Big Ten Teams had a lot more NIL than we did

Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
Coaching doesn’t matter if you don’t have enough talent. Money does all the recruiting these days, so we are at a huge disadvantage. The difference buys a lot of incremental talent for our opponents.
  • At least $6 M NIL gap with Wisconsin
  • At least $8M NIL gap with Nebraska
  • At least $13M NIL gap with Michigan
  • At least $14M NIL gap with USC
  • At least $6M NIL gap with Penn State
  • At least a $13M NIL gap with Indiana
  • As much as a $2M NIL gap with Northwestern
  • As much as a $2M NIL gap with MSU
  • As much as a $2M NIL gap with Maryland
    IMG_1935.png
 

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
38,934
52,076
112
Coaching doesn’t matter if you don’t have enough talent. Money does all the recruiting these days, so we are at a huge disadvantage. The difference buys a lot of incremental talent for our opponents.
  • At least $6 M NIL gap with Wisconsin
  • At least $8M NIL gap with Nebraska
  • At least $13M NIL gap with Michigan
  • At least $14M NIL gap with USC
  • At least $6M NIL gap with Penn State
  • At least a $13M NIL gap with Indiana
  • As much as a $2M NIL gap with Northwestern
  • As much as a $2M NIL gap with MSU
  • As much as a $2M NIL gap with Maryland
    View attachment 1534769
How did OSU and LSU lose 3 games each then?
 

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
38,934
52,076
112
What RivalsAl doesn’t seem to understand despite his daily posts about more NIL is that we aren’t getting more NIL. We have what we have and we will never have what the blue bloods have. So coaching and player evaluation is more important and Greg has shown us he has no clue with either
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
What RivalsAl doesn’t seem to understand despite his daily posts about more NIL is that we aren’t getting more NIL. We have what we have and we will never have what the blue bloods have. So coaching and player evaluation is more important and Greg has shown us he has no clue with either
We’re getting more NIL this year, for the January portal, so yet another swing and miss from you.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: psu83 and newell138
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
What we had wasn't spent well, and not even OP can this fact.
When you’re shopping the bargain bin, a lot of kids aren’t going to pan out. Thevinin and Porter were solid gets. Allison can fill gaps, but god forbid if he has to make a play in the open field. Bradlee Jones is a solid competitor. #8 Kromah is solid. #11 is getting better every game. Everyone else is a dud, and that is problematic.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: newell138 and psu83

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,334
9,389
77
When you’re shopping the bargain bin, a lot of kids aren’t going to pan out. Thevinin and Porter were solid gets. Allison can fill gaps, but god forbid if he has to make a play in the open field. Bradlee Jones is a solid competitor. #8 Kromah is solid. #11 is getting better every game. Everyone else is a dud, and that is problematic.
But we had just as much NIL and revenue sharing as some other programs, many of them, who are performing better, who have better talent, who don't look like a stumbling clusterflub. That means the talent eval was off, or players don't want to play for RU or this staff or the delay in hiring the DC F' everything. No one is contesting that more NIL brings in more talent, but they're not even effectively using what NIL/revenue sharing they do have. That's the point.
 

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
38,934
52,076
112
But we had just as much NIL and revenue sharing as some other programs, many of them, who are performing better, who have better talent, who don't look like a stumbling clusterflub. That means the talent eval was off, or players don't want to play for RU or this staff or the delay in hiring the DC F' everything. No one is contesting that more NIL brings in more talent, but they're not even effectively using what NIL/revenue sharing they do have. That's the point.
This. We aren’t even competitive. Look at MD. New coach and all of a sudden they are winning games against teams that humiliate us

I notice the only one agreeing with RivalsAl is a PSU grad
 

SF88

All-Conference
Aug 6, 2001
1,619
2,179
113
Al is off his rocker, a lot, but I agree with him here.

A lot has gone wrong last year and this year. We have epically bad defenses from a guy who's been a DC at Miami and Ohio State. Why? GS has made a TON of mistakes with the roster and talent. Let's assume he had some NIL $$ last year. What about the previous few years when the upper class guys were brought in. He worked hard to create his own $$. While he was doing that OSU had a 30 Million roster 2 years ago and now over 50 Million.

Coaching matters. Coaching changes games. However, if you don't have the jimmy's and joe's you simply can't win consistently against a B1G schedule. No excuses for Mass or BC. But when you watch 2nd string QB's out run our guys to the corner, or our guys not able to tackle, or our guys just knocked 2-3 yards back at the snap, or almost never getting pressure with 4 guys rushing, I think its lack of talent. Our guys aren't good enough to compete with B1G teams.

Looks at that graph. Most of the teams on the right side are also winning most of the games. The answer is very very simple. You spend 35-50 million and you have a much better chance of success. A guarantee of success, no, but a much better chance at one. That can't even be argued.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
But we had just as much NIL and revenue sharing as some other programs, many of them, who are performing better, who have better talent, who don't look like a stumbling clusterflub. That means the talent eval was off, or players don't want to play for RU or this staff or the delay in hiring the DC F' everything. No one is contesting that more NIL brings in more talent, but they're not even effectively using what NIL/revenue sharing they do have. That's the point.
Who can be successful shopping the bargain bin like we are. Wisconsin got p5 kids. Our recruits are from Drake, eastern Michigan, and South Dakota, Among others. Some of the kids playing flat out just don’t belong on the field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,443
13,325
113
When you’re shopping the bargain bin, a lot of kids aren’t going to pan out. Thevinin and Porter were solid gets. Allison can fill gaps, but god forbid if he has to make a play in the open field. Bradlee Jones is a solid competitor. #8 Kromah is solid. #11 is getting better every game. Everyone else is a dud, and that is problematic.

Luckily that won't be an excuse next year, right?
 

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,334
9,389
77
Who can be successful shopping the bargain bin like we are. Wisconsin got p5 kids. Our recruits are from Drake, eastern Michigan, and South Dakota, Among others. Some of the kids playing flat out just don’t belong on the field.
You're are not addressing the salient point -- many P4, G5 programs have generally the same amount of NIL and revenue sharing. They shop in the same bin, and yet they have better results in the portal. Why is that? I'm trying to take you seriously, but your evasion makes it hard. Tell me which programs in the P4 have a similar amount to Rutgers of NIL/revenue sharing? If you answer that questions, you will understand the concern of many Rutgers fans. According to your graph, Utah had less NIL than Rutgers and they're in the top ten. Surprise me that you are not a troll.
 

LETSGORU91

All-American
Jan 29, 2017
7,203
7,952
113
But we had just as much NIL and revenue sharing as some other programs, many of them, who are performing better, who have better talent, who don't look like a stumbling clusterflub. That means the talent eval was off, or players don't want to play for RU or this staff or the delay in hiring the DC F' everything. No one is contesting that more NIL brings in more talent, but they're not even effectively using what NIL/revenue sharing they do have. That's the point.
RutgersAL #3 is not good dealing with reality. Greg said this was his "deepest and most talented team" in 2.0. Called out Lonergan and Surace as "two QBs we can win with". Also called his O Line so deep, the second unit would have been the first line six years ago. So RutgersAL #3, is Greggie a poor evaluator of talent, a master of deception, or just a bad coach?
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,969
8,945
113
A&M is much worse this year, offense is terrible. OC promotion issue just like Oregon until they fired DM
And their NIL is significantly higher than RU's. Talent isn't the problem in either of those situations. Coaching clearly is. We saw that DM was a bad coach when he was here.
 
Last edited:

