Maxey would be a superstar at point guard

TFCat11

Heisman
Mar 25, 2019
6,497
12,126
108
Hot Take: He’s not as good playing off the ball. So much more comfortable with the ball in his hands to start the offense. But we’ll never see it because Ashton has dreams.
I agree, he would play better running the offense. But Hagans wouldn’t be as good as the combo. So you play your combined strengths, and that’s what Cal is doing.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
Maxey is pretty good about driving and dishing

It would appear Cal believes that Maxey should be more involved.

I think its high risk. Maybe Cal believes that we won't go far unless Maxey brings his "A" game consistently to every game.

The good? Cal is having this discussion about Maxey
The bad? Its February and whether Maxey get its or not in the next 45 days, he won't be around next year either way.

would love to have this discussion about Maxey the first week of December, not February
 

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,732
87,984
113
The choreography among the three guards needs to be tightened a bit before the tournament. The notion that Hagans should be replaced at PG by Maxey is not fine-tuning a decently running machine to make it better. It is driving the car off the cliff. Maxey doesn't have near the in-game maturity or vision that Hagans has.
 

johnc17

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
665
1,050
0
Eeehhhhh debatable.

He doesn't have good pace and control needed to be an elite PG. Ashton can't shoot but but his pace with probing defenses and the ability to shift gears on a dime makes him elite. Tyrese doesn't show this ability yet
 

UK90

Heisman
Dec 30, 2007
31,460
27,816
0
Hot Take: He’s not as good playing off the ball. So much more comfortable with the ball in his hands to start the offense. But we’ll never see it because Ashton has dreams.

I totally disagree.

Maxey's biggest problems have been related to poor decision-making and getting tunnel-vision and playing out of control. And he has an awful case of Archie Goodwin disease where, instead of noticing and adjusting to where defenders are, he just goes barreling straight into them.

He also does not appear to have good passing vision. He frequently misses open teammates of the sort that Hagans always finds.

What has kept those weaknesses in check is the fact that Hagans is the primary ballhandler, decision-maker and distributor. If it was Maxey, we'd see way more turnovers and 2013 style chaos on offense.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: OHcatfan

catsfanbgky

All-American
Oct 18, 2006
18,901
7,622
0
Hot Take: He’s not as good playing off the ball. So much more comfortable with the ball in his hands to start the offense. But we’ll never see it because Ashton has dreams.

You can't even get a basketball take right. People ***** about Hagans 3.2 to's per game. Maxey averages 2.3 per game and does not handle the ball a third as much as Hagans. He would average over 5 to's per game if he was running the offense. Hagans' to / assist ratio is very good. He does average over 3 to's per game, but over 7 assist. Hagans has a 2.21 assist / to ratio, Maxey 1.26 assist / to ratio. If you are going to discredit Hagans for the to's, you have to compliment him for assist. He leads the SEC,6th nationally and 2nd in Power 5 conferences, so why would you want to change PG ? Dumb thinking.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
You can't even get a basketball take right. People ***** about Hagans 3.2 to's per game. Maxey averages 2.3 per game and does not handle the ball a third as much as Hagans. He would average over 5 to's per game if he was running the offense. Hagans' to / assist ratio is very good. He does average over 3 to's per game, but over 7 assist. Hagans has a 2.21 assist / to ratio, Maxey 1.26 assist / to ratio. If you are going to discredit Hagans for the to's, you have to compliment him for assist. He leads the SEC,6th nationally and 2nd in Power 5 conferences, so why would you want to change PG ? Dumb thinking.
a better crowd in Rupp would fix all that.........
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoeBeeHall

CatsPaws270

Heisman
Dec 7, 2015
25,469
66,600
113
I think he struggles when pressured....and he doesn't have the floor general mentality to make the right decision at this stage of his development...he can't handle high level defense.

Some people are saying he's like Archie....but he's more like Malik Monk. Monk was used to having the ball in his hands to create everything for himself...didn't like the catch and shoot or working off the ball. He had to work to find his shots.

It took Malik a bit of time...he came on hot and then hit a bit of a lower point in SEC play as he had to play tougher defense and the grind hit him. But then late in the season he found his shot. I think it will be similar.
 
Sep 13, 2003
23,905
33,655
113
Hagans is the best point guard on this team. Maxey makes too many mistakes to play that spot.

