Was Pope's first year really that great?

UKWildcats1987

Heisman
Sep 9, 2021
21,263
38,405
113
Above average UK season.

Won like 8 top 25 games but lost 8 games by double digits. He did beat duke and UL and UT (until it mattered most). With the injuries and new coach and system and tough schedule it was a solid season. Nothing special.
 
Jul 17, 2025
246
258
43
Yes, it was a good year. Not outstanding or amazing but a good season and likely would have been even more fruitful with better health.

There is no need to retroactively spin damn solid into crap because of subsequent falling down on the job, there is PLENTY of material to focus on last year and how this one has started.

I don't much care about ten losses, depending on the specific losses.

The SEC is now so tough that may be a top 4 seed now. I think Cal's last year we were right around there and got a 2 that went to waste by being first round suckers.

What I do care about is that the offensive guru can't manage to put a good product on the floor even on that side of the ball.
Now all that can be mustered is a ton of iso ball with a side order of zoom and a lot of standing around. You land the best shooter in the nation and get him 5-9 shots a game.

Struggle to score, defense is sad, and rebounding absent so what in the world are we doing?
 

JonathanW2

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2025
662
1,005
93
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882
I don't think I've seen ANYONE claim Pope's 1st (or 2nd) season "was great".
And I'm not a Pope-pumper, I think we've seen enough to know he wasn't the right choice.
But, his first season was "solid", once you consider other factors. Like we lost 50 games from top 9 rotation guys, with 36 games coming from the important PG spot. That doesn't include the games Butler & Carr played at <100%. We lost our starting PG for 9 games plus he played several more at <100%, we lost the backup PG for the last 3/4 of the season, and we lost the 3rd string PG (starting wing) the last 1/3 of the season. You are blind or biased to not acknowledge all of that would be very impactful.
Now injuries happen, and a coach should construct a team to succeed even with a reasonable amount of injuries, but when they all come at the same position, that makes it really tough.
That said, I think many don't/didn't say it was a "great season", but rather that it "was good enough under the injury circumstances" to give him a 2nd chance (year 2).

Now year 2, had a comparable level of injuries, also with PG being the co-primary target position. But the other co-primary injured position was a huge risk Pope took (relying on the health of a guy 6mo off major knee surgery). So to some degree, the impact of year 2 injuries were self-inflicted by Pope. There were a few good moments, but less than the year before. AND just from watching the team, you could just tell it wasn't well constructed, all the pieces didn't seem to fit together. After year 2, many believed "we've seen enough, this ain't working", but a few weren't quite sold on that.

I'm afraid year 3 is going to go much like year 2 in terms of successes and failures, minus the injuries. I was concerned back in the summer that 1) this team was built to be BAD at rebounding; and NOT Good at defense. And that's what we've seen so far. Also I thought many on here were too optimistic on Momcilovic, with me thinking that he wouldn't get the open looks, making him a good shooter instead of a great shooter, and his rebounding and defense would be big liabilities.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,931
63,111
113
Its starting to feel like it was just a perfect collection of 5-year players. No one was neccesarily electric at their positions (speed, power, etc) but id argue that our top7 or so guys just so smart in their roles, high basketball IQ.. that someone like Amari Williams WAS one of the best centers that year or Kobe Brea best wings, despite knowing that neither guy was gonna have an NBA career.
 

howitis_rivals115807

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2001
4,951
1,537
113
Its starting to feel like it was just a perfect collection of 5-year players. No one was neccesarily electric at their positions (speed, power, etc) but id argue that our top7 or so guys just so smart in their roles, high basketball IQ.. that someone like Amari Williams WAS one of the best centers that year or Kobe Brea best wings, despite knowing that neither guy was gonna have an NBA career.
it took a perfect collection of players for pope to lose 12 games, and be blown out by teams like Ohio state and Georgia?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Snarks

Goingfor9

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2003
16,576
3,693
113
It’s great if that’s your baseline I don’t think people thought that each season the program will get worse
 

dynastydreamuk

All-Conference
Nov 18, 2010
1,941
1,621
113
Just going to add my 2 cents:

To me the first year was below average.

Simply we finished 24-12
10 and 8 for SIXTH in the SEC !!!
Did nothing in the sec tournament
Got blasted in the sweet 16 by a team we had beaten twice already (We beat Tenn in strange fashion twice with huge comebacks and them missing an unusual amount of threes)

I just remember it as losing a bunch of games and some games being down a whole bunch of points.

I do think we could have won 3 more games had we been healthy.

That team had talent, butler was a final four point guard. Jaxton Robinson was an nba caliber talent up and coming prior to injury.
Amari was one of a kind big man.
 

Lameguy

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2026
766
1,383
93
I was at the Texas game that year. twice we passed the ball to a texas player on accident. It was comical. we were down 15 pts to Vandy and Georgia at half time that year too.
What I remember about that Georgia game was that UG was allowed to maul the Ky players but Ky got called for breathing on them. The FTs were 38-19 in attempts. I honestly think Pope seeing that physical play was tolerated is why he recruit MoD and JQ, which as we know was a waste. Carr, Williams, Robinson and Almanor all had 4 fouls with Williams only getting 13 minutes.
 

Lameguy

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2026
766
1,383
93
They weren't. They were like all of his teams. Wildly inconsistent. When your teams are soft defensively and rely on shooting the 3 well to be successful, this is the result. It's not sustainable. That team had dudes that knew how to play. Full of 4 and 5 year players. Even when healthy, they still laid eggs. It's just what his teams do, and it's too bad.
After the 8th game they were never fully healthy
 

Cats192

Heisman
Apr 22, 2011
14,928
17,879
93
It was a really good season considering all of the context. I don't want to defend Mark Pope's coaching going forward. I hope they fire him before the sun rises tomorrow.

It was his 1st season. A lot of REALLY good basketball coaches have had losing records in their first season. Todd Golden was 16-17 and went to the NIT in his first year at Florida.

Pope was hired way too late, and really had to rush to throw together a roster.

24 wins in year 1 is actually pretty strong for anyone.
Not only making the NCAA tournament, but getting to the Sweet 16 in year 1 is also pretty strong.

Then you consider: We didn't have a PG for big chunks of the season. We didn't have Jaxon Robinson for key stretches. I think if we had been fully healthy, we could have been an Elite 8 or even a Final 4 team.

And that gives you SO much hope for the future. For a coach to be able to do that year 1 with the things he had to overcome, it would stand to reason that the future should be bright.

Instead, that season seems like the outlier. Mark Pope can't even motivate these guys to run fast and jump hard. If we barely beat NAU, we may not even make the tournament. He should resign and let someone else try to save us all from disaster and embarrassment.
 

Dr.LutherSan

All-American
Sep 6, 2019
4,588
9,217
113
If the head coach wasn't a former player I don't think the opinion of the season would be as favorable. His biggest win was the introductory press conference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cornbreadnmilk

RedwoodHigh

All-Conference
Nov 18, 2025
1,027
1,650
113
That team was fun & exciting to watch. Like a box of chocolates in a way.
This board complained about Amari the most but it was definitely shortchanged by injuries.
I like our current team but my faith & hope in Pope has finally hit the fan watching his administration of the program.
 

Comebakatz3

Heisman
Aug 8, 2008
44,356
34,250
113
I think the key part of this is that it was his first year and he had a relatively short period of time to do recruiting and to get guys from the portal. To my knowledge, he was hired by UK just 4 days before the portal opened. That is a very short amount of time to hire a staff and get in to evaluate players and who might be able/willing to come to UK and who might fit the scheme. So, one could certainly argue that he was having to do a lot of stuff while on a very short timeline and without a full and established staff to help him. Despite this, he got some solid players and then put together a team that made a Sweet 16 run, and probably could have had an even better year but for injuries.

So, I would argue that it wasn't necessarily that the 2024/2025 was amazing, but it was strong enough to give us hope that with more time to evaluate, recruit and build relationships with possible recruits/transfers that Pope could put together and even stronger and more successful roster.

Clearly that was fools hope.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,931
63,111
113
it took a perfect collection of players for pope to lose 12 games, and be blown out by teams like Ohio state and Georgia?

Kind of tells you how bad Pope has been with game prep, motivation, etc.

