Immaculate Conception 33, Byron 14, FINAL

Swansa01

Senior
Aug 10, 2017
444
434
63
Football enrollment was whichever number was greater, your actual enrollment or the average enrollment of all of your opponents. That number determined your class for the playoffs. So teams like IC likely would have been playing in 5A or higher.

For a few years Morris was in a weird conference and despite an enrollment of around 900 they were in 6A due to playing larger schools all year.
I remember that. My senior year at Sterling (02-03), we ended up in the 6A playoffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
829
585
93
Golfing out in Byron today and was told that a few Byron key players didn’t play because of getting caught at a party.

So throw that into the IC shouldn’t be in 3A multiplier equation
 
  • Haha
Reactions: OnlyTheBest
Jul 3, 2025
819
788
93
Golfing out in Byron today and was told that a few Byron key players didn’t play because of getting caught at a party.

So throw that into the IC shouldn’t be in 3A multiplier equation
Nah, what you have there is this thing public school fanboys carry in their wallets like condoms... Goes by a few names... an excuse nonetheless... helps them find peace at night alone in their beds after such a devastating halt to their dreams.

It's always hilarious how puffy the chests get when they beat a private school... but how "wittle ole us" they act when they get their butts kicked by one.

I still get a big smile whenever some Camp Point dad pops off about Althoff... Honestly 2nd only to (in terms of funny for me with Adams County HS football teams) QHS getting sent or sent to a CCL every year for their playoff dismissal game. 😭 :coffee: ;)
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
Is the IC QB playing this week?
If he doesn’t, what’s the game plan? Against Johnsburg the backup threw four tds in the second quarter. Last week he played about a third of the game and thew four passes total. A safety played the other time and threw no passes
 

eagles2k3!

Junior
Aug 29, 2025
294
232
43
This argument will never end. I've seen it here on edgytim since 2000 with the RB/JCA folks. I've honestly been on both sides now that I'm far removed from my high school days. Yes there is an advantage athletically(and academically for some) for private schools. I think this conversation needs to be done because it will never go away unless private schools separate from the IHSA. Even if there were a 3.0 multiplier I still think there would be issues at the higher classes. IC beat Ignatius, who is now in the semifinals of 8A! What do you think they would do to most 5-6a public schools? I know for a fact the IHSA does not want a separation to happen anyway.

I see both sides of the argument, because I cheer for teams on both sides. Yes I wanted Morris to beat Montini, Cary Grove to beat SF, and I wanted Harlem to beat ND, but I also wanted Mt. Carmel to beat LWE and St. Ignatius to beat Maine South. I have my own reasons for those. I'm a traditionalist and I also like an underdog. There is no tradition like Mt. Carmel and I just don't like LWE. St. Ignatius was an underdog and I just don't like Maine South. How can you not like the Morris program too? I've always disliked Montini because I hated playing against them in high school. CG is a personal connection and Harlem has never been this far before. I kinda felt bad for ND losing, but I also liked seeing someone new make the semis.

For those of us that have been around Edgytim since the turn of the millenium these are recycled conversations. It's the same argument today. RB mom or whatever her name was said the exact same things. The only difference now is that public schools are getting transfers too and are getting caught breaking rules sometimes(cough swagger cough).

I don't know the right answer. I used to think the answer was separating the schools, but do I really want to see November without the usual suspects? Idk. I do feel for the public schools who have a once in a lifetime team. It sucks for them to lose to someone who is in the semis or finals every single year. Longwinded answer that doesn't really solve anything.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
This argument will never end. I've seen it here on edgytim since 2000 with the RB/JCA folks. I've honestly been on both sides now that I'm far removed from my high school days. Yes there is an advantage athletically(and academically for some) for private schools. I think this conversation needs to be done because it will never go away unless private schools separate from the IHSA. Even if there were a 3.0 multiplier I still think there would be issues at the higher classes. IC beat Ignatius, who is now in the semifinals of 8A! What do you think they would do to most 5-6a public schools? I know for a fact the IHSA does not want a separation to happen anyway.

I see both sides of the argument, because I cheer for teams on both sides. Yes I wanted Morris to beat Montini, Cary Grove to beat SF, and I wanted Harlem to beat ND, but I also wanted Mt. Carmel to beat LWE and St. Ignatius to beat Maine South. I have my own reasons for those. I'm a traditionalist and I also like an underdog. There is no tradition like Mt. Carmel and I just don't like LWE. St. Ignatius was an underdog and I just don't like Maine South. How can you not like the Morris program too? I've always disliked Montini because I hated playing against them in high school. CG is a personal connection and Harlem has never been this far before. I kinda felt bad for ND losing, but I also liked seeing someone new make the semis.

