Wrestling Thread

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
This Club WWE scam gets even worse...


Priced at $99 per year, Club WWE sign-ups are now open for “founding members.” Those who join at launch receive an exclusive kit of items that includes a match-used ring canvas collectible, a lanyard, and a pin that WWE says has a “personal note” from John Cena to members:

  • Every Founding Member receives an exclusive kit including a match-used ring canvas acrylic collectible, a Club WWE exclusive lanyard, and a Founder pin with a personal note to members from John Cena. A value of $99 on day 1.
The other benefits of Club WWE include ticket pre-sale access, exclusive merchandise, bonus content, a community forum, and a points-based rewards system. A new interview with Cena conducted by Tom Rinaldi is among the bonus content that’s available.

1784306311909.png
  • This match-used ring canvas doesn't appear to be authenticated based on the picture, so impossible to verify if it's actually a legitimate match-used canvas
  • A lanyard and a bland, generic looking pin as a centerpiece of a benefits package, LOL. What's next, a pizza party?
  • Pay money to get access to ticket pre-sales that used to be free
  • Pay money to get a John Cena interview
  • Advertising in 2026 that a forum is one of the key benefits of joining when it's a company that heavily focuses on appealing to kids and casuals. Yes, I understand the irony that I am posting on a website with a paid forum. On3/Rivals is for hardcores, not casuals.
The personal note from John Cena will be pretty neat though if it's actually personalized instead of a form note where they just change the person's name. I'm assuming he'll physically sign these.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
Meanwhile, AEW a week after posting their best Dynamite rating of the year did even better this week by posting their best rating since Blood and Guts 2024, making it the highest rated Dynamite in the HBO Max simulcasting era.

Take the growth and shove it up your candy a$$, Alvarez
 

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
588
844
93
Both can be true. AEW attendance has ticked up a bit and ratings have increased since Omega won the title. It's good to see. At the same time, AEW and their fans claim they have the best roster ever assembled yet it's a celebration if weekly attendance is just north of 3,000. AEW is still successful and has done well since its inception but he's correct. They have everything they need to thrive and the audience has only shrunk. Streaming, national tv, a billionaire family, a large roster, etc. There's no reason why in N. America Raw can't do 12k and Dynamite 7k-9k. That's all he's saying and it's what I've said. Why is Raw, a supposedly terrible show, able to pull in 10k but Dynamite, this supposedly best show of the week, clawing to get 3k? And it's not the economy's fault and it's not because wrestling is niche. If fans can make fun of WWE's attendance woes and do an autopsy on that (fans priced out, boring creative, not creating enough new stars) then let the autopsy on AEW begin as to why Dynamite isn't averaging at least 5,000 fans right now.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
He’s really digging in and not entirely wrong - if page is a mover why is he a background character


Says the guy that criticized the women being the main event for the Dynamite episode that did it's best ratings in two years while Observer business continues to go down the drain.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
Both can be true. AEW attendance has ticked up a bit and ratings have increased since Omega won the title. It's good to see. At the same time, AEW and their fans claim they have the best roster ever assembled yet it's a celebration if weekly attendance is just north of 3,000. AEW is still successful and has done well since its inception but he's correct. They have everything they need to thrive and the audience has only shrunk. Streaming, national tv, a billionaire family, a large roster, etc. There's no reason why in N. America Raw can't do 12k and Dynamite 7k-9k. That's all he's saying and it's what I've said. Why is Raw, a supposedly terrible show, able to pull in 10k but Dynamite, this supposedly best show of the week, clawing to get 3k? And it's not the economy's fault and it's not because wrestling is niche. If fans can make fun of WWE's attendance woes and do an autopsy on that (fans priced out, boring creative, not creating enough new stars) then let the autopsy on AEW begin as to why Dynamite isn't averaging at least 5,000 fans right now.
The average for Dynamite this year is over 3K - and that's with them having booked numerous venues booked that physically can't even fit 3K without violating fire code regulations. So to say that over 3K is celebration worthy or that they are clawing to over 3K is just objectively devoid of truth.
 

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
1,768
4,630
113
Why is Raw, a supposedly terrible show, able to pull in 10k but Dynamite, this supposedly best show of the week, clawing to get 3k?
The same reason that Nickelback sold way more albums than Dream Theater.

Commercial-ability does not equal quality.

Sometimes the more intricate something within a given industry is, the smaller the wide-range appeal. AEW, at its best, is not a competitor to the WWE for the largest slice of the market share pie. At its apex, it is an alternative for those who are less interested in a product akin to a superhero comic book in presentation.

WWE is not objectively wrong to enjoy. Neither is AEW. It’s simply two separate sub-genres.