When i talk about that year 1 team, I more see it as random luck for Pope.. to be able to land like 6 5th year players who all played their roles to perfection. Its not like he scouted them. It was an 11th hour haul from a very very small pool of players who were still an option.

And while they played exceptionally well some games.. they also had games where they were totally unfocused, and other games where more talented teams held them in check. While I liked that team, they werent world beaters. None of them will have any sort of meaningful NBA career, some of them might not even be overseason.
 

Dward13

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2008
10,418
1,936
72
If UK had got Chaz Lanier who went to Tennessee instead of Jaxson Robinson, that would have completed the team. They needed a guy who could create a shot with the shot clock winding down. I also wished Pope could have kept Thiero from transferring to Arkansas.

I really liked Thiero as a lot of us did. I was screaming in year 1 he should have been getting Livingston’s minutes. But Cal was being held hostage by Klutch because we had two of their clients signed for the next class as well (Edwards and Bradshaw)
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,931
63,111
113
I really liked Thiero as a lot of us did. I was screaming in year 1 he should have been getting Livingston’s minutes. But Cal was being held hostage by Klutch because we had two of their clients signed for the next class as well (Edwards and Bradshaw)

Id love to know what was really going on with the roster rotations. Was it Klutch? Was it also promises to parents/kids to get them on campus? The DJ Wagner recruitment was kind of wavering in the end.. I have to believe he made promises to his camp. And that meant continuing to play him at whatever the cost.

It seems he was held hostage by guys like Wagner and Edward's and BJ Boston. But thats his own fault for allowing it to happen.

If Cal just found a pair of balls and played Reed/Dilly much earlier (as they should have) he might still be here coaching.
 

ukcats12

Freshman
Mar 23, 2024
54
97
18
People were blinded by beating Duke and Gonzaga right off the bat and it made the season look much better than it was. It's undeniable we had some incredible wins that year, you can't match the most top 25 wins in a season without doing that. But if you actually look back at some of those wins you can see how damn lucky a good deal of them were.

Duke was handling us quite easily and we were on the road to the first (of many more) big losses. Then Maluach got hurt and never returned and we made a comeback.

The win against Florida was literally the most efficient offensive performance of any team in college basketball all year long. If we played that game 100 more times we wouldn't have recreated that. Sometimes teams just get incredibly hot and that was one of those games.

The win at Tennessee was 95% because for some reason a physical defensive team decided to shoot like 40 3s and miss all of them. If they just play their normal game we don't win.

That year was fool's gold.
 

CrimsonCats_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2022
1,814
3,757
61
It wasn’t amazing in absolute terms, but it felt much more hopeful than not at the time. He had to come in and build literally an entire roster out of the portal on short notice and without a full staff, then went out and won a lot of big games, which you can’t completely handwave away when trying to evaluate fan reactions at the time. Even the tournament exit felt somewhat excusable because we were legitimately devastated by injuries by that point (Robinson and Kriisa out, Butler and Carr trying to play at well below 100%). It seemed like a good foundation for a new coach to build on going forward.

Unfortunately, it now instead looks like his high water mark, and some of the cracks were definitely already showing in hindsight. Several of the big wins required some combination of opponent injuries, improbable comebacks, or perfect storm performances, and the baffling losses were there early on starting with the Ohio State debacle. Not that I fault anyone for being fairly happy with it at the time, heck, I was one of them. Sometimes you just need a little more time and data to contextualize what you’re seeing, and that first season is definitely losing luster the more context we get.
 

MbergCat

Heisman
Nov 23, 2014
7,709
14,623
113
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882
Long story short, yes and no. No, it was not a great season. Yes, it was fun.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
49,262
91,064
113
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882
I’d say injuries cost us probably 6 games or so. It was a really solid year. Nothing world breaking but it was a great start considering what he dealt with. Downhill ever since.
 

Ukbrassowtipin

Heisman
Aug 12, 2011
82,415
90,533
113
We keep talking about how amazing Pope’s first year was, and we keep wondering what happened to the offense. But was that first year really great?

