OT: Tariff Economics Discussion

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
It’s funny, that when Trump announces a tariff yesterday the market now rallies.

A lot of people owe this thread an apology. Let’s go back to the beginning of the thread and see whose predictions were correct.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nmerritt11

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
If we can all put politics aside for a moment (not likely), what's the general consensus on the tariff strategy? Just from a pure economics standpoint it looks to me like:

Short-term possible outcomes:
*Price-hikes will happen on those goods while different manufacturing options are sought (high)
*Scarcity of some goods (medium)
*Panic in the markets due to the unknown (high)
*China relents and a settlement is reached (medium)

Long-term possible outcomes:
*Manufacturers outside of China step in and prices return to pre-tariff rates (medium)
*Prices remain high driving some inflation (medium)
*China pulls more goods from us (low)

Are we far enough along in the strategy to assess their effectiveness and results yet?

Short term - prices have stopped rising as fast as they were. Inflation on CPI reports and PPI reports have come in inline. Truflation showing 1.7%.

- Good are plentiful with no scarcity to speak of
- Markets did briefly panic but this was due to the unknown and uncertainty and they quickly recovered to all time highs

long term - manufacturing is indeed returning to the United States.

So far the textbooks have been wrong and I’d say that Trump has threaded the needle.

Definitely too early to declare victory but the markets like the results so far.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
One of my biggest concerns is what happens in 2020 or 2024 when Trump is out of office. How many of these deals or tariffs or whatever will be quickly overturned because it was Trump? How will the next round of negotiations go when we bend over agin and take it in the shorts.

Seeing the results we are seeing I think the tariffs will be used by future presidents. Many of Trumps tariffs in his first term were kept by Biden.

If someone runs on removing tariffs they are going to have to explain how they will defend all the jobs that the tariffs are bringing home.

Do you still think we are “taking it in the shorts? “
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
Simply stated, tariffs are a terrible idea. They have never worked and they won't work this time. The only thing they accomplish is to tax American consumers and hurt industries like BMW which imports steel and aluminum to use in its manufacturing plant in SC. If a country is willing to sell us goods at a lower cost than we can create them, that is a good thing because it frees up money for our consumers to use for other purposes. If the Idiot-in-Chief understood economics, which he doesn't, he would know that our massive deficits, financed by the Chinese are far more negative than trade deficits.
Care to update this post?
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
Do any economists actually think tariffs are a good idea? My guess is many of the people who like the current tariffs wouldn't have liked them a few years ago when they were for free markets ("everything will be different with Trump! :)"). Many of the people pretending to hate tariffs right now probably would've been for them a few years ago, too ("everything will be different with Trump! :(").
Hmmmm
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
Several points worth noting here:
1) The incidence of the tariffs is mostly being paid by US consumers. For example, the tariffs on aluminum and steel have allowed these industries to expand and increase employment. However, the cost of steel has risen dramatically. For each job saved in the steel and aluminum industry consumers and businesses have paid an additional $900,000 through higher prices -- more than 13 times the wage of a steelworker. (Peterson Institute)

2) The net effect on jobs in the US economy from higher tariffs is zero. Tariffs can save jobs in the steel or aluminum industry but it drives up prices in steel-using industries. The higher costs imply higher prices for these goods and less demand. If the demand for products falls and then so does employment. A dispassionate look at the data shows no (positive) correlation between tariffs and aggregate employment nor a (negative) correlation imports and employment.

3) A 25% tariffs on autos and auto parts would be a nightmare for the US auto producers and US consumers. Global supply chains would be seriously disrupted and the impact on costs would likely exceed the implied tariff costs. In fact, the uncertainty about tariff policies and a trade war seems to be having a negative impact in several markets.

4) Using tariffs as a mechanism to get concessions from trading partners has not been very successful. At best, tariffs and tariff threats have resulted in concessions about 50% of the time and the concessions have been meaningful in terms of achieving the objective at about a 40% hit rate. However, these attempts have been pretty small scale attempts. The Administration's experiment is on a much grander scale. It could work or it could result in another Smoot-Hawley episode.

5) Finally, the focus on bilateral trade deficits is misplaced. I run persistent bilateral trade deficits with Publix. I buy a lot from them and they buy nothing from me, but what matters is my overall spending behavior. Similarly, it is not a surprise that the US would run persistent bilateral trade deficits with a country as trade is driven primarily by comparative advantage. What matters is the overall trade deficit and that is driven primarily by macroeconomic factors. If we want to reduce our trade deficits then the US needs to increase private savings, reduce government deficits and the trade deficit will begin to fall. There are other things could do like impose capital controls or manipulate the exchange rate, but meddling in markets is unlikely to have unintended consequences.

These are some of the points that are included in a presentation that I am working on today for a talk later this month.
Care to revisit this post? A lot of wrong in there
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
Short term adjustments in the tariff are only hurting cash flows , inventory levels and input pricing.

Most large companies have some inventories in a Free Trade Zone warehouse in the US. They will move that inventory to a paid location over the next week where possible and pay the app 10% tariff on the inventory valve. Avoiding the 25 precent.

Steel purchase and orders are typically 10 to 16 weeks in the future with an additional 5 weeks of transit. Orders are typically placed 4 to 6 months in the future. With no definite resolution to the dispute it adds risk to move the country of origin on a product unless you have a multi country sourcing already. The market may correct before you new plan could be implemented.

Tooling to make products cost as much as the impact of the tariff for the first year.

In a lot of case the work will not return to the US.

Company will either shift to another BBC country and import into the US . Or alternatively just make products with different H- codes to avoid the tariff.

Longer term stability is needed to balance out the trade talks.
Trump has structured tariffs so that shifting to another country is very difficult. Additionally there is a baseline tariff that everyone must pay.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
I'm still waiting for the pro tariff supporters to produce some facts and figures to support their argument. Currently they are being decimated.
The stock market is at an all time high. Inflation remains much lower than during the Biden admin. Jobs are returning.

The facts and figures support Trump at this point and if you sold due to his tariff policy you were the one that indeed got decimated.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
You have to ask yourself why did this happen?

Americans choices are let China abuse their employees and provide low cost products or let Americans make them and the price be significantly higher. People want cheap. China has a lot more leverage than America.

For starters one country can vote out their politicians. I’m not saying we have a good deal with China. I just don’t trust Donald Trump is the man to fix it. He’s no different than the other fiscally liberal presidents Obama and Bush. Government is expanding and people are at the mercy of the federal government. Trump fans don’t care because they have their guy.
Do you trust Trump to fix it now? Still think he is no different than Obama or Bush?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
Going out with a double digit price increase to my customers today due to tariffs. These are items you buy at a grocery store and the increases will be passed along.
How did that price increase go for you? You lose any market share yet? Be honest.
We do where available. In most instances, it is still less expensive to source internationally even with the tariffs. The disparity in cost is too great.

Either way you slice it, it will still be a price hike to the American consumer. Sourcing domestically would be a much more pronounced hike.
Price hikes have not come as you suggested. Certainly not in the double digits. Inflation much lower with Trumps tariffs than during the Biden admin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
The story that these tariffs are going to drive huge growth in our manufacturing sector are just not true. It isn't like we can turn on factories and have supply chains moving in a couple of months.

There would have to be extended economic pain before manufacturing in the US would come close to being able to replace all the items that are imported today. The republicans won't survive the midterms, much less the 2028 election, if they think the country will stand for this kind of pain for some hope of a long-term payoff.

I had hoped he was trying put some negotiating ploy in place, but if he truly thinks these tariffs are going to deliver a huge economic boon, he will find out how quickly he can lose support when people are out of work and losing their homes and cars.
Care to revisit this post?

Lots of manufacturing is indeed returning to the US . And this far there is an economic boom. Markets are at record highs again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

Casa_del_Tigre

Heisman
Feb 2, 2017
10,166
17,878
102
Do you trust Trump to fix it now? Still think he is no different than Obama or Bush?
He’s still the same person. Dude is owned by Israel like every other president. I actually thought he would be America first but even Trump got in line.

with regards to the economy, if fed doesnt lower rates there will be a major recession before Trump leaves office. With that said I think tariffs have little to do with the issues our economy is seeing now.
 

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,773
22,015
113
Recession = No
Prices exploding = No
Currency to invest and consume is plentiful.

care to revisit this post?
I will once the actual tariffs effect the prices, they've been on again and off again for a long while. Also, you fail to notice the GDP, and of course job numbers.
From the reporting I've read from economists, companies purchased imports en masse after Trump threatened tarriffs, it sent the stock market in turmoil. Now that the tarriffs are more or less in place since Aug 1st, you actually have to wait for its impact to play out.
Thiis is a big premature ejaculation by you. Do you just not understand what tarrifs are or how our import economy works?

Heres an overview on the potential impacts you should probably get of twitter and read something: https://www.forbes.com/sites/zachar...mediately-cost-more-from-food-to-electronics/
 

yoshi121374

Heisman
Jan 26, 2006
13,367
23,377
113
I will once the actual tariffs effect the prices, they've been on again and off again for a long while. Also, you fail to notice the GDP, and of course job numbers.
From the reporting I've read from economists, companies purchased imports en masse after Trump threatened tarriffs, it sent the stock market in turmoil. Now that the tarriffs are more or less in place since Aug 1st, you actually have to wait for its impact to play out.
Thiis is a big premature ejaculation by you. Do you just not understand what tarrifs are or how our import economy works?

Heres an overview on the potential impacts you should probably get of twitter and read something: https://www.forbes.com/sites/zachar...mediately-cost-more-from-food-to-electronics/

Fatpiggy/Ole Fastball is a troll. He isn't serious, he just likes to rile people up. This is evidenced by the fact that he put on ignore people who called him out for his crap.

He is also a loser who welched on his bet by changing his username, then admitted it when caught. Still never paid though because he has no integrity.

I continue to make that point and bring that up , since we have a bunch of new posters who may not realize what a little ***** he is
 

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,773
22,015
113
Fatpiggy/Ole Fastball is a troll. He isn't serious, he just likes to rile people up. This is evidenced by the fact that he put on ignore people who called him out for his crap.

He is also a loser who welched on his bet by changing his username, then admitted it when caught. Still never paid though because he has no integrity.

I continue to make that point and bring that up , since we have a bunch of new posters who may not realize what a little ***** he is
I mean, I know he's got no principles or integrity, but I do not believe he thinks he's trolling, he honestly thinks he's got his mind wrapped around these issues and he thinks he's schooling folks. The problem of course, is he obviously hasn't read a book since Dr Seuss. It goes against all wise advise to interact with fools. Yet Im a horrible optimist and humanist. Foolish of me, I know.
Fascism is afoot in America, he's a willing participant, so I like mocking him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yoshi121374

CU_4734

Heisman
Aug 9, 2016
7,857
18,914
113
It sends the market to all time highs
You woke up on a rager this morning!

What’s your age range? I think answer will give me an idea of how to approach my point on how fvcked people in their 20s-40s (if those in their 40s still have kids at home).
 

MBRO

Heisman
Dec 7, 2003
9,670
26,527
113
How did that price increase go for you? You lose any market share yet? Be honest.

Price hikes have not come as you suggested. Certainly not in the double digits. Inflation much lower with Trumps tariffs than during the Biden admin.
Yes, we have lost share. Our packaging is 60% steel/aluminum. Many of our customers have converted their products to plastic or flexible bags, which are not impacted to the same degree.

Regarding price hikes, most CPGs built inventory in advance of the tariffs taking effect and are burning through that. Others have contracts with retailers like Wal-Mart that require a 90-120 day notice on price change.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
I mean, I know he's got no principles or integrity, but I do not believe he thinks he's trolling, he honestly thinks he's got his mind wrapped around these issues and he thinks he's schooling folks. The problem of course, is he obviously hasn't read a book since Dr Seuss. It goes against all wise advise to interact with fools. Yet Im a horrible optimist and humanist. Foolish of me, I know.
Fascism is afoot in America, he's a willing participant, so I like mocking him.
Mr been wrong about everything and will never admit it.

You are the same one railing against Bitcoin since it was $20,000 and still claim you are right.

Same with your claims above. inflation! Empty shelves! High grocery prices!

Maybe you should put down the books and remove the “experts” junk from your throat and look at reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
You woke up on a rager this morning!

What’s your age range? I think answer will give me an idea of how to approach my point on how fvcked people in their 20s-40s (if those in their 40s still have kids at home).

I’m 47 with 4 teenagers at home.

Not sure what that has to do with anything.

FWIW I 100% agree we are fvcking our children’s future. But socialism and or communism isn’t the way to go.

I support working on the wealth gap and I support working on the housing crisis. I support keeping jobs in America.

I’d like to see the deficit / debt addressed, something neither party has shown a will to do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,773
22,015
113
Mr been wrong about everything and will never admit it.

You are the same one railing against Bitcoin since it was $20,000 and still claim you are right.

Same with your claims above. inflation! Empty shelves! High grocery prices!

Maybe you should put down the books and remove the “experts” junk from your throat and look at reality.
Fatty, just because you don't understand the nuance of my points doesn't mean im wrong. It just means you are incapable of understanding them.
You simply do not parse or understand my claims. Nor what is actually going on. That doesnt make me wrong, it makes you stupid.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
Fatty, just because you don't understand the nuance of my points doesn't mean im wrong. It just means you are incapable of understanding them.
You simply do not parse or understand my claims. Nor what is actually going on. That doesnt make me wrong, it makes you stupid.

Since i don;t seem to understand, why don't you explain to everyone else why you are right about Bitcoin despite you calling for it's demise since it was $20,000.

And why don't you tell everyone else, since i don't understand, why grocery prices are through the roof (lol), shelves are empty, and the stock market has crashed. Almost everything you predicted has happened. (except the exact opposite).

You are like Trump in many ways, will never admit a mistake.
 

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,773
22,015
113
Since i don;t seem to understand, why don't you explain to everyone else why you are right about Bitcoin despite you calling for it's demise since it was $20,000.

And why don't you tell everyone else, since i don't understand, why grocery prices are through the roof (lol), shelves are empty, and the stock market has crashed. Almost everything you predicted has happened. (except the exact opposite).

You are like Trump in many ways, will never admit a mistake.
You are gish galloping me, look it up because I know you don't know what that is.
If you would like I can tell you what I think about crypto currency
or other topics you can ask. What you shouldn't be doing is claiming I said bitcoin was going to die. Because I didn't, you just didn't understand what I stated on the topic.

Grocery prices are up. They keep going up, its easy to go check the consumer price index on that. Please find where I said the stock market was crashing or shelves were empty? You again, seem to just not understand my comments.

I'm not like Trump, I don't rape women and squelch on my payments.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
You are gish galloping me, look it up because I know you don't know what that is.
If you would like I can tell you what I think about crypto currency
or other topics you can ask. What you shouldn't be doing is claiming I said bitcoin was going to die. Because I didn't, you just didn't understand what I stated on the topic.

Grocery prices are up. They keep going up, its easy to go check the consumer price index on that. Please find where I said the stock market was crashing or shelves were empty? You again, seem to just not understand my comments.

I'm not like Trump, I don't rape women and squelch on my payments.
Exactly what i thought you would post. No accountability with you. Just screaming at the clouds.
 

CU_4734

Heisman
Aug 9, 2016
7,857
18,914
113
I’m 47 with 4 teenagers at home.

Not sure what that has to do with anything.

FWIW I 100% agree we are fvcking our children’s future. But socialism and or communism isn’t the way to go.

I support working on the wealth gap and I support working on the housing crisis. I support keeping jobs in America.

I’d like to see the deficit / debt addressed, something neither party has shown a will to do.
Yeah I don’t think we disagree much from a macro level but my first comment was specifically around tariff implications to specific markets that will hurt every day Americans. I work in supply chain for a chemical manufacturer and our product is used in many applications that you use everyday. The auto market has been a disastrous cycle for a while. Production constraints because of the global supply chain issue during COVID. Then Biden’s stupid moves lead to manufacturers not knowing what to focus on (EV or Gas). Now we’ve got tariffs to deal with. And that’s just one market. Lots of other markets are dealing with the same cycles. That’s why we can’t go to a grocery store right now for less than $300 for a week. Supply chains have been cramped since COVID and had to deal with geopolitical issues since and were facing the burden. Just because the stock market is up doesn’t mean there isn’t a crisis that the lower/lower-middle class is dealing with. I think ensuring free trade is an effort that should always be evaluated, I just think it’s a ****** time to take drastic measures. Short term gains for the deficit that fuel long term pains for lower/lower-middle class families.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy

Dadar

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2003
5,196
3,973
113
Care to revisit this post?

Lots of manufacturing is indeed returning to the US . And this far there is an economic boom. Markets are at record highs again.
The market is not the economy. Have you looked at the PE vs historical
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,001
27,000
113
The market is not the economy. Have you looked at the PE vs historical
Yes I have looked. Either prices are too high or analysts are forecasting earnings too low. The big tech companies keep crushing earnings, see Meta, MSFT, AAPL that all reported in the last week. So there may be some fear of missing out.

I see S&P 500 trading at around 22.5 times earnings when the historical average is closer to 17.

I agree the market is very rich right now. Perhaps people think the tariffs will increase the earnings of American companies and are thus thinking they will grow faster than anticipated? Perhaps we are accustom to the "Fed Put", if you will, and have become too risk averse?

What are your thoughts?
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Clemson Football Insider
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Basketball Thursday Dillon Hunter Update
  5. 05 On3 Football House working on small revisions of Protect College Sports Act before vote