I point this out to say — the WWE vs AEW stuff is nauseating from both sides. Just enjoy the wrestling that floats your boat most? Well, we can’t. We have to argue about which one is better, even though the two of us aren’t even asking for the same things out of our respective products. Why do we do it? To give the appearance of superiority. Superiority?? Wait, isn’t professional wrestling something of a social albatross and a niche as-is? Well, yes it is, but we gotta trim the herd even further by calling each other marks and arguing about how stupid one another are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: American Dragon

Laparkafan

Heisman
Sep 5, 2004
14,638
10,187
93
Both can be true. AEW attendance has ticked up a bit and ratings have increased since Omega won the title. It's good to see. At the same time, AEW and their fans claim they have the best roster ever assembled yet it's a celebration if weekly attendance is just north of 3,000. AEW is still successful and has done well since its inception but he's correct. They have everything they need to thrive and the audience has only shrunk. Streaming, national tv, a billionaire family, a large roster, etc. There's no reason why in N. America Raw can't do 12k and Dynamite 7k-9k. That's all he's saying and it's what I've said. Why is Raw, a supposedly terrible show, able to pull in 10k but Dynamite, this supposedly best show of the week, clawing to get 3k? And it's not the economy's fault and it's not because wrestling is niche. If fans can make fun of WWE's attendance woes and do an autopsy on that (fans priced out, boring creative, not creating enough new stars) then let the autopsy on AEW begin as to why Dynamite isn't averaging at least 5,000 fans right now.
Herein lies the problem no matter how many rational arguments you make the sickos will tear you apart ironically which is why they can’t grow past when cm punk was there. They never really care to go over 1 million viewers as long as TK caters to them.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
The same reason that Nickelback sold way more albums than Dream Theater.

Commercial-ability does not equal quality.

Sometimes the more intricate something within a given industry is, the smaller the wide-range appeal. AEW, at its best, is not a competitor to the WWE for the largest slice of the market share pie. At its apex, it is an alternative for those who are less interested in a product akin to a superhero comic book in presentation.

WWE is not objectively wrong to enjoy. Neither is AEW. It’s simply two separate sub-genres.

I point this out to say — the WWE vs AEW stuff is nauseating from both sides. Just enjoy the wrestling that floats your boat most? Well, we can’t. We have to argue about which one is better, even though the two of us aren’t even asking for the same things out of our respective products. Why do we do it? To give the appearance of superiority. Superiority?? Wait, isn’t professional wrestling something of a social albatross and a niche as-is? Well, yes it is, but we gotta trim the herd even further by calling each other marks and arguing about how stupid one another are.
A product that caters to a niche audience in the same market as the product that tries to cater to the largest audience possible will never be as popular as the one that caters to the largest audience. Name the industry, the niche products ain't as popular as the "brand names" even if they may produce a subjecively superior product.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
Herein lies the problem no matter how many rational arguments you make the sickos will tear you apart ironically which is why they can’t grow past when cm punk was there. They never really care to go over 1 million viewers as long as TK caters to them.
And why should I want something I like to change to something I don't like just because it may help it grow? That doesn't make any sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GeraldV

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
This is how some wrestling fans sound like when they talk about wrestling

John Doe: This restaurant was better before they changed their menu
Jane Doe: I can't believe you want better food at the expense of growth!

John Doe: I liked this band's music more before they changed to be more commercial friendly. Now the music is worse and convert tickets cost more.
Jane Doe: I can't believe you want to listen to better music instead of paying more for tickets!

John Doe: I liked it better when I could repair my own farm equipment, now I have to pay a subscription fee and pay more for parts and labor to get the manufacturer to repair it.
Jane Doe: But they are making more money now, how dare you suggest they do otherwise!

John Doe: I liked it better when my soda bottles were 20 oz. Now they are 16.9 oz and cost more than they did last year. I'm getting less and spending more!
Jane Doe: This is just smart business. Now you have to buy more and spend more money to get the same amount of soda as before. That's just smart business!
 

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
588
844
93
The same reason that Nickelback sold way more albums than Dream Theater.

Commercial-ability does not equal quality.

Sometimes the more intricate something within a given industry is, the smaller the wide-range appeal. AEW, at its best, is not a competitor to the WWE for the largest slice of the market share pie. At its apex, it is an alternative for those who are less interested in a product akin to a superhero comic book in presentation.

WWE is not objectively wrong to enjoy. Neither is AEW. It’s simply two separate sub-genres.

I point this out to say — the WWE vs AEW stuff is nauseating from both sides. Just enjoy the wrestling that floats your boat most? Well, we can’t. We have to argue about which one is better, even though the two of us aren’t even asking for the same things out of our respective products. Why do we do it? To give the appearance of superiority. Superiority?? Wait, isn’t professional wrestling something of a social albatross and a niche as-is? Well, yes it is, but we gotta trim the herd even further by calling each other marks and arguing about how stupid one another are.
Buddy, it's a discussion thread lol. It's okay if we occasionally knock one company or the another or ask questions. If posters wanna knock WWE's attendance, have at it. It's worthy of discussion and right now Summerfest looks pathetic by major PLE standards. What's also worthy of discussion is asking why AEW's tv isn't producing a higher attendance number. Yes, they're in smaller venues but if they weren't, their attendance would still be around 3000, maybe closer to 4000 if they were in a hotspot for a show. It's okay to expect a bit more from the number two company with all the advantages mentioned. If TNA were in AEW's spot, we'd be asking what's with the smaller crowds every week. If Dragon posts 10 anti-WWE things, you disappear. If I ask why can't they get 6000+ for a Dynamite in 2026, you show up with the AEW cape on lol. As far as the niche excuse Dragon likes, it's all wrestling. AEW isn't all that niche. They took indie legends and former WWE stars and occasionally pretend to do Attitude Era stuff with them. What's niche about constantly doing spots with a screwdriver? We saw stuff like that 30 years ago when wrestling was at its peak.