For those of us that have been around Edgytim since the turn of the millenium these are recycled conversations. It's the same argument today. RB mom or whatever her name was said the exact same things. The only difference now is that public schools are getting transfers too and are getting caught breaking rules sometimes(cough swagger cough).

I don't know the right answer. I used to think the answer was separating the schools, but do I really want to see November without the usual suspects? Idk. I do feel for the public schools who have a once in a lifetime team. It sucks for them to lose to someone who is in the semis or finals every single year. Longwinded answer that doesn't really solve anything.

I know of 3 public schools still playing that have “homeless” players. Everyone tries to bend the rules. The one thing I think is different is private schools are getting kids from much further now. Was IC recruiting kids from Elgin, Hampshire, Bolingbrook..etc 20 years ago?
 
  • Like
Reactions: k1867

eagles2k3!

Junior
Aug 29, 2025
294
232
43
I know of 3 public schools still playing that have “homeless” players. Everyone tries to bend the rules. The one thing I think is different is private schools are getting kids from much further now. Was IC recruiting kids from Elgin, Hampshire, Bolingbrook..etc 20 years ago?
No. Not at all. In 2008 when they won state the kids on that team were almost all from Elmhurst, Bensenville, with some Melrose and Berkley mixed in. Lots of legacies.

Times have changed.

Montini used to be mostly Lombard, Villa Park, Downers and some Oak Brook.
Driscoll was Addison, Wood Dale, Bloomingdale, and some Itasca/Roselle.
Marmion was heavy Aurora, St. Charles, Geneva.
St. Francis was almost all Wheaton, We-go, and Glen Ellyn.
Marian Central had a monopoly on McHenry County so kids drove a little further to get there.

Your "homeless" point means that some school registrars aren't doing their jobs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Connorstallions

eaglepwr47

Freshman
Sep 19, 2026
85
99
18
No. Not at all. In 2008 when they won state the kids on that team were almost all from Elmhurst, Bensenville, with some Melrose and Berkley mixed in. Lots of legacies.

Times have changed.

Montini used to be mostly Lombard, Villa Park, Downers and some Oak Brook.
Driscoll was Addison, Wood Dale, Bloomingdale, and some Itasca/Roselle.
Marmion was heavy Aurora, St. Charles, Geneva.
St. Francis was almost all Wheaton, We-go, and Glen Ellyn.
Marian Central had a monopoly on McHenry County so kids drove a little further to get there.

Your "homeless" point means that some school registrars aren't doing their jobs.
McKinney Vento law makes it very easy to claim homelessness- if you claim to be “in transition” and sleeping at a relatives, family friend, etc a school legally has to accept you. The owner of the residencd you are taking up just has to fill out a form saying they have taken them in and the school can’t reject them.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
McKinney Vento law makes it very easy to claim homelessness- if you claim to be “in transition” and sleeping at a relatives, family friend, etc a school legally has to accept you. The owner of the residencd you are taking up just has to fill out a form saying they have taken them in and the school can’t reject them.

I was going to say I didn’t think a school could reject a student that was homeless. I don’t think they can even look into it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k1867

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
No. Not at all. In 2008 when they won state the kids on that team were almost all from Elmhurst, Bensenville, with some Melrose and Berkley mixed in. Lots of legacies.

Times have changed.

Montini used to be mostly Lombard, Villa Park, Downers and some Oak Brook.
Driscoll was Addison, Wood Dale, Bloomingdale, and some Itasca/Roselle.
Marmion was heavy Aurora, St. Charles, Geneva.
St. Francis was almost all Wheaton, We-go, and Glen Ellyn.
Marian Central had a monopoly on McHenry County so kids drove a little further to get there.

Your "homeless" point means that some school registrars aren't doing their jobs.

I know times have changed and I think if you’re paying you should be able to send your kids wherever you want. At the same time I’m sure the DG panthers youth football program sending kids all over the ccl is part of the reason that proposal was made. I know of other schools in DuPage that were made that southside ccl schools were showing up there to recruit. I’m sure part of the reason they have to go further out is the declining enrollments and the change of demographics. I saw recently the Hinsdale schools are down 10% enrollment since 2019.
 

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
343
381
63
I know of 3 public schools still playing that have “homeless” players. Everyone tries to bend the rules. The one thing I think is different is private schools are getting kids from much further now. Was IC recruiting kids from Elgin, Hampshire, Bolingbrook..etc 20 years ago?
Bolingbrook and Elgin are within the 30 mile radius. Hampshire is not.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
Bolingbrook and Elgin are within the 30 mile radius. Hampshire is not.

Point being that 10-20 years ago teams like IC were going that far to get players. Now on instagram I see a kid from evergreen park putting out his “top 10” and ic is in it. Before Josiah Wallace transfered to GBW he was going to mt Carmel all the way from Glendale heights
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave Brody
Aug 15, 2025
191
204
43
Point being that 10-20 years ago teams like IC were going that far to get players. Now on instagram I see a kid from evergreen park putting out his “top 10” and ic is in it. Before Josiah Wallace transfered to GBW he was going to mt Carmel all the way from Glendale heights
That doesn't mean that IC is "recruiting" that kid, or any kid, to play football. Athletic recruiting, regardless if done by private or public schools, is against IHSA rules and should be investigated and punished if found to be true.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,712
4,443
113
No. Not at all. In 2008 when they won state the kids on that team were almost all from Elmhurst, Bensenville, with some Melrose and Berkley mixed in. Lots of legacies.

Times have changed.

Montini used to be mostly Lombard, Villa Park, Downers and some Oak Brook.
Driscoll was Addison, Wood Dale, Bloomingdale, and some Itasca/Roselle.
Marmion was heavy Aurora, St. Charles, Geneva.
St. Francis was almost all Wheaton, We-go, and Glen Ellyn.
Marian Central had a monopoly on McHenry County so kids drove a little further to get there.

Your "homeless" point means that some school registrars aren't doing their jobs.
I'll add that for SF they have always had Naperville kids all the way back to 90's. Now obviously every year is different but Naperville kids go/went to SF.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
On instagram the IC football account reposted a commitment post of a kid from Algonquin. Between stuff like that and their coaching and the football account reposting kids highlights and tagging themselves at the games. I can see why public schools would get annoyed.
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,420
3,032
113
On instagram the IC football account reposted a commitment post of a kid from Algonquin. Between stuff like that and their coaching and the football account reposting kids highlights and tagging themselves at the games. I can see why public schools would get annoyed.
The one I saw on their page was closer to IC - a kid thanking all his youth coaches from the Leyden Bears, and talking about his official “commitment” to coach Kreft and IC.

Successful programs are gonna attract good players. Especially in this day and age. Grade school kids emulating what they see from the college recruits.

Even when Bowen and his class moves on, I doubt that IC as a whole has a big drop off in talent.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
The one I saw on their page was closer to IC - a kid thanking all his youth coaches from the Leyden Bears, and talking about his official “commitment” to coach Kreft and IC.

Successful programs are gonna attract good players. Especially in this day and age. Grade school kids emulating what they see from the college recruits.

Even when Bowen and his class moves on, I doubt that IC as a whole has a big drop off in talent.

the kid plays for Leyden bears but lives in Algonquin. I get why kids are making commitment posts but now many schools are reposting that or posting highlights of kids they are recruiting.

we will see how they do in the future. They lose a ton off of this years team
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doctor_D

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,712
4,443
113
the kid plays for Leyden bears but lives in Algonquin. I get why kids are making commitment posts but now many schools are reposting that or posting highlights of kids they are recruiting.

we will see how they do in the future. They lose a ton off of this years team
Bowen is a Jr, they will be real good next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave Brody
Aug 20, 2026
589
301
63
the kid plays for Leyden bears but lives in Algonquin. I get why kids are making commitment posts but now many schools are reposting that or posting highlights of kids they are recruiting.

we will see how they do in the future. They lose a ton off of this years team
Grant Bowen, Jakobe Baldwin, and Will Schmidt, arguably their three best players, all have at least one more year. I don't think there's going to be a big dropoff.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
204
189
31
Grant Bowen, Jakobe Baldwin, and Will Schmidt, arguably their three best players, all have at least one more year. I don't think there's going to be a big dropoff.

they also have Sallis who has p4 offers and 2 lineman back. They lose their starting qb, pena, carrocio, Shaw, Sebastian. and some other kids that are very good high school players

for a 3a school that’s an insane amount of talent but they had a lot of holes to fill. They will be active in the transfer portal
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,712
4,443
113
they also have Sallis who has p4 offers and 2 lineman back. They lose their starting qb, pena, carrocio, Shaw, Sebastian. and some other kids that are very good high school players

for a 3a school that’s an insane amount of talent but they had a lot of holes to fill. They will be active in the transfer portal
Or...just maybe, they have underclassment ready to fill in?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim 5A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 4A: Semifinalist Player of the Year