Pikiell Gets Supportive Nod from Keli Zinn

dark_check

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2022
2,722
3,235
113
People are just mad about last year so they don’t want to see how things are starting to get better and are just moving the goal posts to stay angry. They don’t want to hear about NIL, even though that was the key factor for the last 3 years.
Blowing big leads at home, starting in big holes on the road and losing is not getting better. And keep blaming NIL if you want but when we get more so will all the other schools. Plus it’s what you do with what you have. Pike has little eye for talent and how are teams with no NIL like ccsu beating us if it’s only about NIL
 

Loyal-Son

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2016
1,473
2,772
81
As soon as I saw this, I smiled.

She said Pike is getting at least two years to turn this around. I figured that would trigger mass hysteria here.

I am half wondering if she did that deliberately to trigger the "fire the coach" crowd, though I strongly lean toward her just trying to educate people about her perspective.

For me, this makes the off-season even more interesting as I will be eager to see what Pike comes up with as the best team money can buy.

His strength may be long-term coaching the same players, and that to me will be his biggest challenge by far - keeping guys until they play the game as he wants it played. Maybe that is a reason she is seeing 2 years as necessary?
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,616
86,618
113
Sit this one out

Mulchahy already knew the story
How about you sit down and shut up? Mulcahy arrived in April 1998, after the incident.
Sept 12, 1999 story:

"Mulcahy decided disciplinary action wasn’t necessary, but Bannon and his staff were given a review of the code of conduct and Mulcahy emphasized Rutgers will never condone “improper behavior by any of our coaches.

Mulcahy wasn’t athletic director when the free-throw contest took place. He said he heard about it shortly after his arrival, discussed it with Bannon, told him it was inappropriate and “nothing like this has transpired since.”"
------
"Later he said, “This matter occurred some 20 months ago prior to my appointment as athletic director [in February, ’98]. When I heard about this shortly after coming aboard I discussed it with Kevin. I told him that it was inappropriate and I would not condone that type of behavior.

“I wanted to make sure that we were on the same page and Kevin agreed. Kevin is a proven mentor and coach whose record speaks for itself. Nothing like this has transpired since and I consider the matter closed.”"

"Geoff Billet, who was Rutgers’ captain that season, said the players seemed to enjoy stripping during the contest.
“It was fun,” said Billet, who finished his standout career after last season and is now an assistant coach at Monmouth University. “The point of the thing was to have some fun. That’s how the guys took it. As it kept going on, guys were laughing. The losers would have to do a suicide naked. We were going to play until the very end."
---
-----
Totally different set of facts, and a different person in charge and at a different time when people were less uptight. See Billet's comments.

But Mulcahy's statements are far from a ringing endorsement of Bannon.
-----



 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,616
86,618
113
Somehow they are forgetting this. Likely on purpose...RU returning talent still bottom tier of league and no guarantee Francus stays

Is Pikes going from 12-20 to 20-12

Well now we have people saying he should get 2 years
Like Keli Zinn implied in the story?

Maybe that's correct. It took Uncle Bob 2 more years to fire Bannon--using that only because you and your bro think that is relevant somehow. ;)
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
247,535
177,245
113
How about you sit down and shut up? Mulcahy arrived in April 1998, after the incident.
Sept 12, 1999 story:

"Mulcahy decided disciplinary action wasn’t necessary, but Bannon and his staff were given a review of the code of conduct and Mulcahy emphasized Rutgers will never condone “improper behavior by any of our coaches.

Mulcahy wasn’t athletic director when the free-throw contest took place. He said he heard about it shortly after his arrival, discussed it with Bannon, told him it was inappropriate and “nothing like this has transpired since.”"
------
"Later he said, “This matter occurred some 20 months ago prior to my appointment as athletic director [in February, ’98]. When I heard about this shortly after coming aboard I discussed it with Kevin. I told him that it was inappropriate and I would not condone that type of behavior.

“I wanted to make sure that we were on the same page and Kevin agreed. Kevin is a proven mentor and coach whose record speaks for itself. Nothing like this has transpired since and I consider the matter closed.”"

"Geoff Billet, who was Rutgers’ captain that season, said the players seemed to enjoy stripping during the contest.
“It was fun,” said Billet, who finished his standout career after last season and is now an assistant coach at Monmouth University. “The point of the thing was to have some fun. That’s how the guys took it. As it kept going on, guys were laughing. The losers would have to do a suicide naked. We were going to play until the very end."
---
-----
Totally different set of facts, and a different person in charge and at a different time when people were less uptight. See Billet's comments.