AEW should be doing even better than they are but something is holding them back from being bigger. It's not WWE fault and it's goofy to pretend AEW fans want a product that doesn't grow. It is not crazy to ask why isn't Dynamite, with that roster and national tv exposure and a big streaming platform, is not doing better attendance wise. The coddling of Uncle Tony and his business is just silly lol. I'm getting the upset finger wag for just asking why more people don't want to attend Dynamite.
 

Im The Village Idiot

All-Conference
Sep 7, 2025
1,768
4,630
113
Buddy, it's a discussion thread lol. It's okay if we occasionally knock one company or the another or ask questions. If posters wanna knock WWE's attendance, have at it. It's worthy of discussion and right now Summerfest looks pathetic by major PLE standards. What's also worthy of discussion is asking why AEW's tv isn't producing a higher attendance number. Yes, they're in smaller venues but if they weren't, their attendance would still be around 3000, maybe closer to 4000 if they were in a hotspot for a show. It's okay to expect a bit more from the number two company with all the advantages mentioned. If TNA were in AEW's spot, we'd be asking what's with the smaller crowds every week. If Dragon posts 10 anti-WWE things, you disappear. If I ask why can't they get 6000+ for a Dynamite in 2026, you show up with the AEW cape on lol. As far as the niche excuse Dragon likes, it's all wrestling. AEW isn't all that niche. They took indie legends and former WWE stars and occasionally pretend to do Attitude Era stuff with them. What's niche about constantly doing spots with a screwdriver? We saw stuff like that 30 years ago when wrestling was at its peak.

AEW should be doing even better than they are but something is holding them back from being bigger. It's not WWE fault and it's goofy to pretend AEW fans want a product that doesn't grow. It is not crazy to ask why isn't Dynamite, with that roster and national tv exposure and a big streaming platform, is not doing better attendance wise. The coddling of Uncle Tony and his business is just silly lol. I'm getting the upset finger wag for just asking why more people don't want to attend Dynamite.
You’re really steeped in it. My goodness. Good luck with that.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
Buddy, it's a discussion thread lol. It's okay if we occasionally knock one company or the another or ask questions. If posters wanna knock WWE's attendance, have at it. It's worthy of discussion and right now Summerfest looks pathetic by major PLE standards. What's also worthy of discussion is asking why AEW's tv isn't producing a higher attendance number. Yes, they're in smaller venues but if they weren't, their attendance would still be around 3000, maybe closer to 4000 if they were in a hotspot for a show. It's okay to expect a bit more from the number two company with all the advantages mentioned. If TNA were in AEW's spot, we'd be asking what's with the smaller crowds every week. If Dragon posts 10 anti-WWE things, you disappear. If I ask why can't they get 6000+ for a Dynamite in 2026, you show up with the AEW cape on lol. As far as the niche excuse Dragon likes, it's all wrestling. AEW isn't all that niche. They took indie legends and former WWE stars and occasionally pretend to do Attitude Era stuff with them. What's niche about constantly doing spots with a screwdriver? We saw stuff like that 30 years ago when wrestling was at its peak.

AEW should be doing even better than they are but something is holding them back from being bigger. It's not WWE fault and it's goofy to pretend AEW fans want a product that doesn't grow. It is not crazy to ask why isn't Dynamite, with that roster and national tv exposure and a big streaming platform, is not doing better attendance wise. The coddling of Uncle Tony and his business is just silly lol. I'm getting the upset finger wag for just asking why more people don't want to attend Dynamite.

Michael Jordan Lol GIF by ESPN


"AEW isn't all that niche"

michael jordan laughing GIF
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
Shida vs. Maya World for the TBS title added to Redemption.

JEricho vs. Ciampa was made a no holds barred match. I thought that had already been announced? Maybe I just saw a Collision spoiler then.

Divine Dominion vs. Sisters of Sin in a hardcore match for the tag titles on Wednesday.
 

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
3,746
2,167
47
You can’t hate on Aldis he’s great and you know it. He had a great match with Cody at all in years ago.
1) He's a GM
2) He's boring
3) His match vs. Cody at the OG All In was boring
4) He's a GM
5) Gunther should be above the level of facing a GM after retiring three legends and being a WWE Heavyweight Champion twice for combined over 300 days
 

Laparkafan

Heisman
Sep 5, 2004
14,638
10,187
93
Also it’s ironic page is a midcarder now I never thought he was great but he’s friends with elite. He hadn’t gotten any better since his roh days.