Effing schools are indoctrinating our children

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
Actually, no we can't. Forcing students to read a particular religious text to the exclusion of all others is the very core of establishing a state religion. The Constitution clearly prohibits it, and the 14th Amendment applies it to state governments. There's no "disagreement" possible - there's only right or wrong. @kidmike41 is entitled to be wrong but it makes him look dumb.
I’m sure you’re wrong all the time. Don’t worry about it too much. Read a history book sometime. Why would the 13 colonies all have state Christian religions if this country wasn’t founded by Christians?
 

tarheelbybirth1

Heisman
Jul 4, 2025
4,826
14,441
113
I’m sure you’re wrong all the time. Don’t worry about it too much. Read a history book sometime. Why would the 13 colonies all have state Christian religions if this country wasn’t founded by Christians?
Because the colonies were not the federal government. Take a knee... you have no f'n idea what you're talking about.
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
Actually, most of the Founding Fathers were theists who paid lip service to Christianity. They were students of the Enlightenment which valued reason over superstition. Jefferson took a blade and famously (and literally) cut all the miracles out of his NT because he thought they were stupid.

James Madison, the Father of the Constitution, wrote:

Strongly guarded as is the separation between Religion & Govt in the Constitution of the United States the danger of encroachment by Ecclesiastical Bodies, may be illustrated by precedents already furnished in their short history [attempts where religious bodies had already tried to encroach on the government]. [James Madison, Detached Memoranda, 1820]

The idea that you've "read the full history of this country" is laughable.
Liberals scared to read the Bible is laughable to me. Oh no, your children may realize you’re leading them astray!
 

tarheelbybirth1

Heisman
Jul 4, 2025
4,826
14,441
113
Liberals scared to read the Bible is laughable to me. Oh no, your children may realize you’re leading them astray!
This isn't about the Bible, dipshit. It's about the Constitution. That you can't understand what the thread is about just cements your stupidity in place.
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
This isn't about the Bible, dipshit. It's about the Constitution. That you can't understand what the thread is about just cements your stupidity in place.
The constitution allows Texas to teach the Bible in school. We will see what the Supreme Court says. They are lawyers, they know best.
 

tarheelbybirth1

Heisman
Jul 4, 2025
4,826
14,441
113
The constitution allows Texas to teach the Bible in school. We will see what the Supreme Court says. They are lawyers, they know best.
As part of a comparative religion course, yes, they do. Requiring that children read the Bible to the exclusion of every other religious text? No, they don't. Period - and it's not even a close call. You've been wrong on every point so far, so I suppose it's no surprise you're wrong still.

Just out of curiosity, could a state require that all children read from the Quran with no other religious texts included?
 

TJ8869

All-Conference
Dec 16, 2022
2,443
4,714
113
The 14th amendment had nothing to do with religion. It was slavery/civil rights.

Federal law/constitution trumps state and local law. We all know this. So how until 1833 did we have state religions if the 1st amendment said that is not allowed?
Because that's how long it took for other groups to wrest power from the Puritan Congregationalists.
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
As part of a comparative religion course, yes, they do. Requiring that children read the Bible to the exclusion of every other religious text? No, they don't. Period - and it's not even a close call. You've been wrong on every point so far, so I suppose it's no surprise you're wrong still.

Just out of curiosity, could a state require that all children read from the Quran with no other religious texts included?
Minnesota is working towards that right now.
 

St. Louis Hawk

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
3,782
11,510
113
The constitution allows Texas to teach the Bible in school. We will see what the Supreme Court says. They are lawyers, they know best.

The Court has repeatedly decided that public schools cannot do this.

What is your source for “the constitution allows Texas to teach the Bible in school.”

Oklahoma just dropped its efforts to do this in the face of multiple lawsuits.
 

The_Joker13_rivals

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2013
662
1,662
92
Kidmike is a retarded troll guys, just ignore him. On the subject at hand, I take solace in the fact I’ll be dead and gone within the next 50 years. I suggest the rest of you just enjoy the ride as America continues its gradual decline and appreciate the fact you won’t be around for its eventual collapse. Likely a couple hundred years out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: THE_DEVIL

Ktrain1969

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2025
1,676
2,412
113
Kidmike is a retarded troll guys, just ignore him. On the subject at hand, I take solace in the fact I’ll be dead and gone within the next 50 years. I suggest the rest of you just enjoy the ride as America continues its gradual decline and appreciate the fact you won’t be around for its eventual collapse. Likely a couple hundred years out.
It won't take that long.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tarheelbybirth1

Hotshoe

All-American
Feb 15, 2012
26,093
6,425
113
Which school teaches that? Link? You’re anti-Constitution. All MAGAs are.
Not remotely true. The right is fully inline with the Constitution, particularly, the Bill of Rights, which the left has shown time and again, does not support. From censorship regarding the 1st Amendment, to the 2nd Amendment, y'all have constantly attacked both.