But Mulcahy's statements are far from a ringing endorsement of Bannon.
-----

He knew the story and lauded Bannon in public...fact

I attended the Bannon show with other die hards..sit this one out
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,616
86,618
113
Kelli wont make it here if Pike us allowed to go 6 seasons without a ncaa bid
How about let next season play out before jumping to conclusions.
None of my statements are a "ringing endorsement" of Pikiell and a desire to keep him at Rutgers. They are a realization of the economic realities of the previous AD signing Pikiell and Schiano to long term contracts when they were not warranted and the "new" need for NIL funds. Pikiell's was a bit more "justified" than Schiano's.

It is kind of comical that both Schiano and Pikiell have been on the same downward trajectory after signing their extension, moving to losing seasons one year after each of their respective extensions.

Continue to kick and scream and stamp your feet. It will not change anything. Unless the whiners can muster up the $$$ to buy one or both of them out.



 

fatsam98

Heisman
Mar 23, 2005
43,410
37,904
113
I honestly don't read that as he has two years guaranteed.

I read it as he has next year to get things back in the right direction when NIL will be less of an excuse -- and if he doesn't, then I suspect there will be a change.

I don't think he's the right man anymore, but I respect Zinn for coming out and at least telling us what she's thinking. His ridiculous contract is not her fault.

Also it's great to read her thoughts on the RAC. A big, expensive, shiny, soulless arena is just not what we need.

I think overall I'm encouraged by our AD/President -- it's just a shame the absolute disaster they inherited.
 

mugrat86

Heisman
Dec 11, 2014
8,146
10,667
82
He could have had Ewin. Passed. He just needed to surround them with athletic defense which he could afford, half of us here knew that. He chose to spend his money on inefficient shooters. It’s not that he had zero additional money. He made bad choices. Stop fooling yourself.
I am not saying Pike is perfect, just refuting all of the guys who totally despise him and claim he can't coach. I bet Pike had more top 25 wins against any previous coach combined. Think about that for a second before you totally trash him.
 

RC80

All-Conference
Feb 25, 2021
1,377
1,688
113
Stuff has to change with staff - cause a new Center, PG, SF - isn't going to make this team automatically better if it doesn't get an assistant to install a 21st century system. Now maybe that is part of the equation by her even saying 2027-28; no assistant coach is showing up thinking the HC has one year. So will see how many more times she floats 2027-28 in her future statements; And not only who gets added from a player perspective; but which assistant(s) gets moved out and importantly who gets added in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers36

RRRRUUUU

All-Conference
Nov 19, 2005
2,376
2,010
63
I don’t think pike is the right guy - really only because he is more loyal to his paid staff than he is to Rutgers basketball. If he made the necessary staff changes, that would be big in my view.

Can’t fault Zinn for giving him another year (or 2?) with the insane buyout that Hobbs hamstrung her with. The buyout plus hiring a new coach plus the NIL a new coach would want to take the job, puts her in a hard spot.

But hopefully she forces Pike to take a hard look at the staff.
 

Mholinko

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2023
1,481
2,275
77
He’s going to be below 500 overall when this season ends after 10 years

No coach at any level anywhere gets 10 years to be sub 500 and keep their job
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

RU-ROCS

All-American
Feb 5, 2003
12,417
7,598
113
If Pike had the money to keep the best players on the current roster and to bring in a legit Big 10 center, PG and a wing this could be a good team. I think that’s Kelly’s thinking. And given Pike’s past success and big buyout I think that’s a reasonable approach.
 

dark_check

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2022
2,722
3,235
113
I am not saying Pike is perfect, just refuting all of the guys who totally despise him and claim he can't coach. I bet Pike had more top 25 wins against any previous coach combined. Think about that for a second before you totally trash him.
Top 25 wins don’t make ncaa tourneys. And the half of you who love Pike have to stop vilifying us that don’t feel he can win in this era. He’s done quite a bit to lose our faith in the last few years. None of us despise him or think he can’t coach at all. He’s just fell off a cliff since 21-22
 

RUfrom NJ

Junior
Jul 22, 2025
148
216
43
He’s going to be below 500 overall when this season ends after 10 years

No coach at any level anywhere gets 10 years to be sub 500 and keep their job
Since "turning the program around" in 2019-20:
  • 112-99 (60-71)
  • 25-71 away from the RAC
  • 2-5 in B1G tournament
  • 1 NCAA tournament win
  • National embarrassment last season
  • Several losses to low-majors/bad mid-majors
I respect Pikiell's character and for the success we had 5 years ago, but the reality is the reality.
 

