A New, Improved Steve at NJ.Com?

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
The latest article is so warm and fuzzy and cuddly to RU and casting stones at PSU, I had to do a double take.
He even looks different in his picture--what a smile:
 

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
Politi is a douche - always was, is, and will be. As soon as he has the opportunity to take a swipe, he will. He's just playing nice 'cause the new administration has cut out local press out of the loop.
 

eceres

Junior
Jun 24, 2013
738
313
0
I think Dugan (or one of them) called this the "honeymoon period". I expect first rough article on signing day, but only moderately rough.

They will get a pass until loss or bad news.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUJMM78

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,104
38,649
113
I think Dugan (or one of them) called this the "honeymoon period". I expect first rough article on signing day, but only moderately rough.

They will get a pass until loss or bad news.

I think Julie and Flood were clueless when it came to handling the media. I don't think Hobbs is at all naive about the NYC media market and will play hardball if the same antics happen now. I think HCCA is smart and will make adjustments if the old nonsense reappears.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scottsdaleal

Ataylor1989x

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2015
2,209
2,355
0
Where were you a reporter?

Four different places..
Where were you a reporter?

Other than the daily Targum? ;). Two major dailies, and eventually two major sports organizations.....I only covered RU while in school, though. I still don't want to be doxed by the people here that spew so much bile at the media, when the whole point is to ask questions.
 
Last edited:

mychaljohn

Junior
May 16, 2003
2,582
347
0
I think I know because that's what he tells me when I speak to him.
There are also great perks for the press who cover good programs
It gets old and boring for the press when you suck.
Good teams and players create all sorts of great stories,
I think that's what he'd tell you. You really don't get the impression from reading his work that he gets a perverse glee (which makes him contrarian to the "his job is better/easier if we win" logic) from our struggles?

Also, he's gone out of his way to claim that his writing style is divorced from how our program actually performs. He's claimed that it doesn't matter what he writes, that the general local media spin on our program has no impact on the public's perception of our program, and therefore, no impact on recruiting, donors, or general goodwill.

And if he believes that, even if he also believes that his job would be more fun when we win, then he can wrote whatever he wants, and it won't make an impact on us.

I say it's nonsense. I say you only need to follow him for a while to see that he gets a rise out of our issues, that he likes tweaking is, and that he's kind of a douche. You are too close to make a fair assessment. If a ballplayer were constantly womanizing, starting bar fights on road trips, and showing up hung over to games, but he was nice _to you_, he's still am awful person.
 
Sep 29, 2005
14,051
16,131
0
He is lulling all you guys to sleep. This weekend the honeymoon appears to be ending as we saw articles on the subsidy and how much RU spends on tutoring athletes.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
An occasional positive article doesn't mean Stevie loves RU.
But the posters saying he might have change only prove: some people look for love in all the wrong places [smoke]
 
Last edited:

Sreichert1

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2015
19
2
0
The Ledger is a tabloid, after 2 years of reading the BS from these RU beat writers, I don't bother anymore. Getting real unbiased opinions from any of them is like using the National Enquirer to pick your stocks.
 
Sep 27, 2006
20,274
23,340
0
How do you know this. I mean...how do you _really_ know?

@RutgersRaRa , myself and @demauroj had a long conversation with Politi, Duggan and Dunleavy over a few drinks in our hotel when we traveled to Ann Arbor. They were all pretty open about the fact that their job, as journalists, was to write articles that people are going to want to read. That being said, there was a lot of crap going on at RU in the past couple of years that, well, sadly mostly panned out the way their articles were saying it would.

they all, however, said that they would like nothing more than to write some good stuff about RU if it was out there. @demauroj and I challenged Politi to write a positive RU article and he ended up writing a great article on the fans who stick with this program no matter what, and he headlined demauroj as a guy who was amongst a few who traveled to all 12 games last year.
 

DanRU

Senior
Jun 9, 2008
262
423
63
The Ledger is a tabloid, after 2 years of reading the BS from these RU beat writers, I don't bother anymore. Getting real unbiased opinions from any of them is like using the National Enquirer to pick your stocks.

I agree the Ledger is nothing more than a tabloid anymore. Not just for sports, but all news. I stopped buying it years ago and rarely click on any NJ.com articles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUJEEPFAN

Ole Cabbagehead

All-American
Apr 21, 2011
8,075
6,323
0
@RutgersRaRa , myself and @demauroj had a long conversation with Politi, Duggan and Dunleavy over a few drinks in our hotel when we traveled to Ann Arbor. They were all pretty open about the fact that their job, as journalists, was to write articles that people are going to want to read. That being said, there was a lot of crap going on at RU in the past couple of years that, well, sadly mostly panned out the way their articles were saying it would.

they all, however, said that they would like nothing more than to write some good stuff about RU if it was out there. @demauroj and I challenged Politi to write a positive RU article and he ended up writing a great article on the fans who stick with this program no matter what, and he headlined demauroj as a guy who was amongst a few who traveled to all 12 games last year.

This issue with Politi et al. has never been about whether they liked RU or not, it has to do with integrity. Journalists don't want Rutgers to lose or win. They don't care. They want to be able to write interesting stories that people will read. In order to do that, they need news. If the team is winning big, that is news, and these guys will be happy to write about it. The problem with that is that top headline winning seasons are few and far between. At all other times, the salacious, scandalous "breaking news" is always going to outsell "Rutgers with a nice 7-5 win season; players looking forward to next year." Unless the team is awesome, the big story that will get them their clicks is always going to be negative.

