IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

Nov 29, 2021
325
895
92
Well then, let's do this:
OSU loses to Neb
Oregon loses to Sparty and/or Wash
Indiana loses a game

Iowa to BTCG...and beats UCLA to get into the CFP!
The Walking Dead Easy Peasy GIF
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Franisdaman

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,318
29,556
113
The thing is.... Since it is humans on this committee, they are probably going to just dig in further after getting called out all week.

Bring back the computers! Yes, you can still end up with bias, but at least you can systematically reduce those and have a committee with equal conference representation sign off on the metrics used.

You can run multiple PREVIOUS seasons worth of results to see what the end results are and if that is anywhere close to how the results on the field during the playoffs finished.

Then you have the computer SET and unadjusted during the year, so there's no human element deciding based on emotions or outside pressure.

And you have someone from each of the Power 4 conferences entering the data each week and ALL FOUR better get the same numbers before the Top 25 is announced

This has to be fixed and why not now?
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
340
571
93
I think a lot of you people are losing focus on what college football is meant to be. Fretting about making the fake sec invitational tournament when you should be basking in another great Iowa football season. It's been a wonderful and fun season so far and I hope we can win out and play a quality team to end the year/start the new year..
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85Bears and 83Hawk

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,318
29,556
113
I think a lot of you people are losing focus on what college football is meant to be. Fretting about making the fake sec invitational tournament when you should be basking in another great Iowa football season. It's been a wonderful and fun season so far and I hope we can win out and play a quality team to end the year/start the new year..


I hope we can win out, too. However, the quality team we should be playing is in the 1st round of the CFP.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,318
29,556
113
His focus is where it should be. Win THIS week. Repeat next week. Then deal with it. For the folks saying he isn't "advocating for his team". Has Cignetti grousing publicly REALLY helped any the last couple of weeks?

blocking out the outside noise is huge....otherwise, they might pull another "Minnesota."

control what you can control and that is what you do today, tomorrow, etc.
 

83Hawk

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2023
1,932
4,302
113
I think a lot of you people are losing focus on what college football is meant to be. Fretting about making the fake sec invitational tournament when you should be basking in another great Iowa football season. It's been a wonderful and fun season so far and I hope we can win out and play a quality team to end the year/start the new year..
Agree.

At no point this season did I ever think Iowa would make the playoffs, because I know how this works. SEC and brand bias rule the day, and Iowa basically has to go undefeated to have a shot (maybe only 1, early loss would do it, if there aren’t enough 2 loss SEC and blue bloods to jump them).

I am enjoying this season as it is.
 

Max Rebo

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2022
899
2,491
93
As we contemplate any potential path Iowa has to move up in the rankings, we should remember that we also need to keep an eye on the teams behind us. As we've recently learned. And I wouldn't dismiss the possibility of Kentucky and/or USC jumping over us.

Both have opportunities for good wins left on their schedule, with Kentucky finishing its season against recently ranked Mizzou and newly ranked Louisville (convenient, no?). USC's game against Maryland on Saturday likely won't help them, but they could get a big boost if they beat UCLA in the regular-season finale.

USC also benefits from being a name brand, and it's been demonstrated that the committee loves the name-brand schools. Kentucky isn't much of a big brand, but they are SEC, and if the committee is committed to getting 3-4 SEC teams into the field, they might decide to give Kentucky a boost ... particularly if Tennessee loses to LSU.

This might be tin foil hat stuff, but I think that's where we live now.
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
340
571
93
What makes it fun? Is it the players that sit out or the sparse crowds?
Anticipating for the entire month of December the game. Seeing the players enjoying a fun atmosphere usually in a warm climate for all the hard work they've put into the season, and then playing a quality team. Usually a January 1 or 2 game on National TV with a ton of exposure and then opening a can of whoop *** on however shows up to play. By the time we play half of the sec invitational teams will be a forgotten memory. It's great!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 83Hawk

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,651
5,190
113
I am sure that privately kf is not happy with the committee...he's a competitor.
But he also knows that if he comes off as unfocused on the Illinois,it could leach down to players....as Saban called it " rat poison"....outside noise.