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
33,669
38,140
113
The Problem will be Ultra Loyal Pike not wanting to replace any coach or player, and wanting to build with his young guys, while other teams continue to pay for age and experience, and/or 5 star freshman. There’s simply not enough talent, young or not, to compete with upper half big ten teams. The one spot we know they’ll look to invest in is the most expensive, it’ll eat up half our NIL budget, and What stud portal Center is choosing RU?

he needs to move TJ back to an administrative role and bring in fresh ideas.
 

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
33,669
38,140
113
Somehow they are forgetting this. Likely on purpose...RU returning talent still bottom tier of league and no guarantee Francus stays

Is Pikes going from 12-20 to 20-12

Well now we have people saying he should get 2 years

I mean, he basically did that in 2020.
 

SirScarlet

Heisman
Jun 27, 2001
27,272
44,354
113
Zinn and Tate love to tell people we now have NIL and money isn’t an issue. It better be true. And, assuming it is, they better demand success from these coaches.
Thats how I take this.

They're making it clear to prospective new coaches - and the entire college athletics world - that they will support our coaches with ample funding. Then it is on them to deliver.

It's a smart strategy and while it leaves us fans in limbo for a little bit longer it's the right move for the future.

I will say this with regards to basketball specifically.. .if he doesn't bring on board a much stronger offensive assistant coach it will just be a waste of money
 
  • Like
Reactions: bitnez

SirScarlet

Heisman
Jun 27, 2001
27,272
44,354
113
People are just mad about last year so they don’t want to see how things are starting to get better and are just moving the goal posts to stay angry. They don’t want to hear about NIL, even though that was the key factor for the last 3 years.
You are a great fan but this isn't the whole story and its a bit unfair.

There have been fewer Pike Fanboys on this website than myself since he showed up. But he is screwing the pooch in terms of not evolving offensively. So while nil will definitely help us he needs to evolve. Otherwise he will not last here much longer and he shouldn't.

College basketball has evolved so must he
 

RUDivision

All-Conference
Jan 6, 2023
2,323
1,825
42
which of the other seven coaches we have had since Tom Young did not have glaring coaching issues? My point is it's very very hard to find a perfect coach. You have to get very lucky
Extremely fair point and all coaches should get an opportunity to show and prove what they can do. It’s been over a decade and it’s time to move on. Too many missed opportunities and mistakes combined with the biggest let down in schools history
 
  • Like
Reactions: dark_check

richthedentist

All-American
Aug 2, 2001
11,013
8,567
113
Not starting Francis in 2nd half cost RU a ton of points . Its criminal
It’s criminal for him to not start at this point and he should be playing 36 minutes him not playing at the start of each half is criminal and I don’t think this BS about him coming off the bench is better is just that
Any good coach would recognize this
 

RAC93

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2023
3,027
4,949
113
Since "turning the program around" in 2019-20:
  • 112-99 (60-71)
  • 25-71 away from the RAC
  • 2-5 in B1G tournament
  • 1 NCAA tournament win
  • National embarrassment last season
  • Several losses to low-majors/bad mid-majors
I respect Pikiell's character and for the success we had 5 years ago, but the reality is the reality.
Very succinct breakdown. Pike is a good man who has done some good things at RU. However, he has had his time to elevate and show us more and that has not happened. If next year is another fail (hard to see how it can’t be at this point), he needs to be gone with Zinn putting her stamp on her own hire to try and row this boat in a more positive direction.
 

dpwhite

All-American
Jan 21, 2003
2,948
7,109
103
Now we are upset he blew the Houston game in the NCAA, or the ND play in game, or the Minn game , or the NIT game or the 2 NBA lottery picks, or the last 3 sub 500
Seasons. ALL get a coach fired !

RU band fans, everyone gets a trophy, keep the head coach and just keep kicking the standard of Excellence down the road:

Out biggest obstacle, more so than NIL Money, is the loser DNA mentality of our fan b
Ok i had no idea why this replied and I cant seem to delete
 

RUskoolie

Hall of Famer
Aug 1, 2007
221,413
112,104
63
The fact that Pike could actually compete in this conference with the talent level he has is an absolute testament to his coaching abilities. There were many people and mods who commented that we wouldn't win a conference game
This is where you are at. This is why I hate this fanbase more each week. You are celebrating...in YEAR 10 mind you...that we are competing in the B1G and didn't lose every conference game.

Most of you deserve the complete loser programs you get to watch and it's why the nation mocks this athletic department frequently.
 

RUskoolie

Hall of Famer
Aug 1, 2007
221,413
112,104
63
This boy is spot on! Thank you! But alot on this board still doesn’t get it.
A lot of this board doesn't belong rooting for big time athletics. They complain about $32 parking for basketball, brag about flipping Pokemon cards in the hallways of the RAC and how they shook down a teenager with pimples at Shake Shack for their free milk shake because of 2 missed free throws. They haven't a clue as to what it takes to compete in big boy football, basketball and virtually every other sport at RU.
 

RUskoolie

Hall of Famer
Aug 1, 2007
221,413
112,104
63
Sure be like the old Rutgers and keep a horrible coach and let the product continue to rot.

Next year Pike will get to 6 conf wins and his supporters will scream from the Moutainside tops about his big improvement.

The program will continue to lose money!

Like every other Power 4 school you fire the embarrassment and bring in the next top coach.
We are not like every other P4 school. The school is keeping Rutgers in the P4. Their poor and uninspired alumni and fans are not those ones floating it. Other P4 schools have enough big donors to cut that check. Our big donors (I **** you not) some of them are still asking for people to define what's NIL.
 

RUDivision

All-Conference
Jan 6, 2023
2,323
1,825
42
which of the other seven coaches we have had since Tom Young did not have glaring coaching issues? My point is it's very very hard to find a perfect coach. You have to get very lucky
It’s just being the 3/4 longest tenured coach in the Big Ten and having a losing record after this season shows we have given him enough time!

Why are we the only school that operates like a Mikey mouse school?

Between Pike’s glaring faults and Greg’s Ineptitude on the field and his DC searches!

NO other power 4 school serious about Athletics, winning, and wanting to eliminate its money deficit allows them to continue to coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

SirScarlet

Heisman
Jun 27, 2001
27,272
44,354
113
We are not like every other P4 school. The school is keeping Rutgers in the P4. Their poor and uninspired alumni and fans are not those ones floating it. Other P4 schools have enough big donors to cut that check. Our big donors (I **** you not) some of them are still asking for people to define what's NIL.
You know I agree with you...I and many others have said the same thing for ages.

I think what makes our situation a bit unique is that our athletic programs have done nothing on the field to inspire sustained confidence. I think this is a much bigger issue than most people want to give Credence to. If you look at the head coaching hires we have made over the past 50 years they have almost all been atrocious. Our inability to hire good coaches has to be some psychology experiment down the road.

My simple point is this at some point the programs need to deliver some level of sustained success. And I am not talking about National titles. But sustained success. And sustained success does not mean sucking around average or 500.

So we have this vicious chicken and egg argument all the time.

But let me cut to the chase because no one wants to read my babble. We finally have an athletic director and a president that are fully aligned and know what the **** they are doing. If we cannot start to turn the ship around under these two I am being dead serious we should shut our entire "big time" athletics department down and go back to the Patriot league.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
247,535
177,245
113
To play devils advocate this line was likely written about the SHU head coach last season.
He gutted that team not keeping 9 like our fanbase wants and bought a whole new one with comparable money to rest of conference in an easier league....and they are still only a bubble team.Holloway way more of an adaptable coach than Pike. Pike increase of money will still put RU in bottom 4 of Big 10 in funding and he has a traditionally poor track record in portal.
 

winfield102

All-Conference
Jun 15, 2005
7,137
2,782
113
I am not saying Pike is perfect, just refuting all of the guys who totally despise him and claim he can't coach. I bet Pike had more top 25 wins against any previous coach combined. Think about that for a second before you totally trash him.
I'm curious how many cracks we get against top 26 teams. I'd guess that he gets more at bats against top 25 teams than past coaches.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Koko