That's reality. The problem with Politi and his ilk at nj.com is not even that they choose to focus on the negative. The tiger can't change his stripes. Its that they are regularly dishonest in doing so. That is why we hate them, that is why we boycott them. Because they have consistently misconstrued or exaggerated facts to make THEIR stories more successful, at the expense of OUR university. And they will do the same thing again as soon as they have a chance. Journalists without integrity care only about themselves. The truth is irrelevant. That is, IMO, unforgivable.
 

Ataylor1989x

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2015
2,209
2,355
0
I'm sorry , but this fixation on media is just a loser mentality. It's part of a toxic culture.

The media's job is simply to report, question and give context to things that are happening. Some people are way too emotionally invested in this to look at things rationally.

Let's say, for arguments sake, that Rutgers football somehow runs the table over the next year and just shocks the world and wins everything. Let's say that they find a way to do this with integrity. Let's say there are no off-field incidents or embarrassing episodes at all. These things are not implausible.

Of course, you'd get unprecedented positive coverage.....but the moment someone within nj.com writes about the arms race and levels of spending involved with college football again, many of you will go back to media conspiracy mode......when in fact, it's a valid subject to talk about in the context of modern society.

Tl;dr: if you're that emotionally invested that you need to go on media screeds all the time, you might want to do what I've done, and become obsessive about culture around a program instead of on-field success or external factors (such as the goings-on at rival programs or the media doing its job well or poorly).

The problem here is just that being an avid sports fan is so inherently dependent on having an externally motivated personality.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mikemarc

Ole Cabbagehead

All-American
Apr 21, 2011
8,075
6,323
0
I'm sorry , but this fixation on media is just a loser mentality. It's part of a toxic culture.

The media's job is simply to report, question and give context to things that are happening. Some people are way too emotionally invested in this to look at things rationally.

Let's say, for arguments sake, that Rutgers football somehow runs the table over the next year and just shocks the world and wins everything. Let's say that they find a way to do this with integrity. Let's say there are no off-field incidents or embarrassing episodes at all. These things are not implausible.

Of course, you'd get unprecedented positive coverage.....but the moment someone within nj.com writes about the arms race and levels of spending involved with college football again, many of you will go back to media conspiracy mode......when in fact, it's a valid subject to talk about in the context of modern society.
....

Except that already happened, and the Star Ledger ran an investigative piece into the "spending run amok" at the school that resulted in the ouster of our AD and did immeasurable damage to the school's reputation among the average disinterested NJ voter, who now think the taxpayers pay for Rutgers football and that Rutgers is wasting their money.

The only problem? Taxpayers do not pay for Rutgers football. Even granting that money is fungible, taxpayers at most pay for a tiny percentage of it (the real number if you take the whole budget into account is between 10 and 20 cents per taxpayer). Moreover, the spending was not run amok. The contract clauses in Schiano's contract were highly typical for college coaches, and had been previously reported on by the SL, without a hint of scandal. When this was pointed out to the SL, they deleted those articles from their archive. The stadium expansion was also very typical, and well justified.

The topic is only valid IF it is reported fairly and accurately. In the case of the SL, they uncovered nothing of note, and the knew it. But they didnt let that stop them from dragging our school through the mud with daily articles for several months, each piece rehashing the same loosely founded allegations as the last. People who think its okay should wake up. A huge part of the reason Rutgers does so lousy in Trenton is because of the campaigns waged against Rutgers by the SL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUJEEPFAN

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
I'm sorry , but this fixation on media is just a loser mentality. It's part of a toxic culture.

The media's job is simply to report, question and give context to things that are happening. Some people are way too emotionally invested in this to look at things rationally.

Let's say, for arguments sake, that Rutgers football somehow runs the table over the next year and just shocks the world and wins everything. Let's say that they find a way to do this with integrity. Let's say there are no off-field incidents or embarrassing episodes at all. These things are not implausible.

Of course, you'd get unprecedented positive coverage.....but the moment someone within nj.com writes about the arms race and levels of spending involved with college football again, many of you will go back to media conspiracy mode......when in fact, it's a valid subject to talk about in the context of modern society.

Tl;dr: if you're that emotionally invested that you need to go on media screeds all the time, you might want to do what I've done, and become obsessive about culture around a program instead of on-field success or external factors (such as the goings-on at rival programs or the media doing its job well or poorly).

The problem here is just that being an avid sports fan is so inherently dependent on having an externally motivated personality.
Sorry, all you've done is clearly laid out what the media should do and equally clearly demonstrate that Politi has done none of those things. Politi never reports. He never provides coverage with a balanced point of view, whereby a reader can determine for himself/herself whether it is positive or negative. People have often pointed out that Politi is not responsible for writing his 'article' titles; that his editor does this. Yet, the titles perfectly summarize his articles, which are full of half truths, because they are purposefully picked to portray issues in a negative light. There is absolutely nothing any of you can do to change my mind that to date, Politi has an agenda to portray RU Athletics in a negative light.
 

demauroj

All-Conference
Dec 23, 2004
42,545
1,941
113
Politi is a douche - always was, is, and will be. As soon as he has the opportunity to take a swipe, he will. He's just playing nice 'cause the new administration has cut out local press out of the loop.

Point out to me honesty where he was wrong in any of his articles. In most cases he wrote the truth before any of us (myself included) were ready to accept it.
After meeting him, actually having a conversation with him, and being the subject of one of his stories. I can honestly say he is a good guy and just tells it like it is in that typical NJ Snark that no one from NJ like reading when it is something they are passionate about.

It's no secret he though Flood and Julie weren't good for Rutgers, and if Ash didn't nail that opening presser he would probably have been all over him already.
The Honeymoon will end a little during Spring, but I think for the most part the media will give him a chance.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference