Engagaement Rings....advice needed

forestdepth

Redshirt
Feb 20, 2018
787
0
0
Ok guys. Looks like it will be happening this summer and I really need to find the best place to make the purchase. Haven't decided how much to spend yet. Was thinking 6k all in hopefully. I'm about and hour and a half from Atlanta and an hour and a half from Birmingham. Any advice?
 
Dec 3, 2008
4,034
379
83
Buy the diamond separately from a diamond broker to save some money and get a bigger diamond than what you thought you could afford.

I used bluenile.com and I was very pleased with the rock I bought.
 

Jeffreauxdawg

All-American
Dec 15, 2017
8,891
8,004
113
Ok guys. Looks like it will be happening this summer and I really need to find the best place to make the purchase. Haven't decided how much to spend yet. Was thinking 6k all in hopefully. I'm about and hour and a half from Atlanta and an hour and a half from Birmingham. Any advice?

Michael Scott says you may want to reconsider your budget.


 

msubrave

Redshirt
Nov 17, 2015
285
16
18
I second bluenile. Paid 4500 for diamond. Took it to local place for setting and he appraised it for 15k.
 

jdbulldog

Junior
Oct 27, 2007
2,594
368
83
Van Atkins in New Albany has good reputation. Albrittons in Jackson may be out of business now (they announced they were closing). If not you may have luck there. If you want an independent, try Johnny Sides in Kosciusko.
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,853
1,705
113
Do what I did

 

ababyatemydingo

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2008
4,151
3,164
113
Ok guys. Looks like it will be happening this summer and I really need to find the best place to make the purchase. Haven't decided how much to spend yet. Was thinking 6k all in hopefully. I'm about and hour and a half from Atlanta and an hour and a half from Birmingham. Any advice?


order your stone from Solomon Brothers
 

NWADog

Junior
Aug 16, 2014
757
228
43
I just bought one from Israel Diamond. They have a great website and sell them wholesale. I got a 1.2 karat emerald cut diamond with a halo of diamonds around it for $4,500 and it’s appraised at $9,000
 

NWADog

Junior
Aug 16, 2014
757
228
43
Also if you go this route and buy a diamond separately get one that has the lower number on the depth of the cut on the diamond because that’ll mean it’s a lot more surface area and makes it look even bigger than it actually is.
 

josebrown

All-Conference
Aug 4, 2008
3,279
1,400
113
I bought one from him...and sold it back to him later.. I basically rented it for a heavy sum...
 

Upyurs

Redshirt
Nov 24, 2017
453
0
0
An engagement ring is probably one of the most important things to a female. A place like this with a bunch of guys is probably not the best place for advice on this matter. If you care about this lady do not go cheap. This really isn’t about you but about her and what she wants and will be proud of. If you can’t afford what she wants probably best to save more money. Don’t go cheap and don’t let a “deal” be a priority in your search. No one is going to give away a diamond ring. Stay clear of websites that seem too good to be true because they probably are. There is so much more to it than size. There is clarity and color and quality of diamonds that make a huge difference. You don’t want your fiancée to have a big rock and it be off color, cloudy but you think you did good because the good ole boys on six pack told you they got a helluva deal on a 2 carat diamond on “diamonds.com”. Go to a reputable jeweler and talk with them. They will work with you on a good fit that works for you and something she will be proud of.
 

5049

Redshirt
Dec 3, 2017
700
0
0
An engagement ring is probably one of the most important things to a female.
That is the problem right there. If this is true of your girlfriend OP, re-think doing it

Divorce rate is high for a reason
 

msubrave

Redshirt
Nov 17, 2015
285
16
18
On bluenile you can sort by exact cut, clarity, color and everything else. They have literally tens of thousands to choose from(at least they did several years ago). Most local guys have limited supply so your stuck choosing between their few dozen.

I was somewhat skeptical buying online so that's why I had a local guy look at it after I bought it. Didn't tell him where I got it or how much paid and he appraised 10k more than I paid.
 
Jan 9, 2016
2,364
346
83
Call Tom Neville with The Source in Montgomery, AL. He's a great guy and a former Bulldog O lineman from the early 60's. Tom will take you step by step on what to look for and what not to look for in a diamond whether you purchase one from him or not. That's where I bought my wife's diamond and bought her setting elsewhere.

If you decide to go this route, DO NOT drive to Montgomery without making a call and setting an appointment first. Tom's place isn't a traditional jewelry store. He'll only see you by appointment and you'll have to be buzzed back through security to his office. Best of Luck!
 
Jun 2, 2013
112
22
18
I've had good luck with Blue Nile for diamond earrings and gemstones. They're worth a look. But if you want a can't miss option, just cut the BS and go to Tiffany in Atlanta. You'll pay a premium, but the quality is outstanding. And just the sight of the little blue box may melt your ladyfriend's brain.
 

Bulldog from Birth

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2007
2,562
1,169
113
I went with the same approach. Bought the diamond from Blue Nile. And then went shopping to lots of local stores to find the band she wanted. Very pleased with how it all turned out.

Don’t underestimate “Cut”. A very important C, at least for a Round diamond.
 

tatedog

Redshirt
Mar 28, 2015
8,739
0
0
Ok guys. Looks like it will be happening this summer and I really need to find the best place to make the purchase. Haven't decided how much to spend yet. Was thinking 6k all in hopefully. I'm about and hour and a half from Atlanta and an hour and a half from Birmingham. Any advice?

My advice: get a prenup.
 
Dec 3, 2008
4,034
379
83
An engagement ring is probably one of the most important things to a female. A place like this with a bunch of guys is probably not the best place for advice on this matter. If you care about this lady do not go cheap. This really isn’t about you but about her and what she wants and will be proud of. If you can’t afford what she wants probably best to save more money. Don’t go cheap and don’t let a “deal” be a priority in your search. No one is going to give away a diamond ring. Stay clear of websites that seem too good to be true because they probably are. There is so much more to it than size. There is clarity and color and quality of diamonds that make a huge difference. You don’t want your fiancée to have a big rock and it be off color, cloudy but you think you did good because the good ole boys on six pack told you they got a helluva deal on a 2 carat diamond on “diamonds.com”. Go to a reputable jeweler and talk with them. They will work with you on a good fit that works for you and something she will be proud of.


You really have no idea what you are talking about. Right now bluenile.com has over 100,000 diamonds to choose from. That’s a lot more than your local jeweler who is most likely having his 5th going out of business sale this month (looking at you Jerry Lake). You can narrow your search on bluenile by size, color, clarity and cut to get the perfect diamond.
 

Wizard.sixpack

Freshman
Sep 15, 2009
6,511
58
48
Don't drop a lot on this ring. If the price of the ring is a problem with her then perhaps you need to reconsider the engagement.
 

TobaccoDawg

Redshirt
Dec 18, 2011
66
0
0
Check our Brilliant Earth online. Similar to blue nile but a little more hipster. Ethically sourced diamonds (that was important to my fiancé) and huge selection. Then take it and get the setting/ring locally. Albrittons in Jackson is great (they’re building a new store across the street from highland village) and they’ll take good care of you. Be sure to get something GIA certified. And yes, cut is king. Good cut will make it look bigger.
 

Junction John

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2014
3,249
0
0
Albritton's is just moving across the street to their own new building.

Albrittons in Jackson may be out of business now (they announced they were closing). If not you may have luck there.

Just clearing up this rumor.
 

CEO2044

Senior
May 11, 2009
1,945
618
113
Just depending on her, you may want to take her ring shopping and figure out what she likes. Takes the element of complete surprise out, but many will appreciate getting to see different styles on their hand- what they think they want will change sometimes based on what it looks like on.
 

Jeffreauxdawg

All-American
Dec 15, 2017
8,891
8,004
113
Don't drop a lot on this ring. If the price of the ring is a problem with her then perhaps you need to reconsider the engagement.

If the price of the ring is a problem with you, odds are she will reconsider the marriage in a few years as you probably are too selfish to make her happy. Many a divorced man has a $50k pickup, a $5k yeti collection, $15k in guns, and an ex-wife with a cheap *** engagement ring.

If you struggle spending 2-3 months salary on what should be a 50+ year purchase, you are either not with the right woman or are financially unprepared to get married. It's unfortunate, but you and her will be judged by the ring. Her friends will be talking **** behind her back about the ring either way. Make sure it's out of jealousy. Go ahead and get the nicest ring you can. Remember, you are getting married, half of what you spend on it is her money anyway. Might as well go all out on the one item she will keep forever. Best investment you will ever make.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Recruiting 2027 OL Li'Marcus Jones flips back to Colorado from Mississippi State
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Kelley Jones named Bednarik Award Semifinalist
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Sam Purcell praises Mississippi State's offensive breakout: "The way they played at UT Martin was what I've been seeing in practice"
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 11 Preview: Auburn Players to Know
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting JUCO Intel: Top recruits taking mid-week, final officials before decision time