Miami Hires Cristobal - Mistake IMO

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,375
113
He sucked at FIU. and wasn't that great at Oregon with every resource imaginable. Utah just ate his lunch.

Miami is getting played.

Cross-posted from the Coaching Carousel Thread (reference is to Thamel article on Yahoo):

Miami is the epitome of delusional.

From Diaz Yahoo article:

"Diaz, the son of a former Miami mayor, was given just three seasons with the Hurricanes before the school — which currently does not have an athletic director. . . "

"To get things turned around in 2020, Diaz hired Rhett Lashlee to run the offense and added D’Eriq King to play quarterback. It paid off as the Hurricanes moved into the top 10 amid an 8-1 start before closing the year with two losses.

King got hurt in the 2020 bowl game and then again early in 2021 as the team started 2-4. With King out, the Hurricanes pivoted to Tyler Van Dyke at quarterback. He had some early struggles, but he and the Miami offense put up big numbers as the season progressed."

-----
Tyler Van Dyke had a very solid freshman year. 2931 yards, 25 TDs, 6 INTs.

And let's look at their losses:

Alabama- can't count that against him.
Michigan State 38-17 (that's almost the same score RU lost by- we are as good as Miami!!!)-not a bad loss
Virginia 30-28
UNC 45-42 - really, no shame in losing by 3 points, but I guess so.
Florida State 31-28. Thou shalt not lose to Florida State in a down year?

Seriously, WTF with Miami fans and boosters? Three losses by 2-3 points each. Second place in the ACC Coastal. Three years into his tenure with his best QB out for the year gets the Mayor's son fired.

Was there something else Diaz did wrong?

Interesting comment by a reader under the story about Cristobal:

"Great recruiter, terrible coach, both in preparation and game management. FSU took "Slick Willie" off Oregon's hands, and Cristobal is just like him. Talks great, recruits great, but absolutely cannot coach, and will not let assistants do their job. Good luck Miami. Just like Florida State, you will rue this decision. In the long run, you have done Oregon a favor. Now they don't have to pay anything to fire him and you get to pay them to buy out his contract. It's a win - lose situation. Oregon wins, you lose."
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,220
17,040
113
If the U invests like they look like they are willing to and poach Clemson's AD, we might just see the Hurricanes return to be among College Foosball's elite programs with Super Mario as the HC.
The Ducks were starting to go downward before he was hired, he then brought them back to being a top PAC program , just short of being the elite program they used to be .
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
He will recruit very well imo but then what? That’s the question. He should’ve dominated the PAC12 the way Dabo dominated the ACC but he didn’t. The PAC12 was way down and ripe for picking to get into the playoffs yearly and he didn’t.

One thing in his favor is I wonder how well Clemson will handle the loss of Venables. They had a step back this year, is that a sign of what’s to come or just an exception. So the ACC could be ripe for the picking too maybe in the future. Can he take advantage this time?

Coordinator hires will be key too and then keeping them or replacing them well when they leave. His first call imo should be to Joe Brady and see if he’s interested in coming back to the area where he grew up and see if he can recreate some LSU magic.
 
Last edited:

Joey Bags

All-American
Sep 21, 2019
5,175
5,311
1
Miami is da u
More specifically, they aren’t “da u” anymore, but the fanbase expects them to be. So when you don’t put up “da u” results, you get fired. This is why the program is in this never ending feedback loop of failure or mediocrity.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,220
17,040
113
I hope temple would have some pride
Miami proved some College programs don't by the way they hired Diaz from Temple and went after Super Mario publicly while amazingly assuring Manny he'd be with them next season, unless
Cristobal came onboard and took the position
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
What’s getting lost in this is manny Diaz’s situation. A few years ago he screwed over temple and left after 2 weeks as HC . Now miami dumps him when something better comes along.
What goes around , comes around.
Mentioned that in the carousel thread…little bit karma for him but he’s still walking away with lots of money.

It would be funny if Temple did go for him again. They got paid 4M by Miami once and they could get him back again on Miami’s dime lol.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,375
113
Schiano should hire Diaz. He can help with Florida.

Definitely not sold on Cristobal. With USC down he should have been running through the Pac. The fact that he couldn't, with all of that Nike money, is telling.
Serious question. You have two choices in 2019, and they are asking for the same money to be Rutgers HC and they both want the job. Cristobal or Schiano?
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,768
151,618
113
Serious question. You have two choices in 2019, and they are asking for the same money to be Rutgers HC and they both want the job. Cristobal or Schiano?

Schiano. F Cristobal. He turned us down before. That doesn't play into my calculus though. If I thought he could win I'd want him hired. He's a right time right place guy to me. Timing is everything though. Good for him. Bad for Miami.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,375
113
Schiano. F Cristobal. He turned us down before. That doesn't play into my calculus though. If I thought he could win I'd want him hired. He's a right time right place guy to me. Timing is everything though. Good for him. Bad for Miami.
IIRC, it was his wife who perhaps turned her nose up at Rutgers and New Jersey?

Don't know how the Eugene, OR area is, but having been to Oregon a few times, would take New Jersey over Oregon every time. Portland is scary, maybe no less than many cities, but things are really out of control in Portland. Have family near Portland, and a distant cousin was murdered there in February- police have zero leads.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cicero grimes

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,768
151,618
113
Portland is a disaster. Oregon blows. It had it's run like 15 years ago. It's over.

Any beta male that gets overruled by his wife for a career upgrade is not head coach material in the first place. Calling a flame out in Miami.
 

Knightmoves

Heisman
Jul 31, 2001
30,973
17,085
113
Will be interesting to see if Cristobal’s recruiting can compete with Florida and the rest of the SEC for local recruits.

I seriously doubt it. Cristobal is not a big HC name and Miami has not been a destination for top players in quite some time. This will be an uphill climb with Miami fans expecting championships and nothing less.
 

jmg75

All-Conference
Jan 8, 2008
2,151
1,772
113
IIRC, it was his wife who perhaps turned her nose up at Rutgers and New Jersey?

Don't know how the Eugene, OR area is, but having been to Oregon a few times, would take New Jersey over Oregon every time. Portland is scary, maybe no less than many cities, but things are really out of control in Portland. Have family near Portland, and a distant cousin was murdered there in February- police have zero leads.
Portland used to be on a list of cities I most wanted to visit, but now I wouldn't set foot in that city if I were paid. Seattle was another city on the list and I am glad I went there when we played Washington State. Wouldn't go there now either. Eugene is a little over 100 miles from Portland so maybe that is far enough away to prevent being infected with whatever ails Portland. But who knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,106
38,652
113
Cross-posted from the Coaching Carousel Thread (reference is to Thamel article on Yahoo):

Miami is the epitome of delusional.

From Diaz Yahoo article:

"Diaz, the son of a former Miami mayor, was given just three seasons with the Hurricanes before the school — which currently does not have an athletic director. . . "

"To get things turned around in 2020, Diaz hired Rhett Lashlee to run the offense and added D’Eriq King to play quarterback. It paid off as the Hurricanes moved into the top 10 amid an 8-1 start before closing the year with two losses.

King got hurt in the 2020 bowl game and then again early in 2021 as the team started 2-4. With King out, the Hurricanes pivoted to Tyler Van Dyke at quarterback. He had some early struggles, but he and the Miami offense put up big numbers as the season progressed."

-----
Tyler Van Dyke had a very solid freshman year. 2931 yards, 25 TDs, 6 INTs.

And let's look at their losses:

Alabama- can't count that against him.
Michigan State 38-17 (that's almost the same score RU lost by- we are as good as Miami!!!)-not a bad loss
Virginia 30-28
UNC 45-42 - really, no shame in losing by 3 points, but I guess so.
Florida State 31-28. Thou shalt not lose to Florida State in a down year?

Seriously, WTF with Miami fans and boosters? Three losses by 2-3 points each. Second place in the ACC Coastal. Three years into his tenure with his best QB out for the year gets the Mayor's son fired.

Was there something else Diaz did wrong?

Interesting comment by a reader under the story about Cristobal:

"Great recruiter, terrible coach, both in preparation and game management. FSU took "Slick Willie" off Oregon's hands, and Cristobal is just like him. Talks great, recruits great, but absolutely cannot coach, and will not let assistants do their job. Good luck Miami. Just like Florida State, you will rue this decision. In the long run, you have done Oregon a favor. Now they don't have to pay anything to fire him and you get to pay them to buy out his contract. It's a win - lose situation. Oregon wins, you lose."

It’s not at all unreasonable to think we’d be in the middle to upper pack of the ACC right now.
 
Jun 7, 2001
37,655
45,328
113
Portland is a disaster. Oregon blows. It had it's run like 15 years ago. It's over.

Any beta male that gets overruled by his wife for a career upgrade is not head coach material in the first place. Calling a flame out in Miami.
He wasn’t over-ruled by his wife. He wanted Greg Schiano money and Rutgers didn’t want to pay that. Our loss. He couldn’t say Rutgers didn’t offer me enough. So they went with the wife said no. Now he’ll be making 4x what he wanted from Rutgers 9 years ago. In any case, had he been hired by Rutgers, he’d have been at Miami by now, anyways. Miami is where he always wanted to be. But the program
Wouldn’t have been driven into the ditch. We’re still trying to climb out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU0509
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start