We beat Duke and looked amazing against Florida at home, but other than that, we were pretty much the same team Pope has had the past two years. We lost to unranked teams, frequently fell behind by 10+ points, and had to come from behind to win some games.

Just look at these losses. They were all against unranked teams, and many of them were blowouts.

DateOpponentResultKentucky ScoreOpponent Score
Tue, Dec 3, 2024@ ClemsonL6670
Sat, Dec 21, 2024vs. Ohio StateL6585
Tue, Jan 7, 2025@ GeorgiaL6982
Sat, Jan 25, 2025@ VanderbiltL6974
Sat, Feb 1, 2025vs. ArkansasL7989
Sat, Feb 15, 2025@ TexasL7882
I think all those teams, minus ohio state made the tournament.

We had the most top 25 wins that year of anyone in the best conference in not just sec history but college history.

With that being said, you could see he was clueless on how to defend anyone. We just had ppl that could light it up. Which that type of offense has completely disappeared from his teams.

Also, you had ppl that were already leaders like butler and Williams and everyone accepted their role. Ill give him.a pass bc of the injuries we had but there were things to be optimistic about....like hopefully he could figure out D and rebounding. He hasn't
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie
Jun 30, 2025
599
924
93
It was a fine season that exceeded expectations despite numerous injuries to key contributors.

It's not Cal's first season by any stretch, but it was a good enough foundation to expect a quality team in the succeeding season.
 

defactorial

Redshirt
Oct 19, 2025
15
46
13
beating Duke started it off on a positive note and then every loss you could just pivot back to that moment and make any excuse you want.

folks would say pope was unlucky with injuries, but i always felt he got lucky in his biggest wins. the 5 biggest wins that year: duke, gonzaga, ut x2 and uf
  • duke: 1-12 from three in the 2nd half, 4-24 for the game
  • gonzaga: 0-9 from three in the 2nd half
  • tenn game 1: took 45 three point shots, made 11 but that is a ton of 3s
  • tenn game 2: 3-18 from three
uf was a great win and was one of the best games i've seen in a while. you can always play the "what-if" game, but considering how bad defense/rebounding has been under pope i view these 3 point shooting numbers more of a team getting cold vs us playing great defense and causing missed shots.

if those teams just shoot bad from three instead of missing everything, pope probably loses half those games. in which uk is now a 5, 6 or 7 seed in the NCAAT. and his first year isnt viewed the same at all.

but at the end of the day.....he won those games.
Kentucky only won the UF game because Brea went 7/9 from 3 on some insane shots. Florida scored 1.40 PPP, which is so elite that they are the only team to ever lose a game in NCAA history while putting up 1.40+ PPP. The next game, Brea shot 2/9 from 3 and UK lost to Georgia.
 

megablue

Heisman
Oct 2, 2012
17,064
18,013
113
Yes ... we were pretty damn good !!! Easily, Pope's best team here. With 7 Seniors, 6 of them were fifth-year players, and 4 were 1000-point college scorers, how could we NOT be pretty good ??? We had an arsenal of experienced and proven college players ... who were hungry and played together.

NOTE: I'm not sure, but I think we were the most experienced team in the history of college basketball ... ????
 
Last edited:

Snarks

All-American
Jan 31, 2005
8,954
8,297
93
It’s revisionist history, most people remember big wins like beating Duke but forget we finished 6th in the SEC.

I think most also thought that would be the worst Pope team (limited time to assemble team), not the peak Pope team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hitman206

Snarks

All-American
Jan 31, 2005
8,954
8,297
93
Above average UK season.

Won like 8 top 25 games but lost 8 games by double digits. He did beat duke and UL and UT (until it mattered most). With the injuries and new coach and system and tough schedule it was a solid season. Nothing special.
When is finishing 6th in conference and not making the weekend of the SEC tournament an above average season?
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky Drops Out of 12-Team Field in Latest CFP Top 25 Rankings
  2. 02 KSR Football CFP Rankings Reaction: How Does Kentucky Get Back Into 12-Team Field?
  3. 03 KSR Football Recruiting Kentucky Flips Trinity TE Jack Stivers
  4. 04 KSR Basketball KenPom is struggling to find SEC wins for Kentucky
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Grambling State win and take an early look at Indiana