I don't agree with this in Texas whatsoever, but you absolutely cannot teach American history without including the study of religion. It simply cannot be done and teach real history.
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
Kidmike is a retarded troll guys, just ignore him. On the subject at hand, I take solace in the fact I’ll be dead and gone within the next 50 years. I suggest the rest of you just enjoy the ride as America continues its gradual decline and appreciate the fact you won’t be around for its eventual collapse. Likely a couple hundred years out.
No one is trolling. Get off my message board if you can’t have a discussion.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: PW Herman

Hotshoe

All-American
Feb 15, 2012
26,093
6,425
113
So you know in the 13 colonies each colony had a state religion. That religion was actually funded by the government. Massachusetts was the last state to get rid of their state religion, in 1833. Anyway other denominations didn’t like that there was a state religion so they put in the establishment clause. All of the religions were Christian though. So Islam was never part of the discussion.
You are correct.
 

Hotshoe

All-American
Feb 15, 2012
26,093
6,425
113
The Establishment Clause is in the Constitution. The Lemon test provides guidance for courts to determine whether a specific law or policy violates the Establishment Clause. And requiring public school students to read Bible verses almost certainly violates all three components of the test.

That's what Sunday school is for. Or private schools. The only time religion should be taught in public schools is in the context of its role in shaping world history.
I totally agree, except in the case of America. You cannot teach American history without teaching Religion in America. It absolutely is who we are. Every historian knows this.
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
And you can teach it without reading a single word of any holy text.
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights”. I wonder who this creator is? How could we teach the students about him?
 

DFSNOLE_rivals

Heisman
Sep 25, 2002
3,803
10,084
113
“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights”. I wonder who this creator is? How could we teach the students about him?
Allah?
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
Why then do we have a SCOTUS to settle these type of issues?
Well I am getting yelled at about the 14th amendment applying to the separation of church and state. It doesn’t explicitly say anything about that, but the Supreme Court through other rulings has intimated that it brings the 1st amendment to bear on the states governments. My logic is simply that the Supreme Court could clarify this stance on religion and clear it up.
 

DFSNOLE_rivals

Heisman
Sep 25, 2002
3,803
10,084
113
Well I am getting yelled at about the 14th amendment applying to the separation of church and state. It doesn’t explicitly say anything about that, but the Supreme Court through other rulings has intimated that it brings the 1st amendment to bear on the states governments. My logic is simply that the Supreme Court could clarify this stance on religion and clear it up.
It seems your stance throughout has been that this is perfectly constitutional.
 

Hotshoe

All-American
Feb 15, 2012
26,093
6,425
113
Of course it did - to the federal government as of 1787, and to the states as of 1868.
To the contrary. Those words are never mentioned in the Constitution, nor can you find them. It simply states, Congress will make no law respecting an establishment of religion. That does not mean what you believe it does. You clearly missed the second part where the government cannot interfere with the Free Exercise Clause. It's still debated to this very day regarding schools, particularly, private religious schools.

Why do private schools have the right to teach a certain religion, and not others?

Like I stated earlier, I don't agree with Texas, but it's definitely a gray area, and will likely go to the SCOTUS. That said, look at Jefferson's letter to the Danbury Baptists in 1802.

"Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between man and his God... thus building a wall of separation between Church & State."

The SCOTUS used his words to reinforce the Establishment Clause in the 20th century.
 

Hotshoe

All-American
Feb 15, 2012
26,093
6,425
113
Things Republicans refuse to focus on:
Jobs.
Economy.
Inflation.
Healthcare.
National debt.
Staying out of wars.

Things Republicans only want to focus on:
Trans bashing.
Minority bashing.
Women bashing.
And indoctrinating our kids with crap like this.
You need more emotions!
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
3,550
5,879
113
It seems your stance throughout has been that this is perfectly constitutional.
I believe that the separation of church and state is not as extreme as y’all. I think the constitution applies to a state sponsored Christian denomination, it was never meant to exclude Christianity from everyday life. Thats why some government meetings open with blessing, etc.