Official '26 PSU - Rutgers game thread

TigersandLions

Redshirt
Nov 14, 2021
36
45
18
Jeremiah Cooper and Toure had rough nights tackling. Ebel has struggled a lot this year and had some really bad missed tackles at critical moments, but to me it seems like the biggest issue with the run defense is this scheme really requires DBs who can come up and tackle. The DBs have not consistently been able to do that this year and it's led to a lot of big, gashing running plays.

Also - It should have never come down to it, and I hate be a cry baby fan, but those two phantom DPI calls on the last drive were really criminal - like warranting an investigation level of criminal. And just to cement my cry baby status - McPherson totally got picked on the last 2-point conversion. Not sure he's fast enough to have gotten out there anyway, but it was pretty blatant, especially in light of the two earlier DPI calls.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

taryn

Sophomore
Nov 1, 2020
254
198
43
There’s a level of delusion that this fanbase has to accept. Penn State is closer to Nebraska in terms of an old program that enjoyed some success 4 decades ago than it is to Ohio State which currently won a National Championship. Penn State at best could be a fringe national program like Florida or FSU except even both those programs have Modern national championships. Indiana went from statistically the worst CFB program in history to a national champion meanwhile Penn State hasn’t even come remotely close in 30 years, that’s enough proof that CFB has changed. Penn State has to drastically change course or it will be closer to NW, Nebraska, Minnesota, Wisconsin and Illinois then Ohio State, IU or Oregon.
the WILL BE part of your last sentence is HERE.
 

TigersandLions

Redshirt
Nov 14, 2021
36
45
18
Does anyone have any idea why Cam Smith got no action on defense yesterday? I thought he looked great last week and was expecting to see more of him. And then the defense was clearly gassed in the second half, but zero plays for Smith (at least that I saw). And I think I saw him on special teams so assuming it wasn't an injury issue. Never saw Brezina either - don't think he's nearly as good as Smith, but he has been getting some snaps and would have thought he'd get a few plays given the amount of time the D was on the field.
 

taryn

Sophomore
Nov 1, 2020
254
198
43
Because he has more time to use the portal to his advantage
He has to improve in a lot of areas--starting with clock management
You realize I'm not a MC fan--he wasn't a coach I wanted but he's here for at least 3 years--so root for him and hope for the best.
its called RECRUITING!!! top players seem to not warm up to this bowl of cold oatmeal.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
897
952
93
LOL--yes, now Rutgers is magically going to steal our recruits
No one has ever recruited a player to Penn State by saying Rutgers hasn't beat us in 1988
Losses like this don't hurt recruiting--kids see an oppportunity to play--all they care about is the bond with the coach and the cash
So if wins don’t matter, and they only care about cash, playing time and nond with coach, I would expect playing time is to our advantage, so we should be able to out recruit Georgia if the money is the same?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,558
4,891
113
Why does that matter if he doesn’t bond with Kirby, it makes no difference?
Kirby is arguably the best recruiter in the history of the sport
He builds elite bonds with everyone--Campbell doesn't have that ability
I'm not sure why you still have yet to be able to read something and take it at face value--actually, that's because then you'd have nothing to say
 

NedFromYork

Sophomore
Aug 29, 2001
108
112
43
Bad PIs. That Rutgers player should have been ejected for that leg twist on the Peoples tackle. Saw same thing by a Miami player in their game last night. Those should be ejections.
 
Nov 1, 2021
613
661
93
Insane that we allowed Rocco Becht to try a sneak on the goal line. Smallest guy out there plus he turned his back to the goal line.

Yes, but you absolutely cannot take a sack on 2nd down pushing the ball back to the 4. He was at the 4 with 2 defenders clearly a couple of steps away so why he didn't just fire it into the back of the endzone was unfathomable to me at the time. He is a huge part of the reason this team is 6-5 and not 8-3 or even 9-2.

The other main reason is coaching. How were they unable to get any push from the OL? How did they get so little pressure on their QB? Are you telling me that Penn State has worse talent than friggin Rutgers? If they had won by 10 last night, I'd have been worried about MC and the future, wondering if the program was gonna crash like the NASDAQ. But now I think program has crashed and your counting on the guy who crashed it to bring it back to some level of prominence.

Given enough time and money, he probably will bring PSU back to be a top 25 team but with the way he's handled the team this year, I don't see any way that we ever make it to the final four with MC at the helm.
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: taryn

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,082
21,678
113
I was running errands yesterday but had the game on in the car. Listening on the radio was brutal - especially since Jones at first called the final TD run ‘stopped’ just before the lateral. But on TV, this looks terrible. This isn’t just a PSU problem either.



 

Omar81

Senior
Nov 12, 2014
328
747
93
Insane that we allowed Rocco Becht to try a sneak on the goal line. Smallest guy out there plus he turned his back to the goal line.
Don’t forget that the “canny” (this season’s “moxie”) fifth year QB needlessly took a three yard sack when he easily could have thrown the ball away. How does Becht suck? Let me count the ways . . .
 
Nov 1, 2021
613
661
93
Well to be fair, our crackerjack offensive scheme had him about ten yards deep at the snap.
This is just one among many things wrong with the coaching. There was another 4 and 1 where again they had the RB 7 yards deep giving the D enough time to establish position and plug any gaps. If ur gonna try brute force, have they never heard of the tush push with someone besides your midget QB who can't dead lift 100 lbs? They act like they have a dominant offensive line when anyone can see that they don't.
 
Last edited:
Nov 1, 2021
613
661
93
Don’t forget that the “canny” (this season’s “moxie”) fifth year QB needlessly took a three yard sack when he easily could have thrown the ball away. How does Becht suck? Let me count the ways . . .

Yes, and the fumble near the end of the 1st half when he dropped back to pass and clearly saw the defender closing in and still held the ball like a a bag of dog poop. That gifted Rutgers 3 points that was the difference in the end.

If MC sat Becht next week and started Manske, I'd be a little more confident that he can adapt and make the changes necessary for future success, and that's not even having any confidence Manske could be much better. Anyway, I also know there is no way he'd do this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Omar81

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,558
4,891
113
Yes, and the fumble near the end of the 1st half when he dropped back to pass and clearly saw the defender closing in and still held the ball like a a bag of dog poop. That gifted Rutgers 3 points that was the difference in the end.

If MC sat Becht next week and started Manske, I'd be a little more confident that he can adapt and make the changes necessary for future success, and that's not even having any confidence Manske could be much better. Anyway, I also know there is no way he'd do this.
Yes let's start Manske and risk driving up is NIL number while ruining our chance to get a portal QB...great plan
He won't do it because he's not a complete moron
 
Nov 1, 2021
613
661
93
Yes let's start Manske and risk driving up is NIL number while ruining our chance to get a portal QB...great plan
He won't do it because he's not a complete moron

Yeah but you don't know what you have in Manske do you? Play him and if he shows you he can play then pay him. If he's meh, then get a portal QB who won't see Manske as a block to him starting.

What you're saying is that MC is planning on threading the needle: to have Manske stay at a low cost and get a high cost portal QB, and they are both equally effective as starting QBs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psumatt85

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,558
4,891
113
Yeah but you don't know what you have in Manske do you? Play him and if he shows you he can play then pay him. If he's meh, then get a portal QB who won't see Manske as a block to him starting.

What you're saying is that MC is planning on threading the needle: to have Manske stay at a low cost and get a high cost portal QB, and they are both equally effective as starting QBs.
The plan isn't to start Manske--it's to hit the portal and have him as the #2 as he continues to develop then compete to start in 2028 and 2029. 5 in 5.

You're logic is perfect--prior to this era. It doesn't work now. You simply can't do what you are asking--name a team doing that? The answer is none because a coach can't do that and build a team with the portal. It's impossible.

Michigan may have lost Carr by playing Underwood last week--everything is high risk for minimal/no reward when you're out of the playoff
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
897
952
93
Yes, and the fumble near the end of the 1st half when he dropped back to pass and clearly saw the defender closing in and still held the ball like a a bag of dog poop. That gifted Rutgers 3 points that was the difference in the end.

If MC sat Becht next week and started Manske, I'd be a little more confident that he can adapt and make the changes necessary for future success, and that's not even having any confidence Manske could be much better. Anyway, I also know there is no way he'd do this.
He missed the window.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Recruiting Rivals300 CB Damontae Butler commits to Penn State following visit
  2. 02 BWI Football How did Penn State's players perform vs. Rutgers? PFF Snap Counts & Grades
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Prediction: Penn State close to adding four-star defender
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State's Loss to Rutgers Proves Running Backs Matter
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State Sunday situation: Following historic failure, will Matt Campbell put the future in focus at Maryland?