Rutgers vs Indiana / Game Thread

Feb 5, 2003
11,004
9,426
113
I'm a little surprised to see Indiana still with the starters in on O after the lightning delay, considering the score.

This is the most disappointing game of the season, by a country mile. The team needs to respond and fight for 60 minutes next week to wash this stink away.
 

G- RUnit

All-American
Sep 13, 2004
14,418
8,038
113
I'm a little surprised to see Indiana still with the starters in on O after the lightning delay, considering the score.

This is the most disappointing game of the season, by a country mile. The team needs to respond and fight for 60 minutes next week to wash this stink away.

Well EMU too. Two games we had to have and failed miserably.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,449
13,339
113
"Just needs reps"

It's almost like you need to pass the ball in games in order to get better at passing the ball.

It doesn't just magically happen "in the future".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rufaninga

RUfromSoCal?

Heisman
Nov 26, 2006
35,396
43,793
113
with all due respect to patrick............


 
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
Chris Ash deserves to be left in the cornfields of the mid-west.

It's more and more evident he was a product of being at a university where he could cherry pick the best of the best talent to perform in his defense, and that's it.
I wouldn't say that. If it was just his OSU stint I'd say okay maybe but he did well at Wisconsin as DC too. Without that I would have been less sold on him with only two years at OSU which could be counterbalanced by a short not so good stint at Arkansas.

What I do worry/wonder about is will he be one of those defensive coaches that doesn't know how or is confounded on how to implement a decent offense. It's sort of the reverse I say about some offensive coaches who get so lost in their offensive machinations they forget about defense. I feel like some defensive coaches don't know how or can't implement a functioning offense by finding the right people. Charlie Strong's stint in Texas reminds of that.
 

Scarlet_Monster

All-Conference
Jan 8, 2011
6,164
4,234
0
I wouldn't say that. If it was just his OSU stint I'd say okay maybe but he did well at Wisconsin as DC too. Without that I would have been less sold on him with only two years at OSU which could be counterbalanced by a short not so good stint at Arkansas.

What I do worry/wonder about is will he be one of those defensive coaches that doesn't know how or is confounded on how to implement a decent offense. It's sort of the reverse I say about some offensive coaches who get so lost in their offensive machinations they forget about defense. I feel like some defensive coaches don't know how or can't implement a functioning offense by finding the right people. Charlie Strong's stint in Texas reminds of that.

The issue with Ash is he says he wants a certain offense, he brings in an unproven OC to run it, it fails badly. He panics, goes completely the opposite direction to bring in Kill who is all about ball control and zero excitement leading to no mistakes, but no big plays.

Chris Ash seems to be from the school that he thinks his defense is so great that his offense only needs to execute a few plays here or there to pull out a win.

He artificially shortens games so his defense doesn't give up 80 points.
 

Mr. Magoo1

Heisman
Nov 15, 2001
15,661
16,630
113
I'm a little surprised to see Indiana still with the starters in on O after the lightning delay, considering the score.

This is the most disappointing game of the season, by a country mile. The team needs to respond and fight for 60 minutes next week to wash this stink away.

The EMU game was equally as terrible. These two pathetic performances almost bookend our season.
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
The issue with Ash is he says he wants a certain offense, he brings in an unproven OC to run it, it fails badly. He panics, goes completely the opposite direction to bring in Kill who is all about ball control and zero excitement leading to no mistakes, but no big plays.

Chris Ash seems to be from the school that he thinks his defense is so great that his offense only needs to execute a few plays here or there to pull out a win.

He artificially shortens games so his defense doesn't give up 80 points.
I think he got shell shocked last year and that's why the reverse course. I wasn't high on DM but was open to him and wasn't high on Kill either but again open to him and thought he'd be better than DM.

I'm actually okay with the conservatism this year but I want to see identification and development of players on offense to make it work better and open up in the future. Will we open it up more? I suspect we will but will it be enough, I don't know and still question that. The thing is I don't want to see the same we have no qb or wrs can't get open year after year. It reminds me of the DBs always being young with Flood or the OL with Schiano and just that general mantra we're young over and over.

To some degree, you have to figure out workarounds for short term issues and at the same time finding longer term fixes.

I know the defense today wasn't good but I do think Ash can develop a decent defense and that's all we need IMO. I still wonder if we'll get a strong offense which IMO is the best avenue for teams lower on the totem pole to overachieve their perceived status on the college landscape. If we can't then I think it puts a cap on us below our potential as a program.
 

Scarlet_Monster

All-Conference
Jan 8, 2011
6,164
4,234
0
I think he got shell shocked last year and that's why the reverse course. I wasn't high on DM but was open to him and wasn't high on Kill either but again open to him and thought he'd be better than DM.

I'm actually okay with the conservatism this year but I want to see identification and development of players on offense to make it work better and open up in the future. Will we open it up more? I suspect we will but will it be enough, I don't know and still question that. The thing is I don't want to see the same we have no qb or wrs can't get open year after year. It reminds me of the DBs always being young with Flood or the OL with Schiano and just that general mantra we're young over and over.

To some degree, you have to figure out workarounds for short term issues and at the same time finding longer term fixes.

I know the defense today wasn't good but I do think Ash can develop a decent defense and that's all we need IMO. I still wonder if we'll get a strong offense which IMO is the best avenue for teams lower on the totem pole to overachieve their perceived status on the college landscape. If we can't then I think it puts a cap on us below our potential as a program.

Defense looked better with Wharton injured.

Cannot wait to see the young linebackers get major playing time next year. Ross Douglass out there, you're playing with 10 guys on defense.

Defense even from the get go had no fight in it. No one laying the hammer down, it was sad. The defense was playing two hand touch.

Ash and Neimann need to hold the players accountable in that situation. If it means berating an upperclassman and benching him in front of the defensive huddle YOU DO IT.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference