BJ Boston vs Malik Monk

Born2RokRupp

Heisman
Oct 16, 2006
19,689
26,092
0
If you made put me my chips on someone, I’ll take Boston. He has a more dynamic offensive game than Monk, and is longer which will help in traffic. His ball handling is elite. Plus Boston has showed he has that “in the zone” gear that made Monk dazzle here. Monk had ebbs of production, and for my money that counts for a lot. I’d bet by the time Boston leaves UK its not as interesting a debate as it is today. Just my take. Was a huge Monk fan, and still am- but I think Boston could be an NBA All-Star, that’s how skilled I think he is. I don’t see Monk getting there, especially after seeing his struggle with substances/distractions.
 

uk78_rivals88018

All-American
Feb 6, 2003
12,401
8,783
0
One had a great college year, the other zero to date. Typical, let's elevate our recruits to mythical proportions. I saw the Boston video and felt he should have a guy in front of him with hands up while practicing those shots. Let's hope he is better than Monk of course but expecatations are always like this with Kentucky fans preseason, and then after a month of real games there will be posts how he should not be leaving the bench with his poor play and turnovers.
 

Shaudylo

Heisman
Apr 2, 2011
11,552
26,012
112
Tough to say through high school I’d say most of the board including myself only see highlights of these guys . Probably a few that actually watch full games of these guys .

But if Boston is the scorer that Monk was in College we are in for a good year .
 

Born2RokRupp

Heisman
Oct 16, 2006
19,689
26,092
0
One had a great college year, the other zero to date. Typical, let's elevate our recruits to mythical proportions. I saw the Boston video and felt he should have a guy in front of him with hands up while practicing those shots. Let's hope he is better than Monk of course but expecatations are always like this with Kentucky fans preseason, and then after a month of real games there will be posts how he should not be leaving the bench with his poor play and turnovers.

Totally fair. Actually, the right answer. But man, I just can’t help myself with Boston. His game looks so damn polished to me, plus bulk and development here. Willing to back him.
 

Born2RokRupp

Heisman
Oct 16, 2006
19,689
26,092
0
When Boston pours in 47 against the eventual champs come talk to me.
One of, if not the best single game effort I’ve seen from a UK player in my time. Wasn’t around for the Goose, and Meeks wasn’t as big of a stage at UT....fair. Boston, to me, just has that ITness, though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EliteBlue

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,923
63,083
113
BJ Seems to be a better prospect as of now, but maybe I'm remembering that Monk's class wrong. I don't recall Monk being a game-changer, although he was close. BJ is one of the 3 or 4 guys in a class that some think is that type of game-changing player.
 

BlueBomb

Heisman
Apr 3, 2009
10,899
20,414
103
I don't even understand questions like this. One player just graduated high school. The other is in the NBA.

One player came within seven points of tying the most points in a game...in the history of our program...as a freshman. And the other...just graduated high school.
 

EastCoastYoungCat

All-Conference
Apr 29, 2020
1,187
1,385
0
Wait and see of course but I think we’re suffering from a little amnesia here. He scored over 20 points in a game 15 times, 30+ 3 games, and the 47 he dropped against UNC. Let’s not pump the brakes, but smash on them, to knock some pause back into some minds. We haven’t seen BJ play yet, I know he’ll be great but we can’t even say the roster is even set yet.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,923
63,083
113
When Boston pours in 47 against the eventual champs come talk to me.

That's really not fair. BJ could never score more than 20 in a game and still feasibly be a better player for us than Monk. Now, BJ will *likely* never have a single game performance like Monk.. but it's worth noting that no one has had a game like Monk since Jodie Meeks. It's rare.
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,102
88,967
98
Wait and see of course but I think we’re suffering from a little amnesia here. He scored over 20 points in a game 15 times, 30+ 3 games, and the 47 he dropped against UNC. Let’s not pump the brakes, but smash on them, to knock some pause back into some minds. We haven’t seen BJ play yet, I know he’ll be great but we can’t even say the roster is even set yet.

Monk scored 30+ points in a HALF three times.
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,102
88,967
98
That's really not fair. BJ could never score more than 20 in a game and still feasibly be a better player for us than Monk. Now, BJ will *likely* never have a single game performance like Monk.. but it's worth noting that no one has had a game like Monk since Jodie Meeks. It's rare.

I know but it was a really well-played post. You have to admit that.
 

Kennycat11

Heisman
Aug 2, 2006
8,249
18,690
113
I dont know who will have the better college career but Boston has better overall attributes coming out of high school. 4"-5" taller, elite ball handler, longer, i think both had a pretty complete scoring package. Monk probably better athlete. Monk just poured in the buckets while at UK. I could see Monk averaging more PPG but Boston averaging near that amount with more rebounds, blocks and better defensive statistics. Didn't monk go like 6 games in a row or something crazy were he didn't collect a single rebound????
 
Jan 30, 2018
16,155
24,636
0
Boston. I mean he hasn't done it in college yet, but I think he's gonna be special. Playing with Bronny and others they played the best of the best all year long and BJ looked like the best player on the court each game. I think he will be in his own category after this year.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,923
63,083
113
I know but it was a really well-played post. You have to admit that.

Hey I won't disagree.. that performance was other worldly.. and in some ways, better and more important than what Jodie Meeks did.

I'll also say this.. while BJ has a slightly higher ceiling.. he has a far lower floor. And what I mean is that we know how Monk played.. he was one of the.. what 30 best players that year? .. BJ might prove that he needs more time. I don't think that's the case, but we never know. I won't fault someone for taking the safe bet, which is Monk.
 

catsfanbgky

All-American
Oct 18, 2006
18,901
7,622
0
It was stated after the original post, both before they played a game at UK. But even just looking at their high school careers and not Monk knowing what we know and Boston just off the high school stats. Reason being, Monk in high school was a one man wrecking crew. he had the green light when he walked in the gym. Boston on the other hand, for most of and by some now, is not even thought to be the best player on his high school team. A lot of people considered Williams as the best player. Even if that was not a debate, their where several D1 players on Boston's team so he could not just come out every game and fire away and score 40 a night. At times he played second fiddle or deferred to Williams. With two great players like that on one team, it happens. There was times Williams deferred to Boston.
They where a stacked team (obviously)

Boston (5 star)
Z.Williams (5 star)
Amari Bailey (5 star) sophomore #6 overall for 2022
Terren Frank (4 star) signed with TCU
Harold Yu (3 star) Junior 7-3 center
Shy Odom - sophomore (high 3 star)
 

cats#1again

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2011
8,011
4,587
0
When Boston pours in 47 against the eventual champs come talk to me.
One game and basically hasn't been heard from since..
Look monk was a great college guard but he was no world beater. He was more or less a spot up shooter that never created his own shot. One major reason he's struggled for the past 3 seasons
 
  • Angry
Reactions: OleRupp

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,102
88,967
98
One game and basically hasn't been heard from since..
Look monk was a great college guard but he was no world beater. He was more or less a spot up shooter that never created his own shot. One major reason he's struggled for the past 3 seasons

Umm he scored 30 points in a half 3x and averaged more PPG than anyone we’ve had under Cal. He was an absolute stud.
 

DerekMcPwn

Heisman
Sep 13, 2016
5,937
19,655
0
As five others have said, it’s kind of a silly question because they’re such different players. Malik Monk was a pure scorer; that was his whole thing. He was undersized at his position, not a floor general, and not a great defender. But the dude could score. So asking “who is the better scorer” is like comparing Floyd Mayweather and Connor McGregor and asking “who is the better boxer?” Should be pretty obvious.

But Boston has every other advantage, and could easily be the better player of the two.
 

Yardeth

Heisman
Jan 2, 2007
13,583
17,894
67
Boston has a more complete game, he can score from anywhere. Monk more of a shooter and snowbirder.
 

bradscats

All-Conference
Mar 28, 2007
4,154
1,617
0
If Boston is going to be a better scorer, he will need to be the best Cal has had. If he is intact that, I really like the outlook for our season.
 

catsfanbgky

All-American
Oct 18, 2006
18,901
7,622
0
Highest scoring average under Cal, Jamal Murray disputes that. And I know it is splitting hairs, it was really amazing when I looked how close their stats where.

Murray - 20. ppg / 5.2 rpg. / 2.2 apg./ 45.5 2fg% / 40.3 3fg% / Eff%56 / per 22.7 / WS 6.1%

Monk - 19.8 ppg / 2.5 rpg / 2.3 apg / 45% 2fg% / 39.7 3fg% / eff% 54 / per 21.3 / ws 5.8%

Other than rebounds per game, you could throw a blanket over their stats. Now, you can say Murray did not have Fox and Bam that the defense had to account for so he had to work harder to get his, or you could turn it and say "Well Monk had to share with Bam and Fox and Murray had to score because his team did not have the studs. Before anyone says it, yes he had Ulis and he was great, but Tyler wasn't a superstar that commanded defensive double teams everywhere he went like Fox. To me that is the best debate, who was better Murray or Monk, as Boston and Monk are not the same. It would be like comparing Ray Allen to Tracy McGrady. Both great, but got to greatness by two very different styles.

For comparisons sake here are / where NBA comps for each player.

Monk - Lou Williams / Eric Gordon / CJ McCollum

Boston - Kevin Martin / Jeremy Lamb / Brandon Ingram
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,464
46,468
90
Hey I won't disagree.. that performance was other worldly.. and in some ways, better and more important than what Jodie Meeks did.

I'll also say this.. while BJ has a slightly higher ceiling.. he has a far lower floor. And what I mean is that we know how Monk played.. he was one of the.. what 30 best players that year? .. BJ might prove that he needs more time. I don't think that's the case, but we never know. I won't fault someone for taking the safe bet, which is Monk.

Monk won the Jerry West award as top shooting guard in the country. I think it’s safe to say he was well within the top 30.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball KSR GAMEDAY: Surely this week will be better, right?
  2. 02 KSR Women's Basketball KSR's top takeaways from another blowout Kentucky WBB win
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Ticket prices for Kentucky's game against Grambling State are a bad sign
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kentucky opens as an overwhelming favorite (again) in bounce-back opportunity
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky opens as underdog at Missouri in SEC finale