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,334
9,389
77
RutgersAL #3 is not good dealing with reality. Greg said this was his "deepest and most talented team" in 2.0. Called out Lonergan and Surace as "two QBs we can win with". Also called his O Line so deep, the second unit would have been the first line six years ago. So RutgersAL #3, is Greggie a poor evaluator of talent, a master of deception, or just a bad coach?
The talent eval and roster construction absolute disaster, especially this last year, and we're to be comforted that more NIL money going to the people who made these prior decisions? The only comfort I have is that Zinn & Co already made up their decision about this coaching staff and it is only a matter of time. Think Al probably the last hold out, and does anyone believe he's not doing this for attention?
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,833
9,069
113
You're are not addressing the salient point -- many P4, G5 programs have generally the same amount of NIL and revenue sharing. They shop in the same bin, and yet they have better results in the portal. Why is that? I'm trying to take you seriously, but your evasion makes it hard. Tell me which programs in the P4 have a similar amount to Rutgers of NIL/revenue sharing? If you answer that questions, you will understand the concern of many Rutgers fans. According to your graph, Utah had less NIL than Rutgers and they're in the top ten. Surprise me that you are not a troll.
He’s using the graph now because when he posted the numbers earlier it showed the overlap. RU is the median in the B1G. Teams 8-14 are similar in spending. The reason we had to ship in the bargain bin is because we missed out on 3 recruiting cycles because for 2 years in a row it took Greg 2-3 months (depending on year) to fill critical coaching roles. It’s less to do with NIL and more to do with incompetence.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,969
8,945
113
Who can be successful shopping the bargain bin like we are. Wisconsin got p5 kids. Our recruits are from Drake, eastern Michigan, and South Dakota, Among others. Some of the kids playing flat out just don’t belong on the field.
The programs that are successful shopping in the bargain bin are the ones who are good at evaluating and coaching talent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,969
8,945
113
He’s using the graph now because when he posted the numbers earlier it showed the overlap. RU is the median in the B1G. Teams 8-14 are similar in spending. The reason we had to ship in the bargain bin is because we missed out on 3 recruiting cycles because for 2 years in a row it took Greg 2-3 months (depending on year) to fill critical coaching roles. It’s less to do with NIL and more to do with incompetence.
RU is in the same NIL neighborhood as UCLA. They're 10-0. RU can't beat UMass and BC.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
You're are not addressing the salient point -- many P4, G5 programs have generally the same amount of NIL and revenue sharing. They shop in the same bin, and yet they have better results in the portal. Why is that? I'm trying to take you seriously, but your evasion makes it hard. Tell me which programs in the P4 have a similar amount to Rutgers of NIL/revenue sharing? If you answer that questions, you will understand the concern of many Rutgers fans. According to your graph, Utah had less NIL than Rutgers and they're in the top ten. Surprise me that you are not a troll.
You are not understanding the difficulty of our competitive landscape. The salient point is we don’t have enough NIL to compete with the teams on our schedule. Does Utahs schedule include Indiana, USC, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Penn State, MSU, Michigan, Maryland, and Northwestern? No it doesn’t. Most P4 and G5 teams don’t play this difficult a schedule. You are making an apples and oranges comparison.

Furthermore, the Big 10 teams we compete against have built a strong capital base of generations. This is why they have the best facilities money can buy. Northwestern just spent well over $1B in facilities and USC just opened a $300M football facility. The strength of the big ten is why Rutgers will be pulling in $70M+ in media distributions this year, while Utah will be pulling in a lot less.

Utah is competing with teams that invested similarly, which is why they are successful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83 and SF88
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
RU is in the same NIL neighborhood as UCLA. They're 10-0. RU can't beat UMass and BC.
UCLA spent more on NIL and they spent a lot more on facilities. Have you ever been to UCLA? It’s one of the nicest campuses in America, while ours is one of the worst. And we didn’t even mention that ucla is more difficult to get into and more selective.

 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,833
9,069
113
RU is in the same NIL neighborhood as UCLA. They're 10-0. RU can't beat UMass and BC.
Yep Chesney hired in the first week of Dec. was able to assemble a staff. Meet with his new team. Get his family settled thousands of miles from home. In a new city and state. Evaluate his roster. Evaluate the portal. And re-recruit the players he wanted to keep. And recruit new players that fit his system. Bring all of these players to campus. And win out on 43 players to revamp his roster. All while we have an existing coaching staff. Double to triple the size of the average B1G staff. And we can’t attract talent to the banks. Make it make sense.
 

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,334
9,389
77
RU is in the same NIL neighborhood as UCLA. They're 10-0. RU can't beat UMass and BC.
Actually UCLA has a lot more NIL if you look at the various listings. Doesn't mean I agree with Al, or that all these listings are accurate, but you may want to check your sources.

You are not understanding the difficulty of our competitive landscape. The salient point is we don’t have enough NIL to compete with the teams on our schedule. Does Utahs schedule include Indiana, USC, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Penn State, MSU, Michigan, Maryland, and Northwestern? No it doesn’t. Most P4 and G5 teams don’t play this difficult a schedule. You are making an apples and oranges comparison.

Furthermore, the Big 10 teams we compete against have built a strong capital base of generations. This is why they have the best facilities money can buy. Northwestern just spent well over $1B in facilities and USC just opened a $300M football facility. The strength of the big ten is why Rutgers will be pulling in $70M+ in media distributions this year, while Utah will be pulling in a lot less.

Utah is competing with teams that invested similarly, which is why they are successful.
Utah has the 40th SOS, and Rutgers the 39th this year.
 
Last edited:

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,334
9,389
77
You are not understanding the difficulty of our competitive landscape. The salient point is we don’t have enough NIL to compete with the teams on our schedule. Does Utahs schedule include Indiana, USC, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Penn State, MSU, Michigan, Maryland, and Northwestern? No it doesn’t. Most P4 and G5 teams don’t play this difficult a schedule. You are making an apples and oranges comparison.

Furthermore, the Big 10 teams we compete against have built a strong capital base of generations. This is why they have the best facilities money can buy. Northwestern just spent well over $1B in facilities and USC just opened a $300M football facility. The strength of the big ten is why Rutgers will be pulling in $70M+ in media distributions this year, while Utah will be pulling in a lot less.

Utah is competing with teams that invested similarly, which is why they are successful.
Utah has 40th SOS, Rutgers 39th this year.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
Yep Chesney hired in the first week of Dec. was able to assemble a staff. Meet with his new team. Get his family settled thousands of miles from home. In a new city and state. Evaluate his roster. Evaluate the portal. And re-recruit the players he wanted to keep. And recruit new players that fit his system. Bring all of these players to campus. And win out on 43 players to revamp his roster. All while we have an existing coaching staff. Double to triple the size of the average B1G staff. And we can’t attract talent to the banks. Make it make sense.
UCLA is arguably the nicest campus and best public school in America. The school sells itself. When you add that he has really nice facilities, he’s got a value proposition that is second to none. Rutgers is comparatively a difficult sell.
 

RUBlackout

All-American
Mar 11, 2008
11,112
7,455
113
Stop trying to obfuscate the issue. Our biggest problem is we don’t have enough talent to compete in the Big Ten. I don’t really care what Utah is doing in a lesser conference.
You are such a loser!!!! Stop with your nonsense and start realizing that this has nothing to do with NIL and ALL TO DO WITH COACHING!!!!

Everyone on here is proving to you that others teams(& Coaches) are doing more with less. Yet we have a bloated support staff and cant beat teams with less NIL and less talent even.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,334
9,389
77
Stop trying to obfuscate the issue. Our biggest problem is we don’t have enough talent to compete in the Big Ten. I don’t really care what Utah is doing in a lesser conference.
SOS = strength of schedule. Not sure I understand your comment. Utah is currently ranked #2 in the country with less revenue sharing/NIL than Rutgers (according to your chart) and the same strength of schedule. You're not seriously suggesting Rutgers could beat Utah?
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
You are such a loser!!!! Stop with your nonsense and start realizing that this has nothing to do with NIL and ALL TO DO WITH COACHING!!!!

Everyone on here is proving to you that others teams(& Coaches) are doing more with less. Yet we have a bloated support staff and cant beat teams with less NIL and less talent even.
The fact that our quarterback can’t hit he broadside of the barn has everything to do with coaching? That sir, is incorrect. You put a competent quarterback like Beau Pribula, who is playing for UVA, and we’re going bowling. And he only cost $2M.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,833
9,069
113
UCLA is arguably the nicest campus and best public school in America. The school sells itself. When you add that he has really nice facilities, he’s got a value proposition that is second to none. Rutgers is comparatively a difficult sell.
I’ve been to UCLA multiple times. Great campus. I will not deny. But their athletic facilities are subpar comparatively. It’s been the issue for many years. What’s changed. They hired a coach that knows how to do more with less. Evaluate talent properly. And has a track record of success. From d3 all the way to JMU. Chesney wins. Even with all the advantages Greg and his staff have had. He was not able to compete with like programs. Not asking him to compete with Ohio State or Penn State for roster spots or in the scoreboard. But how about compete with the middle 8 in NIL that spend in the same range.


Pretty much what every one on here has been saying. No real differential in spending on the middle 7-8 teams.
  1. UCLA – $26-30M
  2. Maryland – $22-25M
  3. Michigan State – $21-25M
  4. Northwestern – $21-25M
  5. Washington – $21-25M
  6. Rutgers – $20-23M
  7. Illinois – $19-23M
  8. Minnesota – $18-22M
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,618
45,283
113
SOS = strength of schedule. Not sure I understand your comment. Utah is currently ranked #2 in the country with less revenue sharing/NIL than Rutgers (according to your chart) and the same strength of schedule. You're not seriously suggesting Rutgers could beat Utah?
What I’m concerned about is what we have to do to better compete with teams that are actually on our schedule, not Utah. In any case, you’ve overlooked the fact that Utah spent a ton of money to upgrade their facilities. $62M recently. And they already had a facility that was better than ours, built around 2012. This is why their recruiting dollars go further.
 
  • Like
Reactions: psu83
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
  3. 03 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half