can lower your W-2 by that amount.
 

cuandcofcfan

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,445
3,364
113
No, a logical fallacy is saying that the income tax is "unconstitutional" (i.e., a reference to the "constitution"), while ignoring a specific (and very explicit) provision in the Constitution that authorizes the income tax.
The general welfare clause misuse is where reality forked from law.
 

1Clemson

All-American
Aug 25, 2003
27,462
7,234
63
To those complaining, please review the tax rate changes below. Not only do you get a boost in your standard deduction, which helps a ton of middle income earners, but almost every dollar throughout the escalating brackets receives a 3-9% discount.



That's a 3% discount for every dollar $19K-$77K ($1,750 savings)
Another 3% discount for every dollar $77K-$156K ($7,000 savings)
A 6% discount from $156K-$165K ($540 savings)
A 4% discount from $165K-$238K ($2,920 savings)
A 9% discount from $238K-$315K ($6,930 savings)

If you made it this far, you have saved $19K through lower tax rates and outside of a narrow $25K window where you pay 1% more ($250), every additional dollar results in more savings.

Even at lower income levels, the rate savings and/or standard deduction should result in a net tax reduction.

Rates only matter if the taxable portion is near equal. The point of this thread is the loss of deductibility that greatly increases the taxable amount, resulting in tax increases. There is now doubt that taxpayers that did not have any deductions are greatly benefitting in effect we have moved the subsidy curve to include all those that don’t pay to add those that are now underpaying as they dont really justify the $24k standard deduction.
 

Death-ValleyTiger

All-American
Aug 3, 2006
3,534
8,037
108
It's funny that some people think that the people in the multi-million to billion status are some how getting a paycheck monthly for whatever it is you all believe is their annual wealth accumulation divided by 12. Bezos is considered the wealthiest man in the country. He doesn't have a billion dollars sitting in a bank account somewhere and he doest have some direct deposit where he receives $40mm monthly and can look at his SS and other deductions. And the crazy socialist who want to take all this money away from the wealthy are just jealous and don't have the drive or intelligence to build their own massive wealth themselves. They should be looking up to the industry elite, not down.
I agree with what you are saying but Bezos sold right at 1 billion in stock in 2017 alone. He definitely has cashed in and I bet with all of his tax experts moving that money around he didn’t pay a lot in taxes compared to the meaningless 81k he takes as salary yearly. As one other poster said they need to cap capital gains so at some point it becomes ordinary income.
 

jspears5

Joined Aug 13, 2018
Aug 4, 2008
8,799
19,112
113
So, basically what we are saying is that Dabo is going to get screwed with all these. How is he going to feed his youngest boy until his football scholarship comes through?
 

1Clemzunfan

Heisman
Nov 7, 2001
65,555
13,541
0
I'd certainly be up for capping it. Everything above some amount (say, $1M) in carried interest per person per year is ordinary income or something like that. There are areas other than hedge funds where this applies and I'm not sure a complete elimination is required. It's unfortunate that it wasn't addressed during tax reform.
I absolutely agree that it should not just be limited to hedge fund managers and carried interest. That is just an example. All capital gains above $1million should be treated as normal income.
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
Rates only matter if the taxable portion is near equal. The point of this thread is the loss of deductibility that greatly increases the taxable amount, resulting in tax increases. There is now doubt that taxpayers that did not have any deductions are greatly benefitting in effect we have moved the subsidy curve to include all those that don’t pay to add those that are now underpaying as they dont really justify the $24k standard deduction.

Sure. But you have to net out either the increase or decrease in your deduction along side the rate reductions. Then there are other beneficial factors as well like raising the AMT threshold, lower pass-through income tax, etc.

It's estimated that 94% will take the standard deduction. I fall into the 6%, but will still be better off. The folks actually paying more will likely be a very narrow band.
 

1Clemzunfan

Heisman
Nov 7, 2001
65,555
13,541
0
To those complaining, please review the tax rate changes below. Not only do you get a boost in your standard deduction, which helps a ton of middle income earners, but almost every dollar throughout the escalating brackets receives a 3-9% discount.



That's a 3% discount for every dollar $19K-$77K ($1,750 savings)
Another 3% discount for every dollar $77K-$156K ($7,000 savings)
A 6% discount from $156K-$165K ($540 savings)
A 4% discount from $165K-$238K ($2,920 savings)
A 9% discount from $238K-$315K ($6,930 savings)

If you made it this far, you have saved $19K through lower tax rates and outside of a narrow $25K window where you pay 1% more ($250), every additional dollar results in more savings.

Even at lower income levels, the rate savings and/or standard deduction should result in a net tax reduction.
I dont think you are understanding. Using mine and @ArmyTiger27 's example...

Unreimbursed job expenses, such as mileage/marketing, etc. are no longer deductible. Same for IPTAY. For me and my wife all of our deductions exceeded not just the old standard deduction, but the new one of $24k. We will still itemize because just mortgage interest, tithes, charitable giving, etc. still meets or exceeds the new standard deduction. So the standard deduction increase does not benefit us at all.

What we wont be able to do now is deduct that job expense like mileage, travel and marketing (my wife is in sales). Also, our IPTAY dues are not deductible. Let's say those add up to $30k . In @ArmyTiger27 's case it sounds like it is even more. He is looking at over $30k in mileage expense alone that he will lose. By not being able to deduct those items it means we will pay the top end tax rate for our income level on those dollars we can no longer deduct off of the top. In my case that is going to be 24%. On $30k that 24% is $7,200 in new tax that I did not owe before. That is a 24% tax INCREASE on that $30k of eliminated deductions because no tax was paid on it before. As it relates to those deductions, it doesn't matter that the rate dropped from 28% to 24%. It is a 24% tax increase on those eliminated deductions for us, not a 4% savings.

Now, we will benefit by around a 3% rate cut on our other income above $19k. That said, that ~3% cut on the balance of our taxable income does not surpass the 24% tax increase I have to pay on those eliminated deductions. It's a net loss for us. Not a huge loss, but a loss. And when you see an extra $300 million a year (at a minimum) added to the debt because of this tax reform on top of not seeing a tax savings it sucks.

The deductions that they eliminated for unreimbursed job expenses are not frivolous deductions. They are working man deductions. They are expenses that were invested into generating that income. It's a tax on money that was not pocketed or brought home to our families. And what makes me even more angry is that it was done to partially offset a significant tax cut for people much more wealthy than me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: broncosrb26

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
I dont think you are understanding. Using mine and @ArmyTiger27 's example...

Unreimbursed job expenses, such as mileage/marketing, etc. are no longer deductible. Same for IPTAY. For me and my wife all of our deductions exceeded not just the old standard deduction, but the new one of $24k. We will still itemize because just mortgage interest, tithes, charitable giving, etc. still meets or exceeds the new standard deduction. So the standard deduction increase does not benefit us at all.

What we wont be able to do now is deduct that job expense like mileage, travel and marketing (my wife is in sales). Also, our IPTAY dues are not deductible. Let's say those add up to $30k . In @ArmyTiger27 's case it sounds like it is even more. He is looking at over $30k in mileage expense alone that he will lose. By not being able to deduct those items it means we will pay the top end tax rate for our income level on those dollars we can no longer deduct off of the top. In my case that is going to be 24%. On $30k that 24% is $7,200 in new tax that I did not owe before. That is a 24% tax INCREASE on that $30k of eliminated deductions because no tax was paid on it before. As it relates to those deductions, it doesn't matter that the rate dropped from 28% to 24%. It is a 24% tax increase on those eliminated deductions for us, not a 4% savings.

Now, we will benefit by around a 3% rate cut on our other income above $19k. That said, that ~3% cut on the balance of our taxable income does not surpass the 24% tax increase I have to pay on those eliminated deductions. It's a net loss for us.

What sucks is that the deductions that they eliminated for unreimbursed job expenses are not frivolous deductions. They are working man deductions. They are expenses that were invested into generating that income. It's a tax on money that was not pocketed or brought home to our families. And what makes me even more angry is that it was done to pay for a significant tax cut for people much more wealthy than me.

I do understand. There is a reconciliation of the additional tax you pay due to lost deductions and the tax you no longer pay due to rate reductions.

Even if none of that $30K were included in the standard deduction (so you had $54,400 in total deductions), you are paying $7200 more due to these lost deductions.

If you are in the 24% bracket, you are at least getting the first 3 levels of rate reduction I outlined above, which totals $9,290 of savings. Plus, whatever additional reductions you realize in the 24% bracket. Call that an additional $1K and this scenario results in a net savings of $3K.

Obviously every situation is unique and there could be some unexpected losers in this deal, but my guess is people are bitching about losing a deduction without factoring in the the new rates and seeing how things net out.

I don't love the loss of deductions either. I pay a truckload of state and property taxes. Numerous multiples of the new cap and more than the mileage deduction above. I lose all of that and still come out ahead when you net it out.
 

1Clemzunfan

Heisman
Nov 7, 2001
65,555
13,541
0
I do understand. There is a reconciliation of the additional tax you pay due to lost deductions and the tax you no longer pay due to rate reductions.

Even if none of that $30K were included in the standard deduction (so you had $54,400 in total deductions), you are paying $7200 more due to these lost deductions.

If you are in the 24% bracket, you are at least getting the first 3 levels of rate reduction I outlined above, which totals $9,290 of savings. Plus, whatever additional reductions you realize in the 24% bracket. Call that an additional $1K and this scenario results in a net savings of $3K.

Obviously every situation is unique and there could be some unexpected losers in this deal, but my guess is people are bitching about losing a deduction without factoring in the the new rates and seeing how things net out.

I don't love the loss of deductions either. I pay a truckload of state and property taxes. Numerous multiples of the new cap and more than the mileage deduction above. I lose all of that and still come out ahead when you net it out.
Your math is wrong on your rate reduction calculations. You show a tax savings of $7,000 on 3% reduction on the income between $77k and $156k. That actually should be $2,370 in savings. Your tax savings are overstated by almost $5k which is the difference in a net gain in your example and a net loss in mine.
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,573
24,241
113
Your math is wrong on your rate reduction calculations. You show a tax savings of $7,000 on 3% reduction on the income between $77k and $156k. That actually should be $2,370 in savings. Your tax savings are overstated by almost $5k which is the difference in a net gain in your example and a net loss in mine.

Good catch. Still, you’re talking about a what, $1K net increase on a super rare corner case in which someone has deductions totaling 27% of their income? ($54K/$200K)

We’re talking fractions of a percent of the country that would be in a similar situation. And a fractional effective rate change to boot.

Not saying I wouldn’t rather it be a reduction. I would. But using a corner case to fault the bill isn’t the best either.
 

CUPLAYER1

Heisman
Sep 16, 2004
35,013
52,650
113
Yes. The increase in the Standard Deduction from $12,700 to $24,000 coupled with the loss of the Personal Exemption means that the overall deduction is +$3,200 for Married Couple, -$850 for Married Couple with 1 Kid and -$4,900 for Married Couple with 2 kids and gets worse by $4050 for each addition child.

Single with no kids and you get an extra $1,600.

You do get an extra $1,000 Child Tax Credit, which basically makes it a wash for 1 child and the brackets in general are a little bit lower, so for some they will save some and others will owe a little bit more.

All in all the biggest winners were rich and corporations.

Our preparer showed us our return last year with the new code for this year....this year was double. Married with 2 kids in the home
 

1Clemzunfan

Heisman
Nov 7, 2001
65,555
13,541
0
Good catch. Still, you’re talking about a what, $1K net increase on a super rare corner case in which someone has deductions totaling 27% of their income? ($54K/$200K)

We’re talking fractions of a percent of the country that would be in a similar situation. And a fractional effective rate change to boot.

Not saying I wouldn’t rather it be a reduction. I would. But using a corner case to fault the bill isn’t the best either.
It will impact more than you think. Many of those people in sales, of which there are a good many, stand to lose or net nothing depending on their other deductions. There are at least 4 people in this thread alone that are losing and these are middle class wage earners.

When middle class wage earners are netting nothing and in some cases losing while lower wage earners are netting an immaterial savings of $1k to $2k, it's a bad deal when anywhere from $4 Trillion to $7 Trillion dollars will be added to the deficit. That deficit spending will be to fund the material tax savings in this bill that are going to the rich and corporations who are just doing stock buybacks and raising executive salaries and bonuses. Add in the long term cost to those lower wage earners due to the deficit spending and it will cost them more than the $1k to $2k they are saving in other benefits, interest expense, stifled wages, inflation, etc. etc.
 

PICPAW

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2001
1,992
1,423
78
While the standard deduction did increase they completely removed personal exemptions, which they always fail to mention. The doubling of the deduction makes for a great headline but when you remove the $4,050 exemption you really only pick up another $2k. The biggest "losers" with the loss of the exemptions is large families.
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Dabo Swinney and the scrutiny from within
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football The day after for Clemson Football
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Pearman, Denson lead Clemson past Duke in upset win
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson upends double-digit favorite Duke 20-10
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson - Duke Postgame Notes