It's out of his and our control so move on to task at hand...is the right attitude.
If we lose this game or neb it will be far worse for me than getting screwed by committee...just me.
Go get em Hawkeyes!
 

Ozzie89

All-Conference
Dec 14, 2006
103,022
4,584
113
SMU laid an egg last week, but see if they can create some chaos at Notre Dame Saturday night. They've been hit/miss all year, hopefully they hit Saturday night.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: The Big Z

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,651
5,190
113
SMU laid an egg last week, but see if they can create some chaos at Notre Dame Saturday night. They've been hit/miss all year, hopefully they hit Saturday night.
I think ND is a lock unless they lose both games
Their win over #1 Miami makes them golden.

I am resigned to our fate.
We had one shot this year ..vs OSU in kinnick.
That loss sealed our fate.
 

Hawk-A-Doodle-Doo

All-Conference
Oct 1, 2001
1,013
2,865
93
He being a realist. We're playing into a stacked deck at this point, and the house (ESPN/SEC) holds all the wild cards...
Yep. It's not pessimism when it's based in cold, hard reality.

We're pis...errr....spitting into the wind with all this hand wringing and teeth gnashing.

Short of total chaos in front of us and/or SOMEHOW sneaking into and winning the BTCG, the SECFP Committee will do whatever is necessary to keep Iowa out. They made that abundantly clear with this week's rankings.

Abundantly. Unmistakably. Incontrovertibly. Crystal. Clear.
 

MAKhawks

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2001
1,788
2,762
113
As we contemplate any potential path Iowa has to move up in the rankings, we should remember that we also need to keep an eye on the teams behind us. As we've recently learned. And I wouldn't dismiss the possibility of Kentucky and/or USC jumping over us.

Both have opportunities for good wins left on their schedule, with Kentucky finishing its season against recently ranked Mizzou and newly ranked Louisville (convenient, no?). USC's game against Maryland on Saturday likely won't help them, but they could get a big boost if they beat UCLA in the regular-season finale.

USC also benefits from being a name brand, and it's been demonstrated that the committee loves the name-brand schools. Kentucky isn't much of a big brand, but they are SEC, and if the committee is committed to getting 3-4 SEC teams into the field, they might decide to give Kentucky a boost ... particularly if Tennessee loses to LSU.

This might be tin foil hat stuff, but I think that's where we live now.

It’s definitely a legit concern. Last week people were rooting for LSU to beat Texas. I get it, but then Iowa would have had another team ahead of them with LSU, because Texas wasn’t dropping below Iowa if they had lost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DuddyB and Max Rebo

MAKhawks

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2001
1,788
2,762
113
I think ND is a lock unless they lose both games
Their win over #1 Miami makes them golden.

I am resigned to our fate.
We had one shot this year ..vs OSU in kinnick.
That loss sealed our fate.

A win there would have been huge, but losing to OSU alone did not eliminate Iowa from the playoffs.
 

Ozzie89

All-Conference
Dec 14, 2006
103,022
4,584
113
Honeslt
Yep. It's not pessimism when it's based in cold, hard reality.

We're pis...errr....spitting into the wind with all this hand wringing and teeth gnashing.

Short of total chaos in front of us and/or SOMEHOW sneaking into and winning the BTCG, the SECFP Committee will do whatever is necessary to keep Iowa out. They made that abundantly clear with this week's rankings.

Abundantly. Unmistakably. Incontrovertibly. Crystal. Clear.

Yup. Id feel better if sports betting handicappers were in that room making these brackets. These old fat ******* ADs and washed up coaches isnt the way, this is insane, completely rigged system.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,318
29,556
113
I am sure that privately kf is not happy with the committee...he's a competitor.
But he also knows that if he comes off as unfocused on the Illinois,it could leach down to players....as Saban called it " rat poison"....outside noise.