I agree. Simple and to the "point".:D

Maxey is not good enough at setting his teammates up or passing to open shooters to play the Point right now. He is great one-on-one attacking the basket and has a quick release from 3, but his court vision isn't great because he has a score first mentality, which is what Cal wants from him.

Ashton is one of the best PG's in the country and can be the very best if he can cut down on the dumb turnovers. It's the one thing he hasn't perfected, but I'm hopeful he will.
 

RalphDaltonFan

Heisman
Apr 3, 2002
60,395
41,937
113
Disagree. One of the issues with this team is out of the 3 PG's the only good passer is Hagans. He's not a great passer, he's good. Quickley is a Lou Williams college version type of player. Score. He's a horrendous passer, specifically in halfcourt. Maxey is improving on the lobs off his attacks late and think Cal's forced him to drive the ball/play through him late because he sees him as best bet to make a layup late in a game, where Ashton can never be trusted in any layup scenario.

Need 1 other guard to be able to create for others late--and Quickley can score in paint but anytime he passes it's brutal. Maxey is 2nd best and Hagans best, but Maxey is best finisher out of the 3 when he gets into the paint-best at drawing fouls. So Cal's forced this now knowing how he's going to play in March-which is painful for some of us but it's reality.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,957
63,169
113
It's too late to test that experiment. Maxey would never get up to speed quick enough and we'd take on several more losses trying to figure it out. Hagans is our guy for this year.

.. but to assume Maxey CAN'T be better is crazy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PPAT4LIFE

caneintally

Heisman
Oct 1, 2002
27,455
17,056
0
The disgruntled are really grasping for straws now as UK has reeled off 8 of 9 wins and Hagans keeps extending his 5+ assists a game streak as he sets his sights on UK's "ALL-TIME" single season assist mark.

Its really sad and pathetic.
This hits the nail on the head. UK is much worse when hagans isn't on the floor and maxey is running point . All the stats show this . Such a off base and silly take but drain usually lives up to his name and gets his takes from the bottom of the drain .
 

uk78_rivals88018

All-American
Feb 6, 2003
12,401
8,783
0
Worst take on a players current skills. Maxey did great at the end of the game on offense but also kiilled up for up to about 45 minutes of the 60 minute game (by clock). Cross court passes to no one, questionable shot selection, his overall passing was atrocious and the suggestion that the ball should be in his hands as a point guard is innane. His offense with the ball in his hands is good when he drives but that is not the role of a point guard. A shooting guard does not necessarily have to be an outside shooter. Also, the first half as I had posted at halftime, was a repeat of Evansville. We jacked up too many outside shots without working the ball at all it was that AAU ball style that has hurt this team on several occasions. Take the first open look and shoot, it's not a good offense especially for a team that isn't the best on the outside. That's why Cal yelled at Brooks as well near the end of the game. We were in a crucial time and he jacks up a lousy 3 when his outside shooting is suspect to begin with. Shot selection continues to be a problem for many on the team.
 

willyclyde

All-American
Feb 25, 2007
5,917
8,898
0
He couldn’t make anymore dumb decisions than hagans already does. He’s playing out of position and would be better at point guard is all I said and I stick by it. Leave it to raftards to spin it and get their feelings hurt lmao
 

KYWildCatsFan

Heisman
Aug 18, 2017
6,934
14,640
98
You're insane. Did you watch him try to pass the ball last night?

Maxey is great at taking his guy one on one and creating his own shot. He doesn't, however, have even close to the same court vision that Hagans has.

Hagans has his bad games. The entire team had one last night. But you're blind and crazy if you think we'd be better off with anybody else running the point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,332
0
Hot Take: He’s not as good playing off the ball. So much more comfortable with the ball in his hands to start the offense. But we’ll never see it because Ashton has dreams.
Ashton is better right now. Maxey will be great at PG at some point but he's still figuring things out right now. I'd rather have him at the 2 and run the offense through Hagans.

Right now more than anything Maxey needs to better understand what a good shot is and what isn't a good shot. Way too many forced shots. And since he's sporadically making them he can't use his own scoring ability much to draw the defense. He's not as good right now at setting others up for that reason.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football What happened on every Kentucky red zone possession against Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Stein Proud of Kentucky's Fight, but will not have a Loser's Mentality
  3. 03 KSR Football Instant Takeaways: Red zone miscues, porous pass defense help continue Kentucky's November losing streak
  4. 04 KSR Football Stein: Kentucky Must Finish Strong in the "Most Important Game of the Year"
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein says he "friggin' hates losing" in his postgame press conference