'26 PSU - Michigan game thread

NedFromYork

Sophomore
Aug 29, 2001
97
106
33
Well, since B1G play started I haven't approved of much, but we have a fullback and a quarterback under center!
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
463
222
43
If he hired him sooner the roster would be very different
But MC wasn't my first choice--I just comprehend he gets 3 years

A lack of talent
Coaching clock management
Unwillingness/inability to adapt
Refusal to bench Rocco after that second pick

No. The roster would be slightly better. Campbell was still bringing in ISU players. His talent evaluation and recruiting skills are average at best.


You also listed coaching, clock management, unwillingness to adapt as problems. Those issues are 100% on campb ell.



Campbell stinks. Chesney was the guy. In 3 years psu will get another shot.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,193
1,214
113
Kraft thought he could lure Marcus Freeman from ND how has a national championship roster. His fallback was a Somoan Mormon who coaches at and went to BYU. Turned down Urban Meyer who has three national championships. And then hired Matt Campbell after signing day and transfer period… he should be **** canned.

At the 12th hour, Krafty The Clown's candidates had come down to Sitaki, Campbell and Chesney. Krafty The Clown managed to order his targets the absolute diametric opposite of how they should have been rated. UCLA is looking to go 6-0 tonight and Chesney made it well known that he wanted the PSU job over the UCLA job...... Krafty could screw up an orgasm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LilWashLion

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
8,325
4,437
113
No. The roster would be slightly better. Campbell was still bringing in ISU players. His talent evaluation and recruiting skills are average at best.


You also listed coaching, clock management, unwillingness to adapt as problems. Those issues are 100% on campb ell.



Campbell stinks. Chesney was the guy. In 3 years psu will get another shot.
That's a false assumption regarding him bringing his guys
With more talent those mistakes are often hidden--see Franklin
We likely will get another shot. Can't blame MC for Chesney not being here.
 

Catch1lion

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,350
7,366
113
Well if you could have down by 3, 10:00 minutes left , and first down on your own 40, you would probably take it . Let’s go .
 

m.knox

All-American
Aug 20, 2003
5,495
5,465
113
Kraft thought he could lure Marcus Freeman from ND how has a national championship roster. His fallback was a Somoan Mormon who coaches at and went to BYU. Turned down Urban Meyer who has three national championships. And then hired Matt Campbell after signing day and transfer period… he should be **** canned.


Amen
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
463
222
43
Again, if MC is hired earlier a lot changes but this isn't defending MC
I said for years that 2026 was going to be rough no matter who the coach was
Would not be many changes. There were better players who the camp ell staff did not want. We could have kept lane and Campbell for the same mo ey that went to Neal and Ebel. Becht got more money than grunk.

Campbell was bringing in isu guys using the cignetti model.
 

psuno1

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
1,101
1,363
113
that drive was terrible, come on. Becht is so jittery back there play like a 5th senior.
 

MtNittany

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
3,943
5,496
113
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
8,325
4,437
113
Would not be many changes. There were better players who the camp ell staff did not want. We could have kept lane and Campbell for the same mo ey that went to Neal and Ebel. Becht got more money than grunk.

Campbell was bringing in isu guys using the cignetti model.
We simple disagree--who do you falsely believe wanted to be here that isn't
Grunk was NEVER staying--he was loyal to Franklin. James has made countless comments that made it clear he knew he was following him. The "insiders" here will tell you the same.
He brought his guys out of necessity
 

BrentPrysDstinks

Redshirt
Sep 9, 2017
10
9
3
the last couple of weeks inspired me to write this… please feel free to modify or amend as it is a “living”poem :


Bring Back Franklin, Blow Campbell Away


Oh, how we miss those Franklin days,
When Penn State played with fire and praise.
Now Campbell stands upon the stage,
With empty words on every page.


He talks of grit, he talks of pride,
But where’s the team that backs his side?
A thousand speeches, polished and grand,
Yet nothing worth a damn in hand.


Now Franklin couldn’t coach a lick,
His game-day calls could make you sick.
But man, that guy could sure recruit,
Five-star talent in every suit.


He’d blow a lead, he’d botch a play,
And coach a big-game win away.
But give him talent, give him time,
One lucky year, we’d reach the prime!


A busted coverage, a miracle catch,
A playoff bracket, a perfect match.
We might’ve stumbled to the crown,
And painted Happy Valley town!


But Campbell’s got a different plan,
Just say nice things and shake a hand.
He preaches culture, trust, and fight,
Then finds new ways to lose each night.


Oh, Cyclone winds, come roaring through,
We’ve got a little job for you.
Sweep Matt Campbell far away,
And bring James Franklin back to stay.


For Franklin’s flaws, we knew them well,
His fourth-down calls were football hell.
But at least he gave us hope each fall,
With Campbell, we get words. That’s all.


So bring back James, despite his flaws,
His lousy clock and timeout calls.
We might’ve won a title by mistake—
But Campbell’s just a lot of talk and heartbreak!
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,193
1,214
113
For all of you nimrods that say Franklin is laying an egg at VaTech -- VaTech just beat GaTech to move to 5-2. Through 7 games last year VaTech was 2-5 (on their way to a 3-9 season). Franklin has already made them into a VASTLY IMPROVED team from last year, but all you Franklin-hate know-it-alls keep telling us that Campbell has to be given years to improve the team..... Franklin improves VaTech dramatically improves VaTech IMMEDIATELY in his first year upon arriving, but he sucks???? You people make ZERO sense and are completely illogical in your criticisms of Franklin and defenses of Campbell (just completely opposite of one another). Campbell has taken a very competitive team and turned it uncompetitive with his transfers in his first year while Franklin has taken a completely uncompetitive team and turned it very competitive with his transfers in his first year, but it's Franklin that stinks??????
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football First Impressions from Penn State's 21-18 loss at Michigan
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell's words aren't adding up after Penn State falls to Michigan: 7 things I think after the Lions' latest loss
  3. 03 BWI Football Everything Matt Campbell said after Penn State's 21-18 loss to Michigan
  4. 04 BWI Football What did Kyle Whittingham, Penn State players, say after the Lions 21-18 loss? 'It's humbling'
  5. 05 BWI Football Did Penn State coach Matt Campbell consider replacing Rocco Becht against Michigan?