It's out of his and our control so move on to task at hand...is the right attitude.
If we lose this game or neb it will be far worse for me than getting screwed by committee...just me.
Go get em Hawkeyes!

agreed. control what you can control and hopefully the committee gets fired today or tomorrow. :)
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,318
29,556
113
What Kirk is preaching to the team regarding the CFP:

"They just need to understand we have no input on this stuff other than how we play....We're trying to win the next game, simple as that. That's what we need to focus on."
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10001110101

HawksRule73

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
990
2,418
93
The thing is.... Since it is humans on this committee, they are probably going to just dig in further after getting called out all week.

Bring back the computers! Yes, you can still end up with bias, but at least you can systematically reduce those and have a committee with equal conference representation sign off on the metrics used.

You can run multiple PREVIOUS seasons worth of results to see what the end results are and if that is anywhere close to how the results on the field during the playoffs finished.

Then you have the computer SET and unadjusted during the year, so there's no human element deciding based on emotions or outside pressure.
Not sure we want the computers either. Massey, who typically has the best computer model out there, has the following:

1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. ND
4. Indiana
5. Alabama
6. Texas
7. Miami
8. OSU
9. UCLA
10. Tennessee
11. Oregon
12. Texas Tech
13. Iowa
14. Wake
15. BYU
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,382
4,239
113
Not sure we want the computers either. Massey, who typically has the best computer model out there, has the following:

1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. ND
4. Indiana
5. Alabama
6. Texas
7. Miami
8. OSU
9. UCLA
10. Tennessee
11. Oregon
12. Texas Tech
13. Iowa
14. Wake
15. BYU
Honestly, aside from Ohio State being that high (which I’m sure the computers don’t take into account significant injuries) that list makes a lot of sense to me.

The solution to take out bias in my opinion is to use a combination of computers, but also give a weight to a committee as well. If you weight the system something like 70% computers and 30% committee members then that might help dissuade bias but also not be so rigid not include things like eye test and anecdotal evidence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LetsGoHawks83

Doctor Hawktagonapus

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2025
972
1,576
93
Honestly, aside from Ohio State being that high (which I’m sure the computers don’t take into account significant injuries) that list makes a lot of sense to me.

The solution to take out bias in my opinion is to use a combination of computers, but also give a weight to a committee as well. If you weight the system something like 70% computers and 30% committee members then that might help dissuade bias but also not be so rigid not include things like eye test and anecdotal evidence.
Computer rankings that are anchored to Win-Loss. You cannot pass a team with a better record unless you reach a critical threshold of rating points for each game of disparity. All preseason biases must be eliminated from the formula before the initial rankings.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,318
29,556
113
Not sure we want the computers either. Massey, who typically has the best computer model out there, has the following:

1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. ND
4. Indiana
5. Alabama
6. Texas
7. Miami
8. OSU
9. UCLA
10. Tennessee
11. Oregon
12. Texas Tech
13. Iowa
14. Wake
15. BYU

Honestly, aside from Ohio State being that high (which I’m sure the computers don’t take into account significant injuries) that list makes a lot of sense to me.

The solution to take out bias in my opinion is to use a combination of computers, but also give a weight to a committee as well. If you weight the system something like 70% computers and 30% committee members then that might help dissuade bias but also not be so rigid not include things like eye test and anecdotal evidence.

Yeah, not sure how computers could account for significant injuries. We all know Ohio State is a shell of itself right now....

All I know is the current system is a disaster. SEC folks are ok with it, of course....
 
  • Like
Reactions: DuddyB
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2028 recruiting class
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Tracking where Iowa's recruits play this week
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Illinois' starters as recruits
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Throwback Thursday: Looking back at Iowa's starters as recruits
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Basketball Ben McCollum talks recruiting, previews Xavier