Big Ten Teams had a lot more NIL than we did

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
6,038
7,368
97
The reason I would not consider the Rutgers win an upset is because Washington lost every road game that season and won every home game at Huskey Stadium. True to form Washington lost on the road in Piscataway. The story of the 2024 Washington season is not 1 win away from Home.
It was a good win, the type of game we should be winning on a regular basis against similar teams. We favored by 1.5-2.5 points though so not an upset
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
Of course, the answer is that they now have better coaching. So you're totally right.

It may be a lot easier to improve a program at UCLA with its beautiful campus, great academics, and record of athletic success than at most schools. Still, Schiano has had plenty of time to achieve similar success here, and instead the program is going backward.
We didn’t give him what we asked for, so recruiting has been especially difficult, and below expectations. He asked for a Fieldhouse and adequate NIL support, none of which has been provided till this point. This is the first year we should have adequate NIL support, but it’s been a long time coming.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: newell138 and psu83

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,976
10,155
58
We didn’t give him what we asked for, so recruiting has been especially difficult, and below expectations. He asked for a Fieldhouse and adequate NIL support, none of which has been provided till this point. This is the first year we should have adequate NIL support, but it’s been a long time coming.
Sometimes one has to learn to do more with less. And I find it hard to believe that a fieldhouse, while very desirable, is crucial in attracting recruits. BTW, aren't we spending up to the cap established in the House settlement?
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,836
9,074
113
Sometimes one has to learn to do more with less. And I find it hard to believe that a fieldhouse, while very desirable, is crucial in attracting recruits. BTW, aren't we spending up to the cap established in the House settlement?
Schiano is on record saying facilities specifically a fieldhouse is not a priority. Yet our resident excuse provider continues to sing that song.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
Sometimes one has to learn to do more with less. And I find it hard to believe that a fieldhouse, while very desirable, is crucial in attracting recruits. BTW, aren't we spending up to the cap established in the House settlement?
Why should a recruit choose a place which offers less, when they have many other options which offer more, like every other Big Ten School? This is making it very difficult to recruit. Nearly every school is going above the cap, so it’s not a serious constraint. OSU is spending $50M+ on football alone. USC and Indiana are spending close to $40M.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: newell138 and psu83
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
Schiano is on record saying facilities specifically a fieldhouse is not a priority. Yet our resident excuse provider continues to sing that song.
It’s not a priority because there’s not enough support. Can’t make it a priority if you don’t have funds to initiate construction. So it’s on the back burner, and may never happen. Need $100M in private funds, and Rutgers will bond the rest. But millions were spent on designs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,976
10,155
58
Why should a recruit choose a place which offers less, when they have many other options which offer more, like every other Big Ten School? This is making it very difficult to recruit. Nearly every school is going above the cap, so it’s not a serious constraint. OSU is spending $50M+ on football alone. USC and Indiana are spending close to $40M.
"You've got a better chance to play here." We see players transfer to lesser schools all the time because the most important thing to them is to play. The same operates in recruitment. Beside, IMHO, Rutgers football ought to be able to be at least mediocre, rather than the patsy it has turned into. What is the most surprising is that even the defense is bad, and defense has always been considered Schiano's specialty.,
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,444
13,327
113
We didn’t give him what we asked for, so recruiting has been especially difficult, and below expectations. He asked for a Fieldhouse and adequate NIL support, none of which has been provided till this point. This is the first year we should have adequate NIL support, but it’s been a long time coming.

Perfect.

So we won't have a "Can't expect Rutgers to compete" thread next year?
Since we'll have adequate NIL support?

" @rutgersal_rivals139582 - no more NIL excuses in 2027!!"
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,836
9,074
113
It’s not a priority because there’s not enough support. Can’t make it a priority if you don’t have funds to initiate construction. So it’s on the back burner, and may never happen. Need $100M in private funds, and Rutgers will bond the rest. But millions were spent on designs.
No it’s not a priority because he moved on from the infrastructure arms race. Just like every other program in the country.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob from NJ

matei

Freshman
Feb 16, 2026
46
76
17
Had we had competitive Big Ten NIL, we would have had a quarterback who could have beaten BC and UMass.
We should have beaten UMass with our third string team.

when you’re a 30+ point favorite, the game should be over when you step in the field.
Rutgers should have beaten UMass with ME as QB.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,707
151,547
113
Clueless as usual. Rutgers spent millions on a study which said otherwise. We need a Fieldhouse to be competitive. Every other Big Ten School has one, especially UCLA. We do not, which makes it more difficult to recruit. Even Maryland has one, as does Penn State.

View attachment 1535250
More lies. UCLA does not have a field house or a stadium. They have a modest facility that is way smaller than the Hale center. Rutgers has 3 practice fields including two grass and turf. UCLA has two half turf fields next each other. UCLA plays in an antiquated tired stadium an hour from campus that they lease. Rutgers has an on campus stadium they own. Rutgers operational spend is near the top. UCLAs is not close.

All lies about very easily searchable things. It’s so crazy. Guess on the spectrum guys don’t understand truth and fiction.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,707
151,547
113
UCLA doesn't even have full fields lol. Numerous high schools have much better facilities than UCLA.

 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Sometimes one has to learn to do more with less. And I find it hard to believe that a fieldhouse, while very desirable, is crucial in attracting recruits. BTW, aren't we spending up to the cap established in the House settlement?
Al is being disingenuous. The Fieldhouse was discussed when he was hired which was before NIL started. It no longer is that important.

As far as doing more with less, we see strong coaches ascend with less. Obviously, it’s hard to do which is why at the minimum, if we can’t ’ascend’, we at least want to beat UMass, beat BC and have an occasional upset. Nobody expects to go 50/50 against more talented teams but to NEVER upset anybody is preposterous and signals poor coaching. Every single weekend, we see upsets. There were a couple this past weekend.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,707
151,547
113
We should have beaten UMass with our third string team.

when you’re a 30+ point favorite, the game should be over when you step in the field.
Rutgers should have beaten UMass with ME as QB.
UMass NIL was a few million. Al’s narrative gets destroyed again
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
UCLA doesn't even have full fields lol. Numerous high schools have much better facilities than UCLA.

UCLA is 10-0. Did their facilities change in between the last few years when they struggled and this year? Did their academics improve, attracting better players? Did something else change?
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
UCLA is 10-0. Did their facilities change in between the last few years when they struggled and this year? Did their academics improve, attracting better players? Did something else change?
Just like Indiana, which has invested heavily in facilities, which affect recruiting, UCLA opened up a brand new facility in 2017. UCLA, Berkeley, and Michigan are regarded as the best public’s in America. They are more selective and more difficult to get into than any other public school. They hired a new head coach. And invested in NIL.
Point being they were ready to win. Rutgers is not ready to win because there’s no Fieldhouse and NIL support is not where it needs to be though it should be better this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
Al is being disingenuous. The Fieldhouse was discussed when he was hired which was before NIL started. It no longer is that important.

As far as doing more with less, we see strong coaches ascend with less. Obviously, it’s hard to do which is why at the minimum, if we can’t ’ascend’, we at least want to beat UMass, beat BC and have an occasional upset. Nobody expects to go 50/50 against more talented teams but to NEVER upset anybody is preposterous and signals poor coaching. Every single weekend, we see upsets. There were a couple this past weekend.
It’s disingenuous to say it’s not important. If it’s not important, why does every other Big Ten School have a Fieldhouse? Why did USC open a brand new one? Why is Oregon building a brand new facility when they already spend out the wazoo on NIL and already have a facility that is much better than ours. It’s especially important when you’re going after the best of the best players. New facilities are needed for recruiting.

It is being downplayed for us because we don’t have money. The “it’s not important” is simply a face saving stance for us.

You need players to spring upsets. Why should players come here when they can use better facilities and a better experience elsewhere. A four star recruit once told me, “Rutgers isn’t serious about being successful.” And he was right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

Retired711

Heisman
Nov 20, 2001
19,976
10,155
58
Just like Indiana, which has invested heavily in facilities, which affect recruiting, UCLA opened up a brand new facility in 2017. UCLA, Berkeley, and Michigan are regarded as the best public’s in America. They are more selective and more difficult to get into than any other public school. They hired a new head coach. And invested in NIL.
Point being they were ready to win. Rutgers is not ready to win because there’s no Fieldhouse and NIL support is not where it needs to be though it should be better this year.
Minor point: Cal (which, as people in the East sometimes forget, is Berkeley) has done terribly this year despite high expectations. As a Cal alum, I go on their board and it's much like this one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Steve91562

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Just like Indiana, which has invested heavily in facilities, which affect recruiting, UCLA opened up a brand new facility in 2017.
If this facility opened up in 2017, and this was as meaningful as you claim it is, why did UCLA struggle the last several years until they switched coaches?

The prior coach had the benefit of the same Fieldhouse, no?
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
It’s disingenuous to say it’s not important. If it’s not important, why does every other Big Ten School have a Fieldhouse? Why did USC open a brand new one? Why is Oregon building a brand new facility when they already spend out the wazoo on NIL and already have a facility that is much better than ours. It’s especially important when you’re going after the best of the best players. New facilities are needed for recruiting.

It is being downplayed for us because we don’t have money. The “it’s not important” is simply a face saving stance for us.

You need players to spring upsets. Why should players come here when they can use better facilities and a better experience elsewhere. A four star recruit once told me, “Rutgers isn’t serious about being successful.” And he was right.
First, it was important before NIL so any Fieldhouse that was constructed before NIL had a different business case.

Second, in the current NIL era, I would argue. It has more importance for the programs that are battling in the top 15 because at that point, it could be a differentiator between elite recruits. However, not having a field house has absolutely nothing to do with why our program is flat out terrible and on a downward spiral. This entire point only has validity if our program gets to the point where it is winning 7-8 games a year and we want to figure out how to get that to more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newell138

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
You need players to spring upsets.
No, and no. And no. The entire concept of pulling an upset is doing more with less in a given game. This is not the same as saying that a program with far less talent should find a way to win every game. The idea is that once in a while, you find a way to beat the team with more talent than you We see literally every single weekend a couple of these types of events, but our coach is unable to do it. Ever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newell138
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
If this facility opened up in 2017, and this was as meaningful as you claim it is, why did UCLA struggle the last several years until they switched coaches?
Until this year, they didn’t invest as much in NIL. Now they have everything needed to be successful. Financial support to get the players, facilities to develop them, and coaching to extract every ounce of potential. Till date, We have been missing adequate NIL and facilities.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
No, and no. And no. The entire concept of pulling an upset is doing more with less in a given game. This is not the same as saying that a program with far less talent should find a way to win every game. The idea is that once in a while, you find a way to beat the team with more talent than you We see literally every single weekend a couple of these types of events, but our coach is unable to do it. Ever.
You need a superior talent at quarterback to spring the upset. You can’t be weak across the board and expect to spring the upset, like we have been.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Why should players come here when they can use better facilities and a better experience elsewhere. A four star recruit once told me, “Rutgers isn’t serious about being successful.” And he was right.
That is a perfectly valid insight to explain why we are not in position to be an annual top 25 program. Even with a large amount of NIL, we may struggle to beat out the power programs for players at this time. I don’t think anybody has any argument there.

But this has absolutely nothing to do with why our program can’t be in the middle of the pack in the power conferences and certainly does not explain why we are one of the worst power conference team in the country and on a downward spiral. It does not explain why once in a while we don’t have an up year where we win 8 games and it doesn’t explain why we are incapable of ever upsetting anybody.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Until this year, they didn’t invest as much in NIL. Now they have everything needed to be successful. Financial support to get the players, facilities to develop them, and coaching to extract every ounce of potential. Till date, We have been missing adequate NIL and facilities.
So you are on record saying that the coaching change has absolutely nothing to do with going from 3-9 to 10-0?

I heard that the flat earth society is looking for a new leader. You should apply.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
That is a perfectly valid insight to explain why we are not in position to be an annual top 25 program. Even with a large amount of NIL, we may struggle to beat out the power programs for players at this time. I don’t think anybody has any argument there.

But this has absolutely nothing to do with why our program can’t be in the middle of the pack in the power conferences and certainly does not explain why we are one of the worst power conference team in the country and on a downward spiral. It does not explain why once in a while we don’t have an up year where we win 8 games and it doesn’t explain why we are incapable of ever upsetting anybody.
You can expect to be middle of the pack when you’re bottom of the pack in metrics that affect recruiting. Capital spend and NIL spend. You love to ignore these and prattle on about coaching, but they are very important because recruiting is the lifeblood of success.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Just like Indiana, which has invested heavily in facilities, which affect recruiting, UCLA opened up a brand new facility in 2017. UCLA, Berkeley, and Michigan are regarded as the best public’s in America. They are more selective and more difficult to get into than any other public school. They hired a new head coach. And invested in NIL.
Point being they were ready to win. Rutgers is not ready to win because there’s no Fieldhouse and NIL support is not where it needs to be though it should be better this year.
Once again, you turn your point into a binary argument so that you have a chance to win, in this case win versus lose.

However, there are a lot of shades of gray in between going 0-12 and 12-0. Most people on this board are looking to sweep the three out of conference games and go 3-6 or 4-5 as a starting point. Your arguments do not hold water as to why this level of winning is unachievable and why with more NIL, the program got worse.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
So you are on record saying that the coaching change has absolutely nothing to do with going from 3-9 to 10-0?

I heard that the flat earth society is looking for a new leader. You should apply.
Of course coaching had an impact. But it was a confluence of factors that allowed UCLA to be successful. Talent acquisition was especially important. Having the resources to bring in a talented 2nd string quarterback who could continue the success, when the starter went down, was a huge factor as well.

you want to argue that the improvement was 100% coaching, which is not true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
You can expect to be middle of the pack when you’re bottom of the pack in metrics that affect recruiting. Capital spend and NIL spend. You love to ignore these and prattle on about coaching, but they are very important because recruiting is the lifeblood of success.
Are you on record saying that the level of resources for this program justifies going 2-10?

Were we at such a resource constraint to explain getting blown out by Umass and losing to BC? And since both of those teams were able to upset Rutgers, why can’t Rutgers upset a team that is a notch above them? EVER?

Why didn’t the coaches of those two teams curl up in the fetal position in their offices and conclude that because they have less talent and resources than Rutgers, they had no chance to win
 

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,340
9,404
77
Show your work. Reported on here close to 2mm. I didn’t believe it either. And BC reported offering 1.5 to keep.
I've seen various online estimates of circa 750K or less. If they paid him 2 mill., that's criminal, he was never worth that.
There are always going to be anomalies. Way before NIL, the big metric was recruiting rankings, and of course, there was a positive correlation where the higher rankings correlated to more winning, but it wasn’t absolute and some programs just were terrible, regardless of how much talent they brought in. So there is nothing new to see here.

Al is resistant to the idea that Schiano is a low level coach that has a strength in program building but that this is a totally different skill than winning games versus mid level or better teams.
I would also add Schiano made a lot more sense pre transfer portal, pre NIL. The changes in the college game has clipped many of his strengths, highlighting weaknesses. In this respect, the game has passed him by. He is more suited to different era of college football, but that game is gone and never coming back.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Of course coaching had an impact. But it was a confluence of factors that allowed UCLA to be successful. Talent acquisition was especially important. Having the resources to bring in a talented 2nd string quarterback who could continue the success, when the starter went down, was a huge factor as well.

you want to argue that the improvement was 100% coaching, which is not true.
To make my point, I don’t carry a burden of establishing that the coaching is 100% responsible for the outcome. I am just establishing that ‘coaching matters’ and by the way, to go 10-0 is an incredible coaching job regardless of resources because that means every single week, he has his players very focused with no WTF games. See Cinci 2006 for evidence how difficult that is.
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,836
9,074
113
I've seen various online estimates of circa 750K or less. If they paid him 2 mill., that's criminal, he was never worth that.

I would also add Schiano made a lot more sense pre transfer portal, pre NIL. The changes in the college game has clipped many of his strengths, highlighting weaknesses. In this respect, the game has passed him by. He is more suited to different era of college football, but that game is gone and never coming back.
Obrien said outright they tried to keep him and offered a substantial monetary package. Only to be outbid by RU. BC reportedly offered 1.5mm ball park. The estimates you see online are worth. Which 750k would be in line with productivity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
38,942
52,083
112
UMass NIL was a few million. Al’s narrative gets destroyed again

Groundhog day.. I think that PSU83 must be another one of his alias's. If you notice he likes every single post RivalsAl makes.

Reading his responses really makes me think he is on the spectrum.
 

rurahrah000

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2010
3,366
2,334
88
Wrong. We’re going to have competitive NIL in January.
Not sure what competitive means. Is it going to be more than $40 million? Regardless, Schaino will still find a way to underachieve. He will still make stupid calls like calling a timeout on 4th down to give the other team a chance to throw the ball instead of allowing the other team to kick a 50+ yard FG into the wind. His team will still not show up for at least 1-2 games that they should have won. We will still somehow end up with 4-6 wins despite having a NIL of $25 million or $45 million. He will always be an average coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet
Jun 7, 2001
37,621
45,286
113
Not sure what competitive means. Is it going to be more than $40 million? Regardless, Schaino will still find a way to underachieve. He will still make stupid calls like calling a timeout on 4th down to give the other team a chance to throw the ball instead of allowing the other team to kick a 50+ yard FG into the wind. His team will still not show up for at least 1-2 games that they should have won. We will still somehow end up with 4-6 wins despite having a NIL of $25 million or $45 million. He will always be an average coach.
Likely around $30M
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

LETSGORU91

All-American
Jan 29, 2017
7,203
7,952
113
The reason I would not consider the Rutgers win an upset is because Washington lost every road game that season and won every home game at Huskey Stadium. True to form Washington lost on the road in Piscataway. The story of the 2024 Washington season is not 1 win away from Home.
Greg winning a game versus any team NOT named Howard is considered an upset.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,707
151,547
113
Groundhog day.. I think that PSU83 must be another one of his alias's. If you notice he likes every single post RivalsAl makes.

Reading his responses really makes me think he is on the spectrum.
It is. He needs to slow play it. Every time OriginAL posts, his ALisas immediately likes it. He's not disciplined enough to even attempt to make it look authentic.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  